• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Competitive Super Smash Bros. Melee Discussion Thread

P

Pappasman

Member
Armada is inhuman. His ability to keep calm and clutch out every situation constantly impressive. And like usual, fox dittos between armada and leffen are always great.
 
F

FZZ

Banned
I think it's safe to say we are out of the Platinum age, and in a new age of Melee. The game/scene itself isn't growing at the rapid rate it did from 2013-2015, it's still growing of course but now its more steady and less exponential. On top of that the meta has stabilized, and players are more focused on refining their craft. Idk what this new era would be called tho.

Also honestly, Armada deserves his own documentary

This dude's level of dominance while the game is reaching its peak is mind boggling to me

Only uses Fox against: Puff, Leffen, and PPMD (whenever PP will return)

He uses Peach for every single other player on the planet. Peach. PEACH.

I don't think there are five gods anymore, well there still are but now its the five gods and Armada who I truly believe belongs in a tier of his own. Sure he will drop a set every now and then but its so rare, like below 50% rare.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nKzYWqkga74

I'm rewatching Episode 9 of the doc and I get to Prog's part where he says Mang0 never gave it his all and if he did he would definitely be the greatest of all time, and I can't help but think how silly that sounds now. I don't think Prog or anyone else during the time of the doc's release would have ever expected a reign and level of consistency and pure dominance from one player. Especially since Melee is the biggest it has ever been, and being played at the highest level of any eSport.

Idk Armada really is something special and even though I sometimes get tired of him winning, looking back on everything I think sooo many people will appreciate what he's doing, and how well he is doing it.

He's the GOAT
 
G

GamerJM

Banned
FZZ said:
I think it's safe to say we are out of the Platinum age, and in a new age of Melee. The game/scene itself isn't growing at the rapid rate it did from 2013-2015, it's still growing of course but now its more steady and less exponential. On top of that the meta has stabilized, and players are more focused on refining their craft. Idk what this new era would be called tho.

Also honestly, Armada deserves his own documentary

This dude's level of dominance while the game is reaching its peak is mind boggling to me

Only uses Fox against: Puff, Leffen, and PPMD (whenever PP will return)

He uses Peach for every single other player on the planet. Peach. PEACH.

I don't think there are five gods anymore, well there still are but now its the five gods and Armada who I truly believe belongs in a tier of his own. Sure he will drop a set every now and then but its so rare, like below 50% rare.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nKzYWqkga74

I'm rewatching Episode 9 of the doc and I get to Prog's part where he says Mang0 never gave it his all and if he did he would definitely be the greatest of all time, and I can't help but think how silly that sounds now. I don't think Prog or anyone else during the time of the doc's release would have ever expected a reign and level of consistency and pure dominance from one player. Especially since Melee is the biggest it has ever been, and being played at the highest level of any eSport.

Idk Armada really is something special and even though I sometimes get tired of him winning, looking back on everything I think sooo many people will appreciate what he's doing, and how well he is doing it.

He's the GOAT
Click to expand...

I think it's kind of hard to tell how fast we're growing or if we're growing at all at this point, I don't think we can really say for a little bit. Last year saw sub-super nationals or whatever they're called tournaments like Shine and Smash Con (I don't count those as supermajors, just regular majors) top numbers from the pre-2015 EVOs. But then Genesis 4 had less entrants than 3.

I'll be honest though I really think that the people who think Melee's just gonna keep growing and growing and become a bigger eSport are kinda delusional. It's not really that easy to get into if you're playing on a CRT and it's insanely hard to get good at, and we're not seeing any signs of support from Nintendo in terms of Melee HD.

I definitely agree on Armada though. He's on another level. A lot of the tournaments he lost in the past few years could have just as easily gone his way, whereas when he's on-point it's hard to see him losing in an alternate universe. So I honestly think the statistics (in terms of his win-rate) are kind of skewed by pure chance. What I mean by this is that if the sample size of tournaments was larger and top players could play at tournaments every day or so and wouldn't face any health problems or burnout because of this (obviously impossible, but hypothetical), then I think Armada would have an even higher win-rate against other gods than he does now.
 
Bakkus

Bakkus

Member
Armada has won every tournament I've ever attended, where he has also attended. He's incredible in every sense of the word.
 
L

LucidMomentum

Member
Also not only is [A]rmada incredibly consistent, but he's a pretty decent person too. There's not a lot of dirt on him from the past and his streams are pretty chill too.
 
L

LucidMomentum

Member
xezuru said:
First hour of Summit 3.5 and the gifs are already rolling in...

https://clips.twitch.tv/BlazingFitDragonHotPokket
Click to expand...

Some of the best stuff comes out of the training days as people arrive for a big event.

Also for Melee I'm pretty happy that I'm keeping up my kind of resolution to hit an out of town event once a month this year.

January through May are a lock, gotta see what I'll do in June before EVO in July.*

I'm not going 0-2, but I'm not really getting out of pools either. Gotta work on that.
 
C

chaosblade

Unconfirmed Member
Smashbox is going to be up on Kickstarter starting Wednesday.

I liked the idea, but I really think I'd rather have one that has actual analog instead of the digital+modifier buttons. Isn't that what B0XX is supposed to be? I see people talk about that but it's hard to actually find info on it.
 
X

xezuru

Member
Summit Spring 2017 has begun!

The introduction to the stream
Started off strong.

Streams: Beyond The Summit | Beyond The Summit 2
Youtube: Beyond the Summit - Smash
SmashGG: Schedule | Bracket | Shop

Event Winners:
Singles:
Armada..............................................
Doubles:
Armada, Mew2King .......................
Draft Crews:
L O S L E F F O S 2.0: Leffen, Hungrybox, Ice, HugS, Vish
Low-tier Iron Man:
Team Beer's Mango
Charades:
The Armadas: Armada, SFAT, Axe, Infinite Numbers, HomeMadeWaffles

Singles Pools were established:
Pool A: Armada, Infinite Numbers, Lucky, Westballz

Pool B: Hungrybox, S2J, PewPewU, Leffen

Pool C: Mango, Ice, SFAT, Plup

Pool D: Mew2King, HugS, ChuDat, Axe

Crews were established:
Team Beer: Mango, S2J, PewPewU, Lucky
Commentator Pick: Lovage

L O S L E F F O S 2.0: Leffen, Hungrybox, Ice, HugS
Commentator Pick: Vish

MEMETEME: Mew2King, Plup, Westballz, ChuDat
Commentator Pick: Toph

The Armadas: Armada, SFAT, Axe, Infinite Numbers
Commentator Pick: HomeMadeWaffles

Mafia:
Speed Mafia Round 1: VOD
Town: D1, Westballz, Mango, Toph, ChuDat
Mafia: Hungrybox
Winner:
Mafia - Hungrybox .......................................................................

Speed Mafia Round 2: VOD
Town: Axe, Zhu, Westballz, Hungrybox, Lucky
Mafia: Toph
Winner:
Mafia - Toph ........................................................................................................

Mafia Day 1: VOD
Town: Mango, ChuDat, Hungrybox (COP), Toph, Scar (Vigilante), Westballz, Zhu, Lucky, Lovage, HomeMadeWaffles, Axe, HugS (Medic)
Mafia: Phil, D1, Vish
Winner:
Town - Survivors: Lovage, HomeMadeWaffles, Axe, HugS (Medic)

Mafia Day 2:
Mafia Day 3:
 
C

chaosblade

Unconfirmed Member
Hugo was actually good at mafia. Smart dude, lot of respect.


And that saved by the bomb video is amazing.


Those stats are so cool.
 
Bakkus

Bakkus

Member
What a laughable match just now. lolm2k, lolchu.

Anth0ny said:
plup just 3-0'd mango


his sheik looks unstoppable
Click to expand...

Nah, He had big problems against SFAT. Couldn't for the life of me understand why Mango went Falco instead of Fox who obviously has a bigger advantage against her.
 
C

chaosblade

Unconfirmed Member
Axe's expressions after taking games off Mango, lol.

Can't believe he won that set. Mango looked worse and worse as the set went on, totally shook.
 
C

chaosblade

Unconfirmed Member
Wow, this mafia game is huge.


Mafia should win easy unless the players that draw it are awful.

Or not, Leffen with the god tier vigi shot before he died.



I was watching blind on game 2. I totally had the read on Mango faking cop and figured they got Ice right after the kill power dropped. He was acting different and it just felt like he pulled the whole thing out of his ass, going from "I've got juicy info" to "nah it's not so good, I'm just the damn cop (so plz don't kill me)." And then the mafia didn't kill the power role when they had a clear opportunity. If it was less sketchy in the first place I could see it being a 4th dimensional play by the mafia to make the town lynch the cop, but it was just the icing on the cake.

I thought the last one was Hbox and until he was out, since he was biting so hard on the fake cop. When they kept going after Crunch died I didn't really have any reads except Caitlin was probably town since Mango called her out and was 99% Mafia. I was kind of leaning Shab in the last round but it was like 51/49. Toss up between him and Lucky.
 
P

peter0611

Member
I'm rooting for Plup, but honestly at this point it doesn't matter. I JUST DON'T WANT ARMADA TO WIN AGAIN. Holy crap, it's getting so boring.
 
F

FZZ

Banned
Brehs this OP gonna need an update for the next thread

2x Evo champion. MLG champion. Simply put, Mango is the greatest to ever play the game. The results speak for themselves: since 2008 Mango has wrecked everyone in his path. While the other gods are certainly capable of taking sets, and even tournaments, off Mango, he always seems to find a way to bounce back. Will he make it a three peat this year?
Click to expand...

Armada is a fucking monster

and just witnessing this level of dominance is inspiring and frightening at the same time
 
G

GamerJM

Banned
FZZ said:
Brehs this OP gonna need an update for the next thread



Armada is a fucking monster

and just witnessing this level of dominance is inspiring and frightening at the same time
Click to expand...

It's needed to be updated for like two years lol

Honestly I don't think the "Era of the Five Gods," is over yet, Big House was only a few months ago, but Armada is clearly a tier above everyone else atm at the very least.
 
L

LucidMomentum

Member
[A]rmada is SS Tier. The other Melee pros are S tier.

Also I did okay at our Fresno regional, got this sick Turnip snipe:

https://clips.twitch.tv/NimbleSmokyRingCoolStoryBob

I got out of pools on loser's side in both Melee and Smash 4, but then lost right after top 32 in both games.

Was a fun time, apart from the fact that Smash.GG crashed for three hours on Saturday and the TO's freaked out so I helped run paper brackets even though I went to play and relax instead of my usual TO duties lol.

I did not play my best though, as I was helping TO. Not to john but I didn't even get to warm up due to the Smash.GG nonsense...
 
M

Mumei

Member
GamerJM said:
It's needed to be updated for like two years lol

Honestly I don't think the "Era of the Five Gods," is over yet, Big House was only a few months ago, but Armada is clearly a tier above everyone else atm at the very least.
Click to expand...

What is the qualification for being a "god" these days, now that we have a handful of non-gods capable of beating gods?
 
C

chaosblade

Unconfirmed Member
Mumei said:
What is the qualification for being a "god" these days, now that we have a handful of non-gods capable of beating gods?
Click to expand...

"Be able to take a set off Armada?"

History aside, it feels like there are 1-2 "gods" at this point and that is Armada and maybe Hbox. Mango, M2K, and Leffen are too inconsistent to be considered equal to those two (especially Armada). I'd put those three in the next tier down along with Plup, who seems to go fairly even with them but generally gets bodied by Hbox and Armada (and rarely loses to anyone aside from those 5).

Then a massive tier after that extending from basically 7-15.
 
G

GamerJM

Banned
chaosblade said:
"Be able to take a set off Armada?"
Click to expand...

+ Win a national tournament

It's getting more and more obvious that Plup should probably be in this tier but Armada is a huge hurdle for him because he seems unstoppable in the Sheik matchup. If he just played another top tier he'd probably be there by now.
 
C

chaosblade

Unconfirmed Member
GamerJM said:
+ Win a national tournament

It's getting more and more obvious that Plup should probably be in this tier but Armada is a huge hurdle for him because he seems unstoppable in the Sheik matchup. If he just played another top tier he'd probably be there by now.
Click to expand...

I'm waiting for the day he pulls out that Fox he's been working on against Armada. IIRC he mentioned transitioning to dual maining Sheik and Fox with the pocket/secondary Samus.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

After 200,000 Votes, Game Informer Readers Name Zelda: Ocarina of Time as the Greatest Game of All Time
Social Community 2 3 4
160
5K
SHA replied
Thoughts on the Smash Bros series?
2
67
2K
playsaves3 replied
Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl 2 | Review Thread
Analysis Review
4
889
BlackTron replied
  • Locked
Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl 2 | Review Thread
Analysis Review
2
698
Draugoth replied
  • Poll
Best Arcade sticks
27
866
Randall365 replied
Top Bottom