• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Cosmic horror, and the fear of the unknown

Status
Not open for further replies.

kingofrod

Member
Getting a fat Amazon cart from this thread, thanks to everyone for the myriad suggestions.

One question I have is where should I start with Laird Barron? It looks like he has quite a lot to choose from, and I'd prefer to start with one book. Is "Swift to Chase" a good starting point?

I haven't read Swift to Chase yet but I heard it's pretty good. I started with The Beautiful Thing that Awaits Us all, then read Occultation, and both of those are pretty awesome. I think "Procession of the Black Sloth" is in the Occultation book - that story alone is worth the price of admission.
 

Prurient

Banned
Very cool! I always said if the Cincinnati Bengals win a Super Bowl I'll get a tattoo, so...

How bad did that hurt on the inside of your arm like that? I think it looks awesome but I'm just imagining have to fill in all that black.

Honestly, it didn't really hurt at all. My butt hurt more from sitting in the chair for 4 hours! Forearm is one of the least painful places, you feel it a bit more at the wrist, and close to the crook of the arm. But overall it's just a kind of pinch that ebbs and flows in intensity, it's 100% bearable. I felt the solid black a little more, but again it's not some intense pain, and you'll probably always get vague answers because it's a bit hard to explain. Just find a good tattooist, do your research and it's fine.
 

HStallion

Now what's the next step in your master plan?
I watched that Laokun film from the second page and holy shit that was amazing stuff. The ending sequences were fucking insane in the best way possible.
 

Calamari41

41 > 38
I haven't read Swift to Chase yet but I heard it's pretty good. I started with The Beautiful Thing that Awaits Us all, then read Occultation, and both of those are pretty awesome. I think "Procession of the Black Sloth" is in the Occultation book - that story alone is worth the price of admission.

Thank you! I already have Swift to Chase on the way, but I will move on to Occultation right afterward on your recommendation.
 
Been thinking about Lovecraft's "Dreams in the Witch House" a lot lately.

Lovecraft pretty much dropped the ball with the quality of the tale, but reflecting on it, but the concept is rather fascinating. Lovecraft came up with the idea that the magic of witches is actually evil geometry that allows them to move between dimensions and space. Therefore: interdimensional satanism.
 

Screaming Meat

Unconfirmed Member
Been thinking about Lovecraft's "Dreams in the Witch House" a lot lately.

Lovecraft pretty much dropped the ball with the quality of the tale, but reflecting on it, but the concept is rather fascinating. Lovecraft came up with the idea that the magic of witches is actually evil geometry that allows them to move between dimensions and space. Therefore: interdimensional satanism.

That's cool!

Charles Stross does something similar in The Laundry Files. In short, eldritch abominations essentially exist inside The Mandelbrot Set. Or summink.
 

GAMEPROFF

Banned
Been thinking about Lovecraft's "Dreams in the Witch House" a lot lately.

Lovecraft pretty much dropped the ball with the quality of the tale, but reflecting on it, but the concept is rather fascinating. Lovecraft came up with the idea that the magic of witches is actually evil geometry that allows them to move between dimensions and space. Therefore: interdimensional satanism.

You can do magic when you are good with math is what I take from this post :D
 

Luminaire

Member
Been thinking about Lovecraft's "Dreams in the Witch House" a lot lately.

Lovecraft pretty much dropped the ball with the quality of the tale, but reflecting on it, but the concept is rather fascinating. Lovecraft came up with the idea that the magic of witches is actually evil geometry that allows them to move between dimensions and space. Therefore: interdimensional satanism.
Suddenly numbers stations became more terrifying.
 

Neat!

Someone needs to commission Santiago Caruso, one of my favorite illustrators, to illustrate an (english) volume of Lovecraft. He already illustrated the Dunwich Horror in Spanish.
OVuKHyp.jpg
 

HStallion

Now what's the next step in your master plan?
This is up on UK Netflix if anybody is interested. I wouldn't recommend it tbh. Although it does have Ron Pearlman innit.

I'm more amazed something like this exists at all. Lovecraft and his works are the opposite of easily digestable kid friendly schlock and that's not getting into the racism lol.
 

nel e nel

Member
From Beyond is the best.

Yessss!!!

Also, John Carpenter's Prince of Darkness.

Where do folks fall with Clive Barker? His Books of Blood series were great, and even though he delves into more typical Hell stuff, he often infuses it with ancient lore that is beyond human knowledge/comprehension.
 

Anung

Un Rama
I'm more amazed something like this exists at all. Lovecraft and his works are the opposite of easily digestable kid friendly schlock and that's not getting into the racism lol.

Rights are free so it's probably easier to cram Lovecraft into your children's movie than be creative.

I do think a stop motion Lovecraft film would be really cool tho.
 

JakeD

Member
Read The Willows because of this thread and loved it. One of my favorite short stories ever. Also checked out The Wendigo by the same author which was a bit more "cosmic" than I would have expected. Liked that a lot also.

Read The Fisherman because of this thread as well. Liked it but IMO it's best moments were the more traditional type horror.
 

GhaleonEB

Member
I picked up The Fisherman from Amazon a couple weeks ago, and started it today. I was really enjoying it, but am now struggling to keep going. Structural spoilers from four chapters in.
The book starts out as a story being retold after it's happened, a bit clumsily. But it's a good story and I'm starting to get pulled in. Then Part 2 starts - and looking ahead, that part takes up 2/3 of the book. And it's an account of a story someone in a diner told the main characters about the place they are about to go, rather than the story of what happens to them when they get there. Only after that diner tale is recapped does the story with the characters seem to resume, for maybe 1/4 of the book's total pages.

I completely lost interest a few pages into the second part, because I want to follow the main characters I've started to get invested in, not this giant diversion.
Really bummed. I've it aside for now.

Week later edit: donating it to the library. Really awful structure and the story was constantly defusing itself.
 

nolips

Member
Picked up The Fisherman because of this thread. Absolutely loved it. Not quite cosmic horror, but not quite traditional horror either. The structure of the book reminded me of House of Leaves.
 
My dad saw the movie The Void last night. It was his first introduction to Lovecraftian horror. Now I got to give him a primer on what that is because he had no idea what happened in that movie
 
Hey just, I'm looking at a couple complete Lovecraft compendiums to get, and I was wondering if anybody could tell me whether or not they use the S.T. Joshi remastered versions, since I can't find the information on Amazon.

They are The New Annotated H. P. Lovecraft, with notes by Leslie S. Klinger and The Complete Fiction of H. P. Lovecraft, published by Race Point Publishing and part of the Knickerbocker classics series.

Here are the Amazon pages for the first one and the second one

I was wondering if anyone, if they had the books, could check, or recommend me any that uses the Joshi versions.
 

HStallion

Now what's the next step in your master plan?
ka1PCHN_d.jpg


Del Toro had a show where he had a bunch of items and such on display including a model of the giant blind penguins from his At The Mountains of Madness adaptation that never came to be.
 

Jeff-DSA

Member
Just finished The Fisherman and checked to see if GAF had any talk going on about it. Looks like this thread just started me down a new rabbit hole.

I really enjoyed The Fisherman. I wish there was a bit more meat on either side of the "other" story in there, but it was a great book. It really does a great job slowly building up and layering in the horror.

I read this coming off of the Troop and I prefer The Fisherman quite a bit in regards to the horror stuff, though I've heard The Deep is more of a genre match. I'll have to look into it.
 

Luminaire

Member
So I've been listening to the Dark Hall Press Cosmic Horror audiobook. It's been incredibly frustrating. Some stories start off great, only to have literally no ending or get so far up their own ass and destroy their own story by stopping dead center.
 

HStallion

Now what's the next step in your master plan?
So I've been listening to the Dark Hall Press Cosmic Horror audiobook. It's been incredibly frustrating. Some stories start off great, only to have literally no ending or get so far up their own ass and destroy their own story by stopping dead center.

In my opinion like 90 percent of people who try Lovecraftian or cosmic fiction don't know what they're doing. I used to buy collections of these types of stories and the huge majority were just reusing the already tired tropes of insanity, weird names, tentacle monsters etc.
 
Just finished The Fisherman and checked to see if GAF had any talk going on about it. Looks like this thread just started me down a new rabbit hole.

I really enjoyed The Fisherman. I wish there was a bit more meat on either side of the "other" story in there, but it was a great book. It really does a great job slowly building up and layering in the horror.

I read this coming off of the Troop and I prefer The Fisherman quite a bit in regards to the horror stuff, though I've heard The Deep is more of a genre match. I'll have to look into it.
Yeah, The Troop isn't cosmic horror or Lovecraftian. But The Deep is a better match for this thread
 

Truant

Member
Besides Lovecraft's own work, the only decent recommendations worth checking out in this thread seems to be The Deep and The Fisherman? Anything else I should get?
 

Luminaire

Member
In my opinion like 90 percent of people who try Lovecraftian or cosmic fiction don't know what they're doing. I used to buy collections of these types of stories and the huge majority were just reusing the already tired tropes of insanity, weird names, tentacle monsters etc.
For real. I know cosmic horror and lovecraftian fiction expect you to use your imagination or struggle to describe that which cannot described, but this collection is ridiculous. its more like they're writing settings for a tabletop game and expect you to write/play the rest.
 

Jeff-DSA

Member
Started The Deep today. Looking for more in the genre outside of short stories or novellas, it really gets hard to find much. I suspect a lot of it has to do with how hard it is to write in the genre well, but I'm pretty shocked at how few the number of recommendations turn up when you start asking around for novels.
 

Jackpot

Banned
What are some good modern cosmic horror novels? The equivalent of issue #1 of Neonomicon, JDATE without the comedy, or Cabin in the Woods?

Tried the Laundry Files and ditched it for being terminally unfunny. Looking to avoid short story collections.
 
What are some good modern cosmic horror novels? The equivalent of issue #1 of Neonomicon, JDATE without the comedy, or Cabin in the Woods?

Tried the Laundry Files and ditched it for being terminally unfunny. Looking to avoid short story collections.
A bunch was recommended above
 
So I've read a bunch of Philip Acassi lately. Good stuff. What else should I read to to my 5 year old at bedtime?

(j/k about the 5 year old part...he's actually 4)
 
So I've been listening to the Dark Hall Press Cosmic Horror audiobook. It's been incredibly frustrating. Some stories start off great, only to have literally no ending or get so far up their own ass and destroy their own story by stopping dead center.

Looking up this anthology... Seems like Lovecraft pastiches by unknown amateur authors - I've never heard of any of these names and I've been scraping the bottom of the barrel for this stuff for a while (not necessarily bad, there is plenty of unknown talent). But I would expect some mediocre writing for sure.

In my opinion like 90 percent of people who try Lovecraftian or cosmic fiction don't know what they're doing. I used to buy collections of these types of stories and the huge majority were just reusing the already tired tropes of insanity, weird names, tentacle monsters etc.

Sounds like 90% of what you've been reading is your typical gimmicky Lovecraft pastiche schlock. This stuff has always existed even since he was alive even - but nowadays there's a lot more of it since Lovecraft popularity and fascination has exploded and there's money to be made on anything tied to his namesake. There's a certain breed of authors writing uninspired, tropey material that's sold on mostly its connection to Lovecraft mythos fanaticism alone, to the least common denominator of "weird fiction" fans, so to speak.

A good rule of thumb is to be wary of anything with heavy-handed use of buzzwords in the title: Lovecraft, Cthulhu, Necronomicon, Eldritch, etc.

Beyond of this specific demographic, there is no shortage of genuinely talented authors who form a community of modern weird fiction practitioners who owe a lot to Lovecraft among others, but don't write exclusively Lovecraft mythos pastiches. I'm talking about Laird Barron, Simon Strantzas, Jeff Vandermeer, John Langan, Caitlin R Kiernan, Gemma Files, Richard Gavin, Jon Padgett, Wilum Pugmire, Livia Llewellyn, etc, etc. All very respected authors by weird fiction enthusiasts beyond Lovecraft fans.
 

HStallion

Now what's the next step in your master plan?
Sounds like 90% of what you've been reading is your typical gimmicky Lovecraft pastiche schlock. This stuff has always existed even since he was alive even - but nowadays there's a lot more of it since Lovecraft popularity and fascination has exploded and there's money to be made on anything tied to his namesake. There's a certain breed of authors writing uninspired, tropey material that's sold on mostly its connection to Lovecraft mythos fanaticism alone, to the least common denominator of "weird fiction" fans, so to speak.

A good rule of thumb is to be wary of anything with heavy-handed use of buzzwords in the title: Lovecraft, Cthulhu, Necronomicon, Eldritch, etc.

Beyond of this specific demographic, there is no shortage of genuinely talented authors who form a community of modern weird fiction practitioners who owe a lot to Lovecraft among others, but don't write exclusively Lovecraft mythos pastiches. I'm talking about Laird Barron, Simon Strantzas, Jeff Vandermeer, John Langan, Caitlin R Kiernan, Gemma Files, Richard Gavin, Jon Padgett, Wilum Pugmire, Livia Llewellyn, etc, etc. All very respected authors by weird fiction enthusiasts beyond Lovecraft fans.

I don't care for many of these authors works either like Vandermeer and his Southern Reach trilogy which I was no fan of. China Mieville does a great job with his writing and one of the few who can pull off decent cosmic horror and weird fiction.
 
I don't care for many of these authors works either like Vandermeer and his Southern Reach trilogy which I was no fan of. China Mieville does a great job with his writing and one of the few who can pull off decent cosmic horror and weird fiction.

Well I'm not especially a fan either of Vandermeer either but he's a well respected author who doesn't write derivative schlock. The rest absolutely know how to write. For an older generation of writers, Thomas Ligotti, Ramsey Campbell and TED Klein have done Lovecraftian horror extraordinarily well.
 

Luminaire

Member
Looking up this anthology... Seems like Lovecraft pastiches by unknown amateur authors - I've never heard of any of these names and I've been scraping the bottom of the barrel for this stuff for a while (not necessarily bad, there is plenty of unknown talent). But I would expect some mediocre writing for sure.
I can't explain how bad it is. I'm getting actively irritated/upset/buttangry at some of these stories. There's one story that uses the word Yellow maybe 19.2billion times (possibly exagerration). One story has literally ended in the middle of itself (Imagine if the protags of Mountains of Madness never went back to camp and instead went to go get a glass of whiskey and that was it, skipping the entirety of the story.) Another ended as if the person just saw the Soprano's series finale. I'm about halfway through it and pushing through because I accidentally spent real cashmoney instead of my audible credit on it.

I guess I'm more frustrated with it being themes that I love but done so poorly. With cosmic horror, so few get it right. These authors can write for sure, they just can't tell a good story. I suppose I'll come back and scream about one of the stories being good if there is one, but my hopes are begrudgingly low. :(
 
I can't explain how bad it is. I'm getting actively irritated/upset/buttangry at some of these stories. There's one story that uses the word Yellow maybe 19.2billion times (possibly exagerration). One story has literally ended in the middle of itself (Imagine if the protags of Mountains of Madness never went back to camp and instead went to go get a glass of whiskey and that was it, skipping the entirety of the story.) Another ended as if the person just saw the Soprano's series finale. I'm about halfway through it and pushing through because I accidentally spent real cashmoney instead of my audible credit on it.

I guess I'm more frustrated with it being themes that I love but done so poorly. With cosmic horror, so few get it right. These authors can write for sure, they just can't tell a good story. I suppose I'll come back and scream about one of the stories being good if there is one, but my hopes are begrudgingly low. :(

Maybe it's meta-cosmic horror and the pain they're inflicting on you is the real point :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom