• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Rose McGowan: Ben Affleck is Lying, he knew about Weinstein raping me and other women

Linkura

Member
You know, that leaked tape story really makes my blood boil.

In 2015, Ambra Battilana Gutierrez went to the police after she was sexually harrassed by Weinstein, so they put a wiretap on her to gather evidence of foul play. After she returned to Weinstein and recorded the tape, the police got hold of the tape and sent it off to the DA.

It got dropped.

When we have cases where women have proof and even go to the police, the system fails them, yet some people still wonder "why many women don't speak out"?

Sometimes, I weep for this world.
Same DA who dropped the case with the Trump kids. Dude is corrupt as fuck.
 
Are we really going to act like most famous actors didn't know this was going on? They continued to work and publicly speak highly of him. Everything that's coming out with this story should be pretty clear that Affleck wasn't the only one that didn't speak up.
 

robochimp

Member
I'm not sure what Affleck is supposedly lying about here. Where does it say he didn't know what had happened?

His intention is to portray that he is shocked at the accusations. When he's known about them for a long time. Sure he's dancing around with words giving himself wiggle room in regards to knowing full well what was going on, but it's fair to call him a liar.
 

ArtHands

Thinks buying more servers can fix a bad patch
I'm not sure what Affleck is supposedly lying about here. Where does it say he didn't know what had happened?

He said all of us should condemn the behavior, when he's the one keeping silence and not exposing it despite knowing it.

If the accusation here is true, Ben Affleck is seriously a POS human.
 

FiggyCal

Banned
What is it a person who hears about this stuff from a victim who doesn't want it known supposed to do?

She was paid $100,000 (assumedly hush money though the article skilfully leaves out what the money was for) after the episode in the hotel, so likely more than sexual harassment?

100,000 is really not that much money.
 
Like the stuff with Nelly, how can we be 100% sure she is telling the truth? I hate to jump to conclusions and just condemn Affleck right there without having done any research of my own, you know, actually knowing what I'm talking about.
 

Ross61

Member
Like the stuff with Nelly, how can we be 100% sure she is telling the truth? I hate to jump to conclusions and just condemn Affleck right there without having done any research of my own, you know, actually knowing what I'm talking about.
There is a video. It doesn’t show clearly what she’s describing but it’s cut in a way that you can’t tell so you can only go by her description of the event.
 

jayhawker

Member
Like the stuff with Nelly, how can we be 100% sure she is telling the truth? I hate to jump to conclusions and just condemn Affleck right there without having done any research of my own, you know, actually knowing what I'm talking about.

She has nothing to gain from accusing Affleck here. Affleck has a lot to gain by convincing people he didn't know. It makes no sense to give Affleck the benefit of the doubt instead of McGowan.
 

Sunster

Member
Like the stuff with Nelly, how can we be 100% sure she is telling the truth? I hate to jump to conclusions and just condemn Affleck right there without having done any research of my own, you know, actually knowing what I'm talking about.

what does she gain from lying?
 
There is a video. It doesn’t show clearly what she’s describing but it’s cut in a way that you can’t tell so you can only go by her description of the event.

I see. Well I'm sure this won't be the last we've heard of it.

She has nothing to gain from accusing Affleck here. Affleck has a lot to gain by convincing people he didn't know. It makes no sense to give Affleck the benefit of the doubt instead of McGowan.

what does she gain from lying?

I guess you guys have a point. I have to admit I'm completely new to this news and I don't fully keep up with all the updates. Now that we're on this subject anyway, how did all of this start? Why did it take this long for this horrible news to come out, for these women to come forward?

And what about Matt Damon? Always thought that was a damn stand up dude, he's in on this as well then?

A while ago I saw some videos on YouTube about the allegedly sickening things happening in the music industry as well, and in this case it was Hiphop. I laughed at a lot of things because they just sounded impossible to me, because you know, there are plenty of absurd conspiracy theory videos out there, but I guess this just shows never say never.
 
I've read the statement a couple times and honestly don't get how this got overblown. We don't know what he knows or how detailed that conversation even went.

Sure he could have said he knew something but who the fuck are we to have him admit stuff like that?
 
Like the stuff with Nelly, how can we be 100% sure she is telling the truth? I hate to jump to conclusions and just condemn Affleck right there without having done any research of my own, you know, actually knowing what I'm talking about.

I wouldn't bother condemning him based on he said/she said. When someone is proven without a doubt to have done/said something worthy of condemning, sure. But we who are looking at this from a distance really don't have to personally engage us in every single part of this mess.

Sometimes it's better to acknowledge that not every battle is yours to take.
 

Sunster

Member
I see. Well I'm sure this won't be the last we've heard of it.





I guess you guys have a point. I have to admit I'm completely new to this news and I don't fully keep up with all the updates. Now that we're on this subject anyway, how did all of this start? Why did it take this long for this horrible news to come out, for these women to come forward?

And what about Matt Damon? Always thought that was a damn stand up dude, he's in on this as well then?

A while ago I saw some videos on YouTube about the allegedly sickening things happening in the music industry as well, and in this case it was Hiphop. I laughed at a lot of things because they just sounded impossible to me, because you know, there are plenty of absurd conspiracy theory videos out there, but I guess this just shows never say never.

He is a very powerful man who can end or cripple you career. He knows this, that makes him a predator. These people didn't imagine other victims, they assumed they were alone. What could they alone do against him? what could they lose by speaking out? history says they probably will be labeled a liar and lose everything.
 
I wouldn't bother condemning him based on he said/she said. When someone is proven without a doubt to have done/said something worthy of condemning, sure. But we who are looking at this from a distance really don't have to personally engage us in every single part of this mess.

Sometimes it's better to acknowledge that not every battle is yours to take.

Well said man. That's very true as well. But goddamn what a mess this has become. It does make you wonder what else happens there, not talking about Affleck but Weinstein.

He is a very powerful man who can end or cripple you career. He knows this, that makes him a predator. These people didn't imagine other victims, they assumed they were alone. What could they alone do against him? what could they lose by speaking out? history says they probably will be labeled a liar and lose everything.

I didn't think of it that way but it does make sense. So how did all of this got out into the public recently? One woman decided it was time to step up and reveal it? Genuine question because I haven't had the time to really keep up with it and how it all started.

But I am interested in reading up more on this, so what usually is a credible source that mostly gives facts and certainly no tabloid trash?
 
For everyone that's upset specifically about Ben Affleck because "he knew and didn't do anything", I hope you feel the same way about Brad Pitt, who has confirmed that he's known at least one story for over 20 years (he confirmed Paltrow's story, and that would have taken place in the mid 90s), was married to another victim in Jolie (and I wouldn't be shocked if Jennifer Aniston had a story to tell as well), and all he did was to tell Harvey not to touch Paltrow (which in the grand scheme of things is about as effective as Ben's "stop doing that", and even Paltrow says that after the incident he was still verbally abusive).
 

ArtHands

Thinks buying more servers can fix a bad patch
For everyone that's upset specifically about Ben Affleck because "he knew and didn't do anything", I hope you feel the same way about Brad Pitt, who has confirmed that he's known at least one story for over 20 years (he confirmed Paltrow's story, and that would have taken place in the mid 90s), was married to another victim in Jolie (and I wouldn't be shocked if Jennifer Aniston had a story to tell as well), and all he did was to tell Harvey not to touch Paltrow (which in the grand scheme of things is about as effective as Ben's "stop doing that", and even Paltrow says that after the incident he was still verbally abusive).

This thread is not about Brad Pitt though. Lets refocus on Ben Affleck.
 
For everyone that's upset specifically about Ben Affleck because "he knew and didn't do anything", I hope you feel the same way about Brad Pitt, who has confirmed that he's known at least one story for over 20 years (he confirmed Paltrow's story, and that would have taken place in the mid 90s), was married to another victim in Jolie (and I wouldn't be shocked if Jennifer Aniston had a story to tell as well), and all he did was to tell Harvey not to touch Paltrow (which in the grand scheme of things is about as effective as Ben's "stop doing that", and even Paltrow says that after the incident he was still verbally abusive).

Pitt is not pretending it's a shock and is not closely associated with him like affleck
 
It seems pretty clear most people were completely unaware of actual assault and rape. I mean you don't think someone like Meryl Streep would have spoken out before now if it was really so open?

Joke post? You realize you're talking about someone who publicly worships Weinstein and flew out of her seat to give a standing ovation to a child rapist, right?

Streep is Hollywood personified.
 

Sunster

Member
Well said man. That's very true as well. But goddamn what a mess this has become. It does make you wonder what else happens there, not talking about Affleck but Weinstein.



I didn't think of it that way but it does make sense. So how did all of this got out into the public recently? One woman decided it was time to step up and reveal it? Genuine question because I haven't had the time to really keep up with it and how it all started.

But I am interested in reading up more on this, so what usually is a credible source that mostly gives facts and certainly no tabloid trash?

It always starts with one victim coming forward. That is why it is more important to believe a potential victim than to assume lie and protect a possible predator. All these #skeptics are the reason women don't come forward. Society is more concerned with the slight possibility of a fake accusation than the vast majority which are real.
 
Pitt is not pretending it's a shock and is not closely associated with him like affleck

I do agree that there are things to be mad at him about (the wishy-washy statement, this TRL incident, Casey), just that "he knew and didn't do anything" isn't a particularly great one.

Edit: And through Tarantino, Pitt's starred in a Weinstein movie more recently than Ben has, I believe.
 

xBladeM6x

Member
You mean like the victims spoke up about it? There’s a reason they didn’t. And a reason he didn’t. It was pointed out in the Terry Crews tweets. “Do you like your paycheck? Do you like having work? Do you like being ostracized from all of that?”

The self righteousness on display is pathetic. It’s super easy to sit here and criticize people while we have absolutely nothing to lose. It’s another thing to go out of work permanently because you stuck your neck out for a friend, were 100% in the right, but their lawyers were bigger than your lawyers and now you’re selling used cars in Reseda.

This sucks. Weinstein’s out of a job and hopefully the worst for him is yet to come. But the people who “stood by and did nothing” did so for the same reasons the victims did nothing. The same reason these fuckers keep getting away with it. Because they are powerful and with a phone call you lose the part or don’t work again. Morals are sacred, but so is eating.
The most sensible post on the entire forum.
 
I mean, he never said shit about Cassey. This ain't surprising at all.

This could be a career killer.

It casts a suspicion on all who are super close to him.

I hope Tarantino was clueless in all of this.
There is no way Tarantino was clueless about this. He's even closer to Weinstein than Affleck and Damon. Same goes for Kevin Smith.
 
The most sensible post on the entire forum.

That is actually a damn good post yeah. It's very easy indeed to sit behind our computers and judge these folks. But I do wonder at the same time where we draw the line. I mean do we pardon everyone that was close to Weinstein and that didn't come forward? It's a goddamn tough subject and absolutely horrible.
 

D4Danger

Unconfirmed Member
I dunno, but here she is giving a standing ovation to a convicted child rapist:
QCy07Fd.jpg

every time this comes up I always laugh at Nic Cage. He has no idea what's going on.
 
For everyone that's upset specifically about Ben Affleck because "he knew and didn't do anything", I hope you feel the same way about Brad Pitt, who has confirmed that he's known at least one story for over 20 years (he confirmed Paltrow's story, and that would have taken place in the mid 90s), was married to another victim in Jolie (and I wouldn't be shocked if Jennifer Aniston had a story to tell as well), and all he did was to tell Harvey not to touch Paltrow (which in the grand scheme of things is about as effective as Ben's "stop doing that", and even Paltrow says that after the incident he was still verbally abusive).

We'd have to know the context of the situation and if Paltrow asked Brad not to come forward or do more.

Clearly, many of the victims didn't want this to come to light and nobody has a right to tell them how to proceed. For all we know, Brad was respecting their wishes.
 

Cybit

FGC Waterboy
Based on what we know, it seems like Harvey's preferences were younger women, and women who were new to Hollywood. Which means he could easily have hidden his "true" self from Meryl, because she wasn't his type. Also, I'll post what George Clooney said again:

I mean, the giant gaping hole in the "everyone knew the full extent" theory is that Obama sent his teenage daughter to intern for the guy. The guy who had the CIA, FBI, and NSA on call didn't know the full extent.
 

Earth

Banned
This could be a career killer.

It casts a suspicion on all who are super close to him.

I hope Tarantino was clueless in all of this.

This is kind of relevant.

Harvey Weinstein said:
I remember when I took Quentin Tarantino with me to a very private screening of the documentary Roman Polanski: Wanted and Desired, which shows some of the legal irregularities of his case.

I was involved by the film, and it was an amazing experience to see people weep at the end of it. Warren Beatty and Robert Evans were there, too, and you could feel the sense of injustice from these people who are part of Polanski's life. They know that, at heart, he is a humanist.

EDIT, Polanski was never put behind bars for that?

He was sentenced but fled prior and went into hiding.
 

Enduin

No bald cap? Lies!
Jesus christ. But I'm assuming he wasn't aware of the rape I hope? Otherwise you'd think he would have been caught as well. I had no idea about this. :(

EDIT, Polanski was never put behind bars for that?

Polanski fled the country in 1978 before sentencing and has been a fugitive ever since living in Europe. But despite that he's still continued to direct major motion pictures, like The Pianist which won him best picture and best director, with massive movies stars who have bent over backwards to film in locations that won't extradite him to the US and throw him in jail.
 

Rooster12

Member
idk who I can trust anymore in Hollywood

Do you work in Hollywood? I'm guessing you probably don't.

Then maybe you shouldn't blindly jump on these actor's nuts. Enjoy their movies, but outside of that don't invest too much time in to whatever they do.
 
Jesus christ. But I'm assuming he wasn't aware of the rape I hope? Otherwise you'd think he would have been caught as well. I had no idea about this. :(

EDIT, Polanski was never put behind bars for that?

Everyone was aware at the time of that picture. Harvey Weinstein himself has infamously called for his release. Predators feel for other predators, I suppose. You should probably read this to see how many other actors/directors you respect have come to the vigorous defense of this piece of shit. Be under no illusions about this: Hollywood is garbage - for every Keanu Reeves there are ten Donald Trumps and Harvey Weinsteins.
 
He skipped out to France before the trial started.

Good lord. And France couldn't just send him back?

This reminds me of a thread here, I think it was early this year or last year and it was about a Hollywood actor, was a big child actor and he had horrible things to say about pedophilia in Hollywood.
 
Top Bottom