DontBeThatGuy
Member
imagine that, ignoring threads you have no interest in. Could it all be so simple?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Moderators: the new ban on social and political discourse
- Thread starter GarthVaderUK
- Start date
nogoodnamesleft
Banned
Mod this man plz
nogoodnamesleft
Banned
Imagine when you try and the shit spiels over into threads that had nothing to do with it anyway but people cant help themselves to start shit about it.
x24hrs2livex
Banned
I usually didn't, but if the (above) potential new policy makes some people realize that banning discussion on certain topics that you don't like or agree with isn't really the best way to go about things, I'm all for it. Judging by a lot of the reactions so far tonight though, I think that might be asking for a lot.
Were you comfortable with ModBot?
Hm, what topic were you upset about when it got "banned?"
I don't recall saying that I was ever "upset" about discussion of any particular single topic being banned.
DontBeThatGuy
Member
That has nothing to do with political threads in OT or threads created to foster such a discussion.
You can moderate that issue you're describing, if it becomes an issue, without burning everything else to the ground.
But the asinine annoyances of certain members isn't why any of this is actually happening.
Perfect!!
Lets make Neogaf great again
Gross.
I dont recall saying that. And I didnt use the word complain. I said harassing. Harassing a person and a community is unacceptable no matter the reason.
i think something like a weekly trump news thread could have worked. it wouldn't get too big and would be easier to follow.
Megatron
Member
Why does people always goes melodramatic with the word "Let make something something great again"
So many fake outrage everytime...
SuperDowns
Banned
Newsflash, everything is political. Even media that has no "politics", apolitical is political.
SuperDowns
Banned
Because those words are symbolically incredibly bad. It's not just the words but the weight the apathic , status quo, white male hegemony it carries.
Pai Pai Master
Banned
You're dense if you don't think there's an underlying meaning to those words.
This sounds amazing
Sho_Nuff82
Member
I still don't see a rationale for dumbing down discussion just so we can have more space for Justice League, iPhone, and *insert sport star: supernova* threads. Those threads don't go away just because the rest of the world is happening.
Besides, how can you realistically remove political discussion from a movie thread about a political event or perspective? Or a TV show about gay people? Or a videogame about murdering Nazis? Or a sports thread where half the players have something to say about politics either on or off the field? If this happened 3 months ago, would we not be allowed to discuss the Weinstein allegations in a Miramax thread?
I don't see this as sustainable going forward. You can't discuss art without discussing the human condition. You can't even have an apolitical discussion about biology and human physiology.
Not dense, just stereotypically insincere. Says a lot that, in order for some people to appear reasonable, they must consistently pretend that they don't mean what they say. If your words do not have meaning, would the world be any worse off if you didn't share them?
Hip Hop
Member
But best of all, no more BCT!
KojiKnight
Member
Banned but didn't remove the gifs?
Mohonky
Member
That was my reaction I was like errr.....think.you forgot something lol.
Probably banned for another post in another thread then. Can imagine theyre not going through each banned useres post history.
How is that amazing? As someone who is gay I find discussion of my own rights pretty important.
Herr Schwarz
Banned
I never had a problem with OT I just think it was maybe the mods had trouble herding the shrieking cat user base.
Plus the trump guys got obliterated pretty quickly.
Plus the trump guys got obliterated pretty quickly.
That phrase has meaning to it. Don't pretend like it doesn't.
This sounds boring as fuck. Where will I get my news from?
Also, just another toothless forum like all the rest?
Officerrob
Banned
This is...eye-opening
clarknova156
Member
I figured there were lots of silent (well some werent) Trump supporters , anti-BLM and such people but anti-LGBTQ? I didnt think that would be called a plus that such discussion is now gone...
Freshmaker
I am Korean.
I am curious how that'll resolve the next time there's a something like a Zelda thread discussing stuff like wanting to have a female Link. Since stuff like that is inherently politically charged, and it's been a regular topic over the years.
I've always found stuff like that interesting. It'd be a shame to lose stuff like that, but I suppose that boils down to how strictly this political thing is enforced. It seems vaguely fleshed out as is.
I've always found stuff like that interesting. It'd be a shame to lose stuff like that, but I suppose that boils down to how strictly this political thing is enforced. It seems vaguely fleshed out as is.
PaulExcellent
Member
Love it. This is the type of attitude we'll be seeing here, isn't it?
Talk about a hugbox/bubble/whatever, then complain the site isn't made for me.
God, ignoring a thread must be so hard.
Like the guy said, Movies.
Fourmyle of Ceres
Member
Glad to know gaf is now the de facto cis het white male nerd pseudo ethnic center of discussion and that no one else matters really tbh.
Lol, what a fucking disgrace.
Lol, what a fucking disgrace.
This is obviously a panicked attempt to right the ship. Very little of the way this situation has been handled has been done well.
This is an example of that, and assuming the forum stays alive over the course of the next month, I am sure some of these initial mistakes will be corrected. But still I think if Off Topic is going to survive, it needs to be more inclusive for all, and moderate civil debate, for everyone involved.
This is an opportunity for the forum to fix itself.
This is an example of that, and assuming the forum stays alive over the course of the next month, I am sure some of these initial mistakes will be corrected. But still I think if Off Topic is going to survive, it needs to be more inclusive for all, and moderate civil debate, for everyone involved.
This is an opportunity for the forum to fix itself.
What a turd of a comment. Yeah no one in the civil rights movement ever talked about racism when fighting it.
Klappdrachen
Member
It's already happening, people are called "SJWs" and shit. It's just another opinion!
KojiKnight
Member
A bunch of people just got banned for it, so there is still hope there. The purge was just focused on suicides first it seems.
GribbleGrunger
Dreams in Digital
Yeah, this would be nice. I play games to get away from this sort of thing.
Nuking OT from orbit makes it seem seems like Evilore has an implicit fear of his own site. In any case, the forums are in a moderation vacuum right now.
dripdripsplash
Member
This is sarcasm. I hope.