-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
COD Ghost XB1/PS4 comparions rolling in (list of all updated sites)
- Thread starter chubigans
- Start date
This is also true. 1080p is 2.25 times the amount of pixels of 720p, and tha hardware is "only" 40% to 90% more powerful, depending on which metric you look at.
720p vs. 900p as in BF4 always seemed much more fitting.
Chobel
Member
This is Gameinformer review http://www.gameinformer.com/games/c...1/12/call-of-duty-ghosts-review-xbox-one.aspx
The result : no visual difference, no mention of framerate issues.
Polygon are not alone in this, Gameinformer said the same thing.
The result : no visual difference, no mention of framerate issues.
Polygon are not alone in this, Gameinformer said the same thing.
Always-honest
Banned
Yep, I have a feeling there's something weird about the PS4's output of this game, especially if those are real comparison shots and they didn't screw it up
DodgyGeezerFella
Member
Sub_Level
wants to fuck an Asian grill.
Dammit
Why is it so hard to believe that maybe there isn't much a difference? Its possible that there truly is just not that much of a difference. If they never said it was 720p from the start I have a feeling many wouldn't of noticed.
I think because people know that its 720p that its getting blown up like everyone on earth should notice a huge difference. I know many people that would never ever be able to tell the difference between 720p and 1080p. I know many people my parents age that couldn't even really tell or care for the difference between SD and HD channels. Its just not that noticeable to some people.
I think because people know that its 720p that its getting blown up like everyone on earth should notice a huge difference. I know many people that would never ever be able to tell the difference between 720p and 1080p. I know many people my parents age that couldn't even really tell or care for the difference between SD and HD channels. Its just not that noticeable to some people.
The Ghosts review event was held on October 21st. Reviews are based on the build that was available then.
Chobel
Member
No, If PS4 version is 1080p and Xbox One version is 720p.
SEGAvangelist
Member
So Polygon is failing to mention the frame rate issues may be fixed by launch...
IGN fails to mention to the frame rate issues...
Giant Bomb tells the truth.
Good Guy Giant Bomb.
IGN fails to mention to the frame rate issues...
Giant Bomb tells the truth.
Good Guy Giant Bomb.
Always-honest
Banned
Playing like that. Here is my shot, maxed in game settings, 4xMSAA -
Well, almost ;P. The other image looks cleaner (the downsampled one). Look at the wooden poles, gun and the flowers. aparent jaggies (small, yes.. impressive, yes).
But i think it will look that clean while in motion. Impressive.
velociraptor
Junior Member
I suspect this is what happens when you try to add fancy features to an age old engine.
I would prefer if they built an engine, from the ground up, for the PS4/XBO.
Nope, IGN mentions it as the uncommon, odd stutter.
Trogdor1123
Member
First COD game ive bought in years and its sounding like its meh at best. Maybe return it for Killzone...
ScepticMatt
Member
what I've learned from this comparisons is that the PC/Next-gen versions look MUCH better than current-gen, especially lightning and shaders.
RugbyPlayer
Banned
As a hobbyist photographer...the tint on both of those screens is absolutely disgusting which makes any other argument about graphics pointless, cant see jack in either image
Mr.Marston
Member
I have more respect for Quarter to Three than I do for Polygon.
Guys, we know the rendering resolution of both versions. A reviewer saying they can't see the difference doesn't mean there is no difference. It just means they are either lying, or have really poor vision. Either way, any reviewer who says they can't perceive any difference in visual fidelity between the two versions is probably really bad at their job.
My PC is hooked up to my main TV. The difference between 720p and 1080p is massive on a big tv.
I was playing Arkham Origins last night and flicking between the resolutions just to see.
Sorry but it is, I'm beginning to think these games are getting reviewed on small monitors or something.
Yea the jagged edges are the same size on both version. So either both are captured at 720P or they lied about PS4's resolution.
That's because you are actually outputting a 720p image to your TV and not a 1080p signal like the XBO does (even if not native, it probably has a better scalar than your TV).
Uh...what? Xbox One is sending a 1080p upscaled image. Am I wrong somewhere?
Facepalm.gif.
High end PC GPU's have their own scalers, if I'm not happy with that I could leave it to my Onkyo receiver or failing that the scaler in my TV is one of the best in the business.
UnluckyKate
Member
yeah this is 720p no AA something is fishy here
TheCanisDirus
Member
VE3TRO
Formerly Gizmowned
Ok I've just downloaded the IGN comparison video and they've either fucked up or the PS4 version is not running at 1080p in the recording.
No way the PS4 version looks like it's 1920x1080 in any of the clips.
I think IGN has recorded both consoles at 720p then just placed it into a 1080p project for export in their video editing suite. Nothing from the PS4 clips result in a 1080p picture.
And they've screwed up with the XB1 recordings in some scenes. In certain areas their hardware hasn't picked up the Reds correct which has resulted in a pinkish tone instead of the correct one.
You can see this here in the pictures below. I honestly don't expect the game to be like this.
Now I know people are going to say oh you can't tell from a MP4 video at 8mbps but yeah you should be able to see slight differences.
No way the PS4 version looks like it's 1920x1080 in any of the clips.
I think IGN has recorded both consoles at 720p then just placed it into a 1080p project for export in their video editing suite. Nothing from the PS4 clips result in a 1080p picture.
And they've screwed up with the XB1 recordings in some scenes. In certain areas their hardware hasn't picked up the Reds correct which has resulted in a pinkish tone instead of the correct one.
You can see this here in the pictures below. I honestly don't expect the game to be like this.
Now I know people are going to say oh you can't tell from a MP4 video at 8mbps but yeah you should be able to see slight differences.
feint_ruled
Member
Both TSA and IGN messing up in the same way? It's starting to strain credibility. Maybe the PS4 version just really does look that bad.
Lord Error
Insane For Sony
Either they were capturing video at 720p in PS4's case, or they converted to 720p when matching two videos together, or the developer lied and PS4 version is not 1080p. Because those screens and videos I've seen of PS4 version are not 1080p. Neither the IGN or the TheSixthAxis.
No, they are identical.
velociraptor
Junior Member
The Antitype
Banned
People who claim they can tell an immediate difference between the versions on either of the two comparison videos are lying through their teeth, lol
The game looks crappy on both platforms.
The game looks crappy on both platforms.
To me, in IGN's comparison vid neither version actually looks 1080p....are we sure the PS4 version really is 1080p? Because it looks 720p to me...unless compression or video capture settings were borked or something.
Main improvements in IGN's video comparison aren't even resolution related. They're lighting/gamma/colour related. PS4 looks better on these fronts. I'm assuming that on screen, minus flawed capture and compression, the PS4's resolution advantage will show dividends. Hope DF's comparison sheds light, because so far this has all been very confusing.
Agreed. I bet if they put those shots up without the x1 and ps4 headings no one would be able to tell which is which.
Just curious actually for my own knowledge but what makes it look 720p? I watched it on my tv through YouTube and they both looked identical. Just curious what stands out in the video and makes u say "that's 720 for sure" other then u know the x1 is 720p.
Castef
Banned
Gemüsepizza
Member
What is going on with the PS4 resolution in those pictures, they don't look 1080p to me...