BigTnaples
Todd Howard's Secret GAF Account
Yes. Just look at the lighting on those steps....
The XBO version looks atrocious.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DF/JF: Battlefield 4 PS4 vs XB1 videos/screens (900p PS4, 720p XB1)
- Thread starter shinobi602
- Start date
Yes. Just look at the lighting on those steps....
The XBO version looks atrocious.
Kenshin001
Member
Kind of accurate though. You can say PS4 has more pixels until you are blue in the face and it has better frame rate but just looking at the screens or vids you wouldn't know.
Most noticeable is the horrible jaggies on XBone and the blurriness on PS4.
Quadraphonic
Member
"Blurry mess" = "Accurate image". You haven't looked at any non-DF images, have you?
I certainly see the jaggies but the PS4 version is a blurry mess.
Just look at this:
Nope. Don't see anything even remotely resembling a "blurry mess."
By your logic, the PC version is also a blurry mess, by virtue of the fact that neither the PS4 nor the PC version feature the retardedly overdone edge sharpening effect.
If you've been paying attention at all over the past five or six months, you'd know that the Xbox One has a significant disadvantage in pre-order numbers and interest in general. Go out an actually talk to people about what they're interested in and you will see that Microsoft's decisions have had a very negative impact on their fanbase. Almost every hardcore Xbox fan I know in real life has no plans to get an Xbone and wants a PS4 instead. On Facebook (casual haven), forums, Youtube, gaming sites, you name it... the interest level for these systems is extremely lopsided.
Maninthemirror
Banned
You are again going by the DF capture which we all have established including DF Themselves was F'd up . See the ign and videogamer comparison
Bam Bam Baklava
Member
You're overstating the blur factor. All the videos I've seen from jack looks sweet.
Now i know you're pulling our legs.
Psycho_Mantis
Banned
Resolution and frame rate mean nothing. Lmao! Some people just cannot accept that the PS4 version is objectively superior.
Duxxy3
Member
You obviously haven't read the entire thread.
The digital foundry footage is screwed up. The xbox one video is completely messed up. Crushed blacks that don't exist in any other videos, and a sharpness filter that isn't there either.
Lord Error
Insane For Sony
There's no way to not have some level of blurring when upscaling. With any kind of realtime upscaling algorithm anyway. I have to say KZ:SF does look a lot more appealing than this. I just went back to this thread, and... yeah. 60FPS be damned, image quality and overall look are so nice in KZ.
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=703051
Americanmushroom
Banned
lol. Its called aniti aliasing
What the hell is this crap? Jaggies. Jaggies everywhere! Surely, that'll be patched in. Can't see my self tolerating this at all.
Arrogant Bastard
Banned
And how much for the cpu and ram that will give an equal comparison to the PS4?
Exactly! You tell em Senjut- Salvador bro. Set some of these fools straight that think there is an actual difference between the two version. If anything, the Xbone version will have the upper hand due to the custom scaler and audio chip.
cyberheater
PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 Xbone PS4 PS4
But Penello said there was no way that MS would hand over a 30% performance advantage to Sony.
On a different subject. Has anyone explained why both versions aren't using the same textures?
On a different subject. Has anyone explained why both versions aren't using the same textures?
Jest Chillin
Member
Dark10x (who another poster said works for DF) has surmised that DF used their own capture device but didn't have time to really configure it properly for the new systems, while the other outlets all used the same Elgato capture device that DICE provided. That's why DF's is the only one that looks massively different.
Clockwork
Member
Come on now...
blurry mess? that PS4 screenie looks exponentially better than the Xbone
the software scaler does suck and sony should have used a hardware one. ive seen screenshots from other sites where it looks blurry on ps4. its gutting i know but FOR this game, it is sadly true. it has the vasoline look on ps4
Thanks, i really appreciate it.
RedAssedApe
Banned
word of advice to some of you...don't ever get your tv calibrated. they turn your sharpness down to 0 and everything gets all blurry without the artificial edge enhancement.
stupid professionals!
stupid professionals!
Whiteshirt
Member
Apparently randomly generated. Hence why some things between the PC, PS4 and Xbox One are different like camo configurations and ground textures. The textures should be the same.
You see how well it fools the people who know nothing about this stuff. It's perfect for the casual audience and their sub-par LCD displays.
SRTtoZ
Member
1) Penello was sort of right, its not 30%, its more.
2) The ground textures and camo textures are randomly generated.
Nightengale
Member
The differences are lot more pronounced on a wide-screen TV. It's not the best representation, because of YT and video-player compression, but try connecting it to your TV. The jagginess is annoying.
Shamaylan twist : He was talking about PC, not Xbox vs PS4. /s
Shamaylan twist : He was talking about PC, not Xbox vs PS4. /s
We all knew the Xbox One version wasn't going to look as good.
For me, I was interested to see how close next-gen was to the PC version. I'd say its about the same jump from X1 to PS4. Noticeable, but still impressive.
I think people looking to buy this on a next-gen console should be fine, either platform. Obviously if BF4 is of paramount importance, it could sway somebody over to buy a PS4, but if you had your heart set on an Xbox One, I wouldn't be upset by this or anything.
For me, I was interested to see how close next-gen was to the PC version. I'd say its about the same jump from X1 to PS4. Noticeable, but still impressive.
I think people looking to buy this on a next-gen console should be fine, either platform. Obviously if BF4 is of paramount importance, it could sway somebody over to buy a PS4, but if you had your heart set on an Xbox One, I wouldn't be upset by this or anything.
Pristine_Condition
Member
Yeah. It must be said that Sony's decision to launch Killzone: Shadowfall with the PS4--a decision that was derided by some--looks like it may pay off well.
So many naysayers were baffled at the decision to have Guerrilla kick off the PS4 launch, rather than a SSM or ND, saying a Killzone game couldn't possibly serve a purpose in a launch that included two monster FPS franchises like CoD and Battlefield. But now, looking at the current landscape, that may turn out to be a key decision. Killzone is clearly going to be the tentpole console FPS title for launch as far as pure eye candy is concerned. Nothing else in the FPS genre will scream "next gen" nearly as loudly.
Will it outsell the likes of the big boys? Nah. That's almost impossible. But it will likely become at least that secondary title, if not a "must-have," for FPS fans that buy PS4s, if only to show what the system can do when it "stretches its legs" a bit. If I were buying a launch PS4, I'd certainly be picking up a copy. I'm thinking this will be a lot of folks' first Killzone game too, (especially folks who were 360-only gamers last gen who are making the switch,) so it's good Guerrilla made the decision to make this game a sort of a reboot of the franchise too.
...
That being said, These PS4 videos from Jack have me excited for Battlefield 4, even if it isn't nearly as technically stunning as KZ:SF. Dice knows how to get the pulse moving, and there's always something about the BF games that just clicks for me. It's exciting to know I'll be able to play it soon. I won't be there for launch, but I will be there.
CartridgeBlower
Member
How can you fuck up the capture WHEN THAT IS THE WHOLE POINT OF THE ARTICLE YOU ARE DOING???
Shit seems fishy, who knows.
Shit seems fishy, who knows.
Let's face it, the goalposts will keep moving, and people will rationalise their purchase.
This time last week, some were adamant 3rd party launch titles would have forced parity, today we see the PS4 version of BF4 pushing 40% more pixels, with a better framerate.
History also tells us console power discrepancies become more noticeable over time, not less. Thankfully, this time around, I can actually save money purchasing my prefared console, that doesn't happen very often!
This time last week, some were adamant 3rd party launch titles would have forced parity, today we see the PS4 version of BF4 pushing 40% more pixels, with a better framerate.
History also tells us console power discrepancies become more noticeable over time, not less. Thankfully, this time around, I can actually save money purchasing my prefared console, that doesn't happen very often!
I don't mind debating, my calm down was to the sheer volume of posts saying the same thing within about 5 minutes.
The N64 launched over a year after the PS1, just like the PS3 launched a year after the 360.
If those launches were aligned who could really say how they would have fared differently?
DF made a mistake, there is even a member in this thread adressing it. Here is the PS4 version captured better:
Done!
PS3
PS3 "Xbone Mode"
Xbox One
If you think we are bullshitting you, grab your remote controller and you can achieve both effects on your current consoles. You can make Halo Reach look sharp as fuck, but jaggies are still present. You can also make it look blurry.
brain_stew
Member
Not had a chance to properly disect things as I'm on my phone but the difference is huge. Over a 50% resolution advantage and better effects and yet the PS4 still runs at a higher frame rate. Despite What you may think of the visual impact in this particular case, that's a huge and damning assessment of the performance chasm between these two machines. It will be interesting to see how that performance delta is used in other multiplatform titles; resolution and HBAO won't be the only thing differentiation multiplat titles going forward.
cyberheater
PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 Xbone PS4 PS4
Thanks.
Jesus christ man, you're feeding him.
Psycho_Mantis
Banned
Lol just thinking about what Penello said here makes me laugh.
Thing is, edge sharpening, and overly saturated colors is the exact thing that sells to the average consumer. Just walk around any given electronics stores TV department. TV's are set at crazy settings out of the box to "wow" the consumer. I've got the feeling this is exactly what's going to happen for the Xbox One, people are going to be wowed by the picture looking sharper, and see the Xbox One version as the better one.
Might be sad, but it's the truth.
shinra-bansho
Member
I feel kind of sorry for the legitimate non-crazy and/or non-shill Junior Members who get a bad rap as a result. The spate of people banned as obvious social marketers basically has me doubting every post from people with Junior Member tags.
For anyone still doubting there's a real difference...
First watch JackFrags XB1 capture of the Fishing in Baku campaign mission
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g0ycN0re_5A
Then watch the Gametrailers review which has PS4 campaign footage (you'll know if it's PC or PS4 by the queues on the screen, or the PS4 UI icons in the top right).
http://www.gametrailers.com/reviews/oxobi5/battlefield-4-review
XB1 single player footage is noticeably worse. There's no way you can claim they look the same. You don't need to compare screens, just look at the actual footage.
First watch JackFrags XB1 capture of the Fishing in Baku campaign mission
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g0ycN0re_5A
Then watch the Gametrailers review which has PS4 campaign footage (you'll know if it's PC or PS4 by the queues on the screen, or the PS4 UI icons in the top right).
http://www.gametrailers.com/reviews/oxobi5/battlefield-4-review
XB1 single player footage is noticeably worse. There's no way you can claim they look the same. You don't need to compare screens, just look at the actual footage.