DominoKid said:
Toriyama was trolling hard w/ the Buu saga.
Yeah, like, from a sheer narrative perspective, it's clear he had ideas up to specific points--which is the hallmark of a good writer. You have an ending in mind. Then he had to start again from scratch. Freeza Saga had a clear ending and beginning. Android...went all over the place, but still had the right ending. Buu...was just random garbage.
Freeza:
Goku saves the Universe from his race and his father's killer, and transforms one last time from his happy go lucky self to a cold killer, except this time it's not a giant ape but an energy being, fulfilling his races's destiny as the chosen Saiyin, a martyr til the end. Gohan is his successor, now as Goku and Krillin both die, leaving the older generation dead.
Then comes the androids, whose motivation is pure revenge. Sort of a weak premise, but it has some tension. I suspect Yamcha was supposed to die as well in a Worf effect to show the danger of androids' energy-sucking powers, clearing the last of the old guard who are out of their league. Tien dies holding back Cell. Piccolo dies stalling Cell. Everyone cannot beat this guy...but then they all miraculously survive. Gohan goes from naive kid to the TRUE hero who kills Cell, completing his character arc that started with the Saiyan saga. Goku dies for real this time, no resurrections. Gohan takes over, and the new generation is ready.
Buu saga: Toriyama has said in interviews he screwed up here. He couldn't make Gohan an interesting Superhero character in high school--he has admitted high school drama and romance is NOT his strength, and it shows. Then came Goten as a mini-Goku. The BEST part of Buu Sage was Spopobichi, who genuinely WAS creepy. Human, but zombie-like, unkillable and just a creepy Videl-beating monster. I hated him more than Buu...and then Toriyama randomly kills him off. Waste of a great monster.
Then comes
the most dangerous villian EVER with Buu, who is basically the T-1000 mixed with Aladdin. Toriyama was flat out stealing American ideas by then. And how does that villain wage his war?
He eats candy. Gotenks headbutts him with a headbutt noise. NO ONE thinks that Toriyama, when starting the Buu saga, had this vision of a kid with no eyebrows fighting a bubblegum demon. He was clearly just throwing shit to see what stuck. And when that failed, he just had Goku save the day again despite the entire Buu saga supposedly saying how this is NOT going to happen.
I respect Toriyama. He is a genius of our time. It's just clear he just didn't want to do DBZ anymore. They really, really, really should have given him time off after the Android Saga to recharge his cells and come up with better ideas.