Zing said:
Maybe. I made a list of the must have games. I only came up with 13 games and I own nine of them. I dunno. Stuff like Dragon Quest I & II sounds good, but once you get playing you realize how old this stuff is. I played Metroid II for an hour last night and it just plain feels like an old Game Boy game. It feels like a game constrained by its platform. GBA games don't have that feeling, probably because they are SNES level while the Game Boy is sub-NES level.
On Metroid II I agree completely. I've been saying for a long time that it desperately needs the MZM treatment. But DW1&2 on GBC is still the most playable version. Go back to the NES version and see how much fun it is when you have to open a menu to talk to people or open chests.
I own around 50, and I can't say they're all must-haves, but there's still a lot of fun games there.
-Color Only-
Deja Vu I & II: The Casebooks of Ace Harding
Dragon Warrior III
Hamtaro: Ham-Hams Unite!
Kirby Tilt 'n' Tumble (requires an actual non-backlit GBC unfortunately)
Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Ages
Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Seasons
Metal Gear Solid
Motocross Maniacs 2
Super Mario Bros. DX (available elsewhere, but not in portable form)
Warlocked
-Color/B&W-
Dragon Warrior 1 & 2
Dragon Warrior Monsters
Game & Watch Gallery 2
Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening DX
Pokémon Trading Card Game
Shadowgate Classic
Warioland II
-B&W-
Donkey Kong '94
Faceball 2000
Final Fantasy Legend
Final Fantasy Legend 2 (coming to DS.. in Japan at least)
Kid Icarus
Kirby's Dream Land 2
Mario's Picross (I think these puzzles are DLC for Picross DS.. not sure)
Metroid 2: Return of Samus (did NOT age well)
Operation C
Parodius (JPN)
Super Mario Land
Super Mario Land 2
I weeded out some stuff that would be redundant (Pokemon RBYGS etc) but I'd consider all of those worth at least giving a chance to, and those are just games I own. There's still more worthy games I don't have like Mole Mania, Survival Kids, and the Castlevania games.