Yeah, I've seen that, it's a wonderful podcast. It's fascinating to see such a unique perspective on video games, he even notices details that we largely take for granted.
The difference is, he doesn't post on a site like GameTrailers. If the site was geared to players who have never played a first person shooter before - that would be something else entirely. I'd even enjoy watching them play or struggle to win, because I remember that feeling as a kid. But, if GameTrailers wants to claim they are any authority on games, it's kind of a problem.