Support NeoGAF

[Trey]

Element is ridiculous. This beat and flow is not even fair.

 

[Sane_Man]

He's really bearing his soul in Fear.

 

[Lemaitre]

Element is ridiculous. This beat and flow is not even fair.

Really? I thought it was his weakest so far. About to start Feel tho.

Edit: Feel is much better to my ears.

 

[Rran]

Even Bono can't tarnish Kendrick. Speaks wonders for his genius.

Or Kendrick just brings the best out in people U2 have made some amazing music, yo

 

[kobe(beast)]

It is pretty weak so far. Iam on loyalty, about to start pride.

 

[MugiwaraCole]

Trying to wait for iTunes, but y'all testing my patience.

 

[jxN3]

It can't get better than Element, right? Holy shit.

 

[Catvoca]

Finished first listen. I like it.

Spoiler

Definitely less of a concept album then GKMC and TPAB and it's less out there sonically than TPAB. I anticipate I will end up liking it less than those because of that. Really like some of the songs so far, Pride, DNA and XXX are immediate standouts. Loyalty is wack though, didn't feel GOD much either. Hoping I uncover more depth lyrically and thematically after more listens. Overall really dig it, and excited to start it over again (which I will do after I stop blasting XXX on repeat)

 

[MugiwaraCole]

I'll wait but I hear that TPAB haters will love this and I hear the production is unreal.

TPAB haters can go fuck themselves.

 

[Dreams-Visions]

on second playthrough now.

someone call the fire department

i hope you have speakers or cans that do this shit justice

 

[ubique]

Kinda boring album but I like it

 

[phanphare]

Spoiler

Definitely less of a concept album then GKMC and TPAB

Spoiler

listen to it again, it's there

 

[CoolOff]

Second time around now, DNA goes so hard.

 

[Sane_Man]

Just finished up my first listen. SO different to what I was expecting and thankfully that's a positive here. Really love it. Loyalty was the only track I wasn't fussed about but maybe it'll grow on me. Kendrick can't be stopped.

 

[Dreams-Visions]

Second time around now, DNA goes so hard.

that's where i am again. jesus christ what a beat.

 

[chaislip3]

The beat on FEAR. is so good

 

[hughesta]

I can't fucking wait to listen this yall

 

[Mik317]

its pretty good. Probably his weakest but thats moreso because of how good the others are as a whole.

 

[Lemaitre]

Surprisingly I think Loyalty is the weakest so far.

 

[Catvoca]

Spoiler

listen to it again, it's there

Spoiler

I mean it's there in the intro and ending but I don't feel like it has as clear of a core concept to it? It's a first listen so I'm sure it'll change but you could tell generally what GKMC and TPAB were going for from a first listen but other than the rewind stuff I didn't feel any particular thematic flow from song to song.

 

[Bookoo]

I'll wait but I hear that TPAB haters will love this and I hear the production is unreal.

I am not sure about that. I guess you could say there are more "aggressive bangers", but it's definitely not GKMC.

 

[Trey]

Surprisingly I think Loyalty is the weakest so far.

it's the melody that grates on me.

 

[Thursday War]

lol at all the tpab heads itt hating

not all projects have to be super cohesive

its obvious kdot wanted to have fun this time after releasing two fully conceptualized albums and wanting to put this album out "urgently"

enjoy it for what it is

 

[Bookoo]

Spoiler

I mean it's there in the intro and ending but I don't feel like it has as clear of a core concept to it? It's a first listen so I'm sure it'll change but you could tell generally what GKMC and TPAB were going for from a first listen but other than the rewind stuff I didn't feel any particular thematic flow from song to song.

Spoiler

Yea, I agree with you. If there is a concept it is extremely vague and only around the edges. Probably the only reason I am little disappointed, but I still enjoy the majority if not all of the tracks on the album.

 

[CassidyIzABeast]

Yeah? Sonically, conceptually, or both?

Its a good album. I just don't feel like I'm going to go back to it much.

There's not much in the way of structure on this. This feels like a tape full of vibe out joints rather than traditional songs. The hooks are pretty blegh to me and I love Kendrick's songs. There's no Alright, You aint gotta lie, levitate, sing about me, and so on and so forth songs on here.

Sidebar but Humble sounds out of place on this album. Its nothing like i where out of context it was aight but on the album was great. Humble is a hard ass record crammed between a smooth record and followed up by some Love Below sounding joint. Completely threw my expectation off.

 

[Lemaitre]

lol at all the tpab heads itt hating

not all projects have to be super cohesive

its obvious kdot wanted to have fun this time after releasing two fully conceptualized albums and wanting to put this album out "urgently"

enjoy it for what it is

So far it's just...boring and a bit uninspired. I'm on Pride and it's becoming a bit grating so far. I can't see myself bumping any of the tracks so far, even though it's still super early.

Edit: Re-listening to Humble on my first full play through but it's my favorite song off the album still. I hope they didn't release the best track first....

 

[Puck Beaverton]

Nobody is asking the important questions:

Does
It
Bump
In
The
Whip
Tho
?

 

[phanphare]

Spoiler

I mean it's there in the intro and ending but I don't feel like it has as clear of a core concept to it? It's a first listen so I'm sure it'll change but you could tell generally what GKMC and TPAB were going for from a first listen but other than the rewind stuff I didn't feel any particular thematic flow from song to song.

Spoiler

I feel it has two or three main concepts, one is the narrative of what's going on which is alluded to with the intro and outro, the second is the self reflection aspect, and the third is the meta reflection on the world and people in general. he gets shot and sees his life flash before his eyes before going to either heaven or hell.

 

[HiiiLife]

Nobody is asking the important questions:

Does
It
Bump
In
The
Whip
Tho
?

More than TPAB sure.

 

[rdytoroll]

Nobody is asking the important questions:

Does
It
Bump
In
The
Whip
Tho
?

That it will.

 

[Dreams-Visions]

Nobody is asking the important questions:

Does
It
Bump
In
The
Whip
Tho
?

hell yea.

 

[mortal]

The leak is no more than a few hours old. How about ya'll actually listen to the music and let it sink in for awhile before making comparisons and comparisons, like damn.

 

[sanstesy]

Yeah after two listens definitely his weakest yet for me. Too inconsistent and half of the tracks are too simple and one-note for what you expect from Kendrick.

But it's not as bad as expected after HUMBLE came out. A solid listen overall with ELEMENT being the best track by a wide margin.

 

[chaislip3]

These beat switches are going to be the death of me

 

[jxN3]

Loyalty loyalty loyalty!!

I dig it. Rihanna was great.

 

[CoolOff]

Loyalty is hot garbage.

Edit:

Loyalty loyalty loyalty!!

I dig it. Rihanna was great.

 

[Lemaitre]

The leak is no more than a few hours old. How about ya'll actually listen to the music and let it sink in for awhile before making comparisons and comparisons, like damn.

You can have initial impressions with music, what's the issue? Of course that initial impression will change but not by much. After my first listen for Humble I was already a fan. Rest of the album so far not so much.

 

[HiiiLife]

The end of DNA mannnnnn

 

[Catvoca]

The leak is no more than a few hours old. How about ya'll actually listen to the music and let it sink in for awhile before making comparisons and comparisons, like damn.

I mean a lot of us are prefacing "hey this is my first impression". I think there's value in putting that stuff out there now, it's fun to look back on that stuff after the dust has settled and shake your head at how wrong everyone was lol. It's also a fucking thread for discussing the album so people are gonna talk about the album dude 😀

 

[Zeusy]

dammit i gotta wait until spotify

 

[Thursday War]

So far it's just...boring and a bit uninspired. I'm on Pride and it's becoming a bit grating so far. I can't see myself bumping any of the tracks so far, even though it's still super early.

Edit: Re-listening to Humble on my first full play through but it's my favorite song off the album still. I hope they didn't release the best track first....

DNA is boring? Element is boring? XXX is boring? yikes....

let it grow on you

 

[Kelsdesu]

Nobody is asking the important questions:

Does
It
Bump
In
The
Whip
Tho
?

Yeah. Its worthless to me if it doesn't Bump.
I want another m.A.A.d. city..... There I said it.

 

[ZeoVGM]

ALMOST TIME TO EAT, BREHS

who bringin the sweet rolls tho

Is there a good wallpaper size version of this? Or something similar where everyone is sitting?

 

[Lemaitre]

The chorus on Lust is pretty funny. But again not really feelin it as a whole....(this song I mean).

 

[mortal]

You can have initial impressions with music, what's the issue? Of course that initial impression will change but not by much. After my first listen for Humble I was already a fan. Rest of the album so far not so much.

Sure, that's all good. Obviously everyone isn't going to feel the same. In most cases listening to an entire music project, especially one as dense as Kendrick's tend to be takes some time to even form an impression. This is addressed to those rushing to make album rankings.

 

[CountBlack]

only misses for me are God/Loyalty/Love

 

[Spine_Ripper]

Of course this leaks as I'm at school

 

[jxN3]

Lust is so fucking Andre 3000 inspired, can't believe he isn't on this track.

 

[Lemaitre]

DNA is boring? Element is boring? XXX is boring? yikes....

let it grow on you

Haven't listened to XXX yet but yes I am not a fan of Element or DNA. I find the sampling on DNA pretty annoying especially on the second verse.

Edit: Love is also dull to me. Not a fan of this one either. Sounds like something that could be off a Drake album.

Edit 2: Bout to start XXX. I'll get back to you on that one soon.

 

[rdytoroll]

Yeah. Its worthless to me if it doesn't Bump.
I want another m.A.A.d. city..... There I said it.

No worries, there's bangers