• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

NeoGAF's Top/Essential RPGs

kswiston

Member
VOTING IS OVER!!!

PREFACE:

I often find myself trying to pick up quality games that I have missed over the last decade or two. While game review sites and score aggregate sites (GameRankings, Metacritic) are often handy for identifying what is worth checking out, I have always found that they do a poor job of assessing role playing games, especially the lesser known titles. Word of mouth consensus from GAF can be better, but you have to do more digging and (again) most discussion tends to be about the big franchises.

In this thread, people picked up to 10 rpgs that they felt were the best/most essential in the genre. All picks were equal, and there was no points ranking/weighting. Overall, close to 300 people made ~2500 votes to generate the list below.

This thread is meant to be a list of Top/Essential rpgs from all platforms and all sub-genres. Hopefully the final result will serve as a useful little guide to some of the highlights of the genre.


TOP 100+ RPGs BY VOTES



1) Chrono Trigger - 126 votes
Original Release: March 11, 1995
Platforms: SNES, PS1, DS

chronotrigger.jpg
chronotrigger2.jpg
chronotrigger3.jpg


Summary: Chrono Trigger was developed and published by Square, and follows a group of adventurers who travel through time to prevent a global catastrophe. Chrono Trigger's development team included Hironobu Sakaguchi, creator of the Final Fantasy series, and Yuuji Horii and Akira Toriyama—two freelance designers known for their work on the Dragon Quest series. Chrono Trigger was praised for many of its features, including multiple endings, plot-related sidequests focusing on character development, unique battle system, and then detailed graphics.


2) Final Fantasy VI - 89 votes
Original Release: April 2, 1994
Platforms: SNES, PS1, GBA

FF6.jpg
FF6-2.jpg
FF6-3.jpg


Summary: Final Fantasy VI ( originally Final Fantasy III in North America) was developed and published by Square. Set in a fantasy world with a technology level equivalent to that of the Second Industrial Revolution, the game's story focuses on a group of rebels as they seek to overthrow an imperial dictatorship. The game features fourteen permanent playable characters, the most of any game in the main series. Final Fantasy VI was the first game in the series to be directed by someone other than producer and series creator Hironobu Sakaguchi; the role was filled instead by Yoshinori Kitase and Hiroyuki Itō. Yoshitaka Amano, a long-time contributor to the Final Fantasy series, returned as the image and character designer, while regular composer Nobuo Uematsu wrote the game's score, which has been released on several soundtrack albums.


3) Planescape: Torment - 67 votes
Original Release: December 12, 1999
Platform: Windows PC

planescape.jpg
planescape2.jpg
planescape3.jpg


Summary: Planescape: Torment was by Black Isle Studios and takes place in Planescape, an Advanced Dungeons & Dragons (AD&D) fantasy campaign setting. The game's engine is a modified version of the Infinity Engine, which was also used for BioWare's Baldur's Gate. Planescape: Torment is primarily story-driven; combat is given less prominence than in most contemporary role-playing games. The protagonist is an immortal who has lived many lives but has forgotten all about them, even forgetting his own name. The game focuses on The Nameless One's journey throughout the city of Sigil and other planes to reclaim his memories of these previous lives. The game was not a significant commercial success but received widespread critical praise and has since become a cult classic. It was lauded for its immersive dialogue, for the dark and relatively obscure Planescape setting, and for the protagonist's unique persona, which shirked many characteristics of traditional role-playing games.


4) Final Fantasy VII - 66 votes
Original Release: January 31, 1997
Platforms: PS1, PC, Playstation Network

FF7.jpg
FF7-2.jpg
FF7-3.jpg


Summary: Final Fantasy VII was originally developed by Square and published by Sony Computer Entertainment. Set in a dystopian world, Final Fantasy VII's story centers on mercenary Cloud Strife who joins with several others to stop the megacorporation Shinra, which is draining the life of the planet to use as an energy source. As the story progresses, the situation escalates and Cloud and his allies face Sephiroth, the game's main antagonist. Originally planned for the SNES, and then the N64, Square moved development of Final Fantasy VII to the Playstation to take advantage of the larger storage capacity offered by cds over cartridges. The music was scored by Final Fantasy veteran Nobuo Uematsu, while the series' long-time character designer, Yoshitaka Amano, was replaced by Tetsuya Nomura. Noted for its graphics, gameplay, music and story, Final Fantasy VII is acknowledged as one of the most influential games of all time.


5) Demon's Souls - 64 votes
Original Release: October 2009 (NA)
Platforms: PS3

demonssouls.jpg
demonssouls2.jpg
demonssouls3.jpg


Summary: Demon's Souls is a fantasy action RPG developed by From Software. The game is described as a spiritual successor to the King's Field series, and set in a dark fantasy world where an acursed fog brought forth demons that laid waste to humanity. Noted for its high difficulty level, Demon's Souls was released to nearly unanimous praise, winning year-end awards from several publications.


[tie] 6) Baldur's Gate II : Shadows of Amn - 53 votes
Original Release: September 24, 2000
Platform: Windows PC

bg2.jpg
bg2-2.jpg
bg2-3.jpg


Summary: Baldur's Gate II was developed by BioWare and is set a few months after the events of Baldur's Gate. The story opens with the player having been ambushed by assassins and taken captive into a mysterious dungeon under the control of the mage, Jon Irenicus. Based on the 2nd edition Advanced Dungeons & Dragons role-playing system, Baldur's Gate II was praised for its epic story and well developed characters. Throughout the game, the player must make crucial choices, some of them vital to the character's development. Using Bioware's infinity engine, the game is played from an isometric view, and enemy encounters can be fought in both active and turn-based modes.


[tie] 6) Final Fantasy Tactics - 53 votes
Original Release: June 20, 1997
Platforms: PS1, PSP, Playstation Network

FFT.jpg
FFT-2.jpg
FFT-3.jpg


Summary: Final Fantasy Tactics was developed by Square, originally for the PS1. Square-Enix released a moderately upgraded port of the game for the PSP featuring animated cut-scenes, new job classes, and a retranslated script. Directed by Yasumi Matsuno, the game combines thematic elements of the Final Fantasy video game series with a game engine and battle system similar to that used in Tactics Ogre (another Matsuno game). The game is set in a fictional medieval-inspired kingdom called Ivalice and follows Ramza Beoulve, a young highborn cadet who finds himself thrust into the middle of a military conflict called the Lion War, where two noble factions are coveting the throne of the kingdom.


[tie] 6) Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic - 53 votes
Original Release: July 15, 2003
Platform: Windows PC, Xbox

kotor.jpg
kotor2.jpg
kotor3.jpg


Summary: KOTOR was developed by BioWare and published by LucasArts. The game takes place 4,000 years before the rise of the Galactic Empire. Darth Malak, a Dark Lord of the Sith, has unleashed a Sith armada against the Republic. Malak's aggression has left the Jedi scattered and vulnerable; many Jedi Knights have fallen in battle and others have sworn allegiance to Malak. The game's battle system is based on Wizards of the Coast's Star Wars Roleplaying Game, a d20 role-playing game derived from the Third Edition Dungeons & Dragons rules. Combat is round-based; time is divided into discrete rounds, and combatants attack and react simultaneously. An alignment system tracks actions and speech to determine whether the player's character aligns with the light or dark side of the Force. Generosity and altruism lead to the light side, while selfish or violent actions will lead the player's character to the dark side, altering the character's appearance in the process.


9) Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4 - 52 votes
Original Release: July 10, 2008
Platforms: PS2

persona4.jpg
persona4-2.jpg
persona4-3.jpg


Summary: Persona 4 was developed and published by Atlus, and is chronologically the fifth installment in the series. Instead of the city locales of previous games in the series, Persona 4 takes place in a fictional Japanese countryside, where the main protagonist is a high-school student who moved into the countryside from the city for a year. During his year-long stay, he becomes involved in investigating mysterious murders while harnessing the power of summoning Persona. Combining high school simulation and traditional dungeon crawling rpg elements, Persona 4 features a weather forecast system with events happening on foggy days to replace the moon phase system implemented in the previous games.


10) Diablo II - 43 votes
Original Release: June 29, 2000
Platform: Windows PC

diablo2.jpg
diablo2-2.jpg
diablo2-3.jpg


Summary: Developed by Blizzard North, Diablo II is a dark, fantasy-themed action rpg with elements of the hack and slash and "dungeon roaming" genres. The game was conceptualized and designed by David Brevik and Erich Schaefer, whom with Max Schaefer acted as Project Leads on the game. The story takes place after the end of the previous game, in the lands of Sanctuary where Diablo, the Lord of Terror, was defeated by an unnamed warrior. The storyline of Diablo II progresses through four acts, with each act following a predetermined path and list of quests. The player assumes the role of a hero from one of five different character classes. Players fight monsters through wilderness areas and dungeons in order to level-up their character and gain better items. Combat is in real-time, and shown from an isometric viewpoint. The game can be played either in single player mode, or in multiplayer through Blizzard's Battle.net service, or via a LAN.


11) Skies of Arcadia - 41 votes
Original Release: October 5, 2000
Platforms: Dreamcast, Gamecube

skies.jpg
skies2.jpg
skies3.jpg


Summary: Skies of Arcadia was developed by Overworks for the Dreamcast and published by Sega. The game's story focuses around Vyse, a young pirate in a Jules Verne-inspired fantasy world, and his friends as they attempt to stop the Valuan Empire from reviving ancient weapons with the potential to destroy the world. Most of gameplay in Skies of Arcadia takes place in dungeons, and combat comprises two vastly different settings: those encountered in ship to ship combat, and character to monster combat. Sega released an enhanced port, Skies of Arcadia Legends, for the GameCube. Legends features slightly enhanced graphics, shorter loading times and some additional content.


12) Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King - 40 votes
Original Release: November 27, 2004
Platforms: PS2

dq8.jpg
dq8-2.jpg
dq8-3.jpg


Summary: Dragon Quest VIII was developed by Level-5 and published by Square Enix. Dragon Quest VIII uses cel-shading textures for the characters and scenery and is the first game in the series to have fully three dimensional environments. Despite the graphical update, the game retains most of the series' role-playing game elements, such as turn-based combat and the experience level system. Dragon Quest VIII follows a silent Hero and his party of allies as they journey towards their goal of defeating the wicked Dhoulmagus. Like all mainline Dragon Quest titles, battles are randomly occurring and turn-based. However, this is the first game in the series to not have battles shown from a first person perspective.


[tie] 13) Earthbound - 39 votes
Original Release: August 27, 1994
Platforms: SNES

earthbound.jpg
earthbound2.jpg
earthbound3.jpg


Summary: EarthBound was co-developed by Ape and HAL Laboratory and published by Nintendo. Despite being successful in Japan, the North American version was released to poor commercial response. Despite the poor sales figures, the game has been lauded by gamers for its humorous depictions of American culture and parody of the RPG genre, and has since become a cult classic. EarthBound takes place on Earth in the year 199X, and puts the player in control of four characters, Ness, Paula, Jeff, and Poo. Rather than using an overworld map screen like most console RPGs of its era, the world in Earthbound is entirely seamless, with no differentiation between towns and the outside world. Another non-traditional element is the perspective used for the world. The game uses oblique projection, while most 2-D RPGs use a "top down" view on a grid or an isometric perspective.


[tie] 13) Mass Effect 2 - 39 votes
Original Release: January 26, 2010
Platform: Xbox 360, Windows PC

ME2.jpg
ME2-2.jpg
ME2-3.jpg


Summary: Mass Effect 2 is an action oriented rpg developed by BioWare Edmonton, with assistance from BioWare Montreal, and published by Electronic Arts. Mass Effect 2 begins in 2183, shortly after the end of Mass Effect. On patrol to locate and destroy any remaining Geth, the Normandy and its commanding officer, Commander Shepard, are attacked. This starts a cascading series of events that finds Shepard searching the Milky Way for a crew of specialists and commandos capable of facing the greatest threat the galaxy has ever known. Mass Effect 2 blends third person shooter gameplay with the world building and character progression that are staples of the rpg genre.


[tie] 13) Xenogears - 39 votes
Original Release: February 11, 1998
Platforms: PS1, Playstation Network (Japan only)

xeno.jpg
xeno2.jpg
xeno3.jpg


Summary: Xenogears was developed and published by Square for the Sony PlayStation. Xenogears follows protagonist Fei Fong Wong and several others as they struggle to survive in a world torn apart by war between the nations of Aveh and Kislev. The principles and philosophies of Friedrich Nietzsche, Sigmund Freud, Carl Jung and Jacques Lacan, as well as various religious themes influence the overall plot and world of Xenogears. A major theme of the game is the nature of human memory: from the start of the game, Fei has memory loss, which colors his interactions with other characters. In addition, the struggle between man and machine is also central to the game's plot. Each of the playable characters can ride in giant mechs known as gears and can use them in battle. Xenogears gameplay features two-dimensional sprites overlaid on three-dimensional backgrounds and two different battle systems: the first uses the characters in combo-based physical combat and the second takes place in turn-based "gear" battles.


16) Valkyria Chronicles - 38 votes
Original Release: April 24, 2008
Platforms: PS3

vc.jpg
vc2.jpg
vc3.jpg


Summary: Valkyria Chronicles, known in Japan as Battlefield Valkyria: Gallian Chronicles, is a tactical role-playing game published by Sega, and developed by their Sega WOW division, for the PlayStation 3. The game is set in Europa, a fictional version of Europe, in 1935. Because of its abundance of Ragnite ore, which can be refined into a powerful fuel, the neutral nation of Gallia comes under attack from the East Europan Imperial Alliance, which is itself engaged in a war with the Atlantic Federation. Players take control of a militia squad of Gallian nationals, dedicated to repelling the invasion. The game's visuals, which utilize SEGA's CANVAS graphics engine, resemble a watercolor painting in motion.


[tie] 17) Fallout 3 - 36 votes
Original Release: Oct 28, 2008
Platform: Windows PC, PS3, Xbox 360

fallout3.jpg
fallout3-2.jpg
fallout3-3.jpg


Summary: Fallout 3 is an action role-playing shooter developed by Bethesda Game Studios. The game takes place in the year 2277, 36 years after the setting of Fallout 2 and 200 years after the nuclear apocalypse that devastated the game's world in an alternate post-World War II timeline. The game places the player in the role of an inhabitant of Vault 101, a survival shelter designed to protect a small number of humans from the nuclear fallout. When the player character's father disappears under mysterious circumstances, he or she is forced to escape from the Vault and journey into the ruins of Washington D.C. to track him down. Along the way the player is assisted by a number of human survivors and must battle myriad enemies that now inhabit the area now known as the "Capital Wasteland". The game has an attribute and combat system typical of an action strategy game but also incorporates elements of first-person shooter and survival horror games.


[tie] 17) Suikoden II - 36 votes
Original Release: December 17, 1998
Platforms: PS1, PSP (jpn only)

suiko2.jpg
suiko2-2.jpg
suiko2-3.jpg


Summary: Suikoden II was developed and published by Konami for the PlayStation. The game features a vast array of characters, with over sixty characters usable in combat and many more who move the plot forward. Suikoden II takes place years after the events of the original Suikoden, and centers around an invasion by the Kingdom of Highland of the City States of Jowston. The player controls a silent protagonist whose name is chosen by the player; he is the adopted son of Genkaku, a hero who saved the City-State of Jowston in a war against Highland years ago. The protagonist and his best friend, Jowy Atreides, each gain one half of the Rune of the Beginning, one of the 27 True Runes of the Suikoden setting, and become caught up in the intrigues of the invasion and the dark fate of those who bear the halves of that Rune.

19) Final Fantasy X - 34 votes
Original Release: July 19, 2001
Platforms: PS2

FFX.jpg
FFX-2.jpg
FFX-3.jpg


Summary: Final Fantasy X was developed and published by Square for Sony's PlayStation 2. The game marks the Final Fantasy series' transition from entirely pre-rendered backdrops to fully three-dimensional areas, and is also the first in the series to feature voice acting. Final Fantasy X replaces the Active Time Battle (ATB) system with a new Conditional Turn-Based Battle (CTB) system, and uses a new leveling system called the "Sphere Grid". Set in the fantasy world of Spira, the game's story centers around a group of adventurers and their quest to defeat a rampaging monster known as "Sin". The player character is Tidus, a blitzball star who finds himself in Spira after his home city of Zanarkand is destroyed by Sin. During the game, Tidus, along with several others, aids the summoner Yuna on her pilgrimage to destroy Sin.

CONTINUED IN POST #3

*Summaries adapted from game information on Wikipedia.org
 

kswiston

Member
20) Shin Megami Tensei III: Nocturne - 33 votes
Original Release: January 29, 2004
Platforms: PS2

nocturne.jpg
nocturne2.jpg
nocturne3.jpg


Summary: Shin Megami Tensei III: Nocturne was developed by Atlus, and was the first Megaten game in the series to be released into the United States using the "Megami Tensei" name. The player takes control of a half-human half-demon silent protagonist. The protagonist is an average high school student with some interest in video games and in the occult. He becomes involved in the Conception, the end of the world, when visiting his teacher. Classic MegaTen games had a simple turn-based system where characters attacked in one round based on their speed rating. Nocturne has a different turn-based system in place called the 'Press Turn' system. In this system, the player is assigned Press Turns equal to the size of his party (although a special event allows the player to gain an extra press turn) and can re-use some of them by scoring Critical Hits or exploiting elemental weaknesses.


Ranks 21-50 (with quotes from the GAF community)

21) Mass Effect - 32 votes
22 - tie) Final Fantasy IV (II US) - 31 votes


22 - tie) Final Fantasy IX - 31 votes
FF9-2.jpg

"Everything good about the 8-bit Final Fantasy's, but in 3D. The art design and soundtrack are timeless." - AlphaBromega

22 - tie) Final Fantasy XII - 31 votes

25) Deus Ex - 30 votes
deus2.jpg

" Along with System Shock 2, Deus Ex really proved the tremendous potential of the hybrid RPG." - EviLore

26) Mother 3 - 29 votes
27 - tie) The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion - 28 votes


27 - tie) Vagrant Story - 28 votes
vagrant2.jpg

"Surely Square Enix's finest hour since the SNES." - elfinke

29 - tie) Dragon Age: Origins - 26 votes
29 - tie) Secret of Mana - 26 votes
31) The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind - 25 votes
32 - tie) Pokémon Gold / Silver - 24 votes


32 - tie) Vampire: The Masquerade: Bloodlines - 24 votes
bloodlines2.jpg

"Bloodlines is clever, witty, and dark, filled with interesting personalities and uniquely leveraging a modern setting." - EviLore

34 - tie) Fallout 2 - 23 votes


34 - tie) The World Ends With You - 23 votes
twewy2.jpg

"one of the few games that really, really takes advantage of the DS's strengths. That, and it's a damn good RPG." - MechaX

34 - tie) World of Warcraft - 23 votes
37 - tie) Fallout - 22 votes
37 - tie) Persona 3 - 22 votes


39) Dragon Quest V - 21 votes
dq5-2.jpg

"Games have tried to tell a story that spans generations, but few can't compare to Dragon Quest V. DQV tells less about saving the world and is more about becoming a man." - Edgeward

40 - tie) Chrono Cross - 20 votes
40 - tie) Disgaea: Hour of Darkness - 20 votes
42) Tales of Vesperia - 19 votes
43 - tie) Golden Sun - 18 votes


43 - tie) Grandia - 18 votes
grandia-2.jpg

"This is the game that got me back into RPGs after the SNES era, and I couldn't have asked for a better way." - Einbroch

43 - tie) The Witcher - 18 votes
witcher2.jpg

" Loved how your decisions impacted and changed the game 10-15 hours after you had made them." - Sir Garbageman

46) Pokémon Fire Red / Leaf Green - 17 votes
47 - tie) Lunar: Silver Star Story - 16 votes
47 - tie) Tales of Symphonia - 16 votes
49) Panzer Dragoon Saga - 15 votes
50 - tie) Final Fantasy VIII - 14 votes
50 - tie) Grandia II - 14 votes



Ranks 52-100+ (with quotes from the GAF community)

52 - tie) Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance - 13 votes
fe-por2.jpg

"Favorite strategy RPG. Lots of emphasis on unit movement and placement, less on pre-battle preperation and class choices. Just awesome." - elbkhm

52 - tie) Lunar 2: Eternal Blue Complete - 13 votes
52 - tie) Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door - 13 votes
52 - tie) Super Mario RPG - 13 votes
52 - tie) Valkyrie Profile - 13 votes
57 - tie) Final Fantasy V - 12 votes
57 - tie) Kingdom Hearts - 12 votes


57 - tie) Lufia II: Rise of the Sinistrals - 12 votes
lufia2-2.jpg

"First game to actually make me cry." - Rebochan

57 - tie) Neverwinter Nights II: Mask of the Betrayer - 12 votes
nwn2-2.jpg

" In many ways the spiritual successor to Planescape: Torment, MotB captures the same essence. Quality writing, first and foremost, in a planeshifting dream-like setting with the best npc companions you'll find anywhere." - EviLore

57 - tie) Paper Mario - 12 votes
papermario-2.jpg

"A perfect blend of exploration, puzzles, skill-based combat, and character customization all wrapped up in an a very well-written game. Probably my favourite RPG ever." - Eddman

57 - tie) Terranigma - 12 votes
63 - tie) Baldur's Gate - 11 votes
63 - tie) Phantasy Star Online - 11 votes


63 - tie) Shadow Hearts: Covenant - 11 votes
shadowhearts2-2.jpg

"It was dark. And I like that." - Shadow Red

66 - tie) Arcanum - 10 votes
66 - tie) Phantasy Star IV - 10 votes


66 - tie) System Shock 2 - 10 votes
systemshock2-2.jpg

" A highly influential first person RPG hybrid with heart-racing tension and a memorable story delivered through audio log files scattered throughout the game, System Shock 2 is probably the only game that can scare the shit out of you with enemies that resemble brown lego blocks by today's standards." - Evilore

69 - tie) Dragon Quest IV: Chapters of the Chosen - 9 votes

69 - tie) Ultima VII - 9 votes
ultima7-2.jpg

" High point of the series and the last party-based Ultima. My personal favorite rpg of all time." - Dejan

71 - tie) Baten Kaitos Origins - 8 votes
bko2.jpg

"Improving upon the predecessor in almost every way, there is some divide about whether or not the battle system is better here or in the first installment, but it is still incredibly unique and satisfying in either case." - batbeg

71 - tie) Breath of Fire V: Dragon Quarter - 8 votes

71 - tie) Fire Emblem (GBA) - 8 votes
fe-2.jpg

"The game that got me hooked on SRPGs." - Brak

71 - tie) Pokémon Diamond/Pearl - 8 votes
71 - tie) Tales of the Abyss - 8 votes
76 - tie) Baten Kaitos - 7 votes
76 - tie) Breath of Fire III - 7 votes
76 - tie) Etrian Odyssey - 7 votes
76 - tie) Icewind Dale - 7 votes
76 - tie) Link to the Past - 7 votes
76 - tie) Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story - 7 votes
76 - tie) Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga - 7 votes
76 - tie) Parasite Eve - 7 votes


76 - tie) Phantasy Star II - 7 votes
phantasy2-2.jpg

" my favorite game ever. Amazing setting, some of the best plot twists in video game history, extremely difficult dungeons." - djtiesto

76 - tie) Shadowrun (16-bit) - 7 votes
76 - tie) Shining Force III - 7 votes
76 - tie) Star Ocean: Second Evolution - 7 votes
76 - tie) Suikoden - 7 votes
76 - tie) Suikoden III - 7 votes
90 - tie) Illusion of Gaia - 6 votes
90 - tie) Link's Awakening - 6 votes
90 - tie) Persona 2: Eternal Punishment - 6 votes
90 - tie) Shining Force II - 6 votes


90 - tie) Wild ARMs - 6 votes
wildarms-2.jpg

"Until this day this is the most influential RPG I have played through." - Agate


95 - tie) Alundra - 5 votes
95 - tie) Anachronox - 5 votes
95 - tie) Diablo - 5 votes
95 - tie) Disgaea 3: Absence of Justice - 5 votes
95 - tie) Dungeon Master - 5 votes
95 - tie) Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn - 5 votes
95 - tie) Icewind Dale II - 5 votes
95 - tie) Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time - 5 votes
95 - tie) Ogre Battle - 5 votes
95 - tie) Shadow Hearts - 5 votes
95 - tie) Shin Megami Tensei: Digital Devil Saga - 5 votes
95 - tie) Shining Force - 5 votes
95 - tie) Star Ocean: Till the End of Time - 5 votes
95 - tie) Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic 2 - 5 votes
95 - tie) Tactics Ogre - 5 votes
95 - tie) Wizardry VIII - 5 votes


96 - tie) Ultima Underworld - 5 votes
underworld-2.jpg

"Amazing, groundbreaking game, and one of my all-time favorites." - Ben Sones

96 - tie) Valkyrie Profile 2: Silmeria - 5 votes
96 - tie) Ys Book I & II - 5 votes
 

Dogenzaka

Banned
Demon's Souls - *Hidden Gem (EDIT: Not sure if this qualifies as a hidden gem?)
Kingdom Hearts
Persona 4
Valkyria Chronicles - *Hidden Gem (EDIT: Not sure if this qualifies as a hidden gem?)
Fallout 3
Tales of Vesperia
Pokemon Platinum

...my mind is going blank
 

TheSeks

Blinded by the luminous glory that is David Bowie's physical manifestation.
1. Parasite Eve (J/ARPG)
2. Parasite Eve 2 (ARPG)
3. Summon Night: Swordcraft Story
4. Final Fantasy Tactics
5. Final Fantasy 8
6. Final Fantasy 12
7. Valkyria Chronicals
8. Pokemon Red/Blue/Yellow
9. Demon's Souls
10. Breath of Fire 3
 

EatChildren

Currently polling second in Australia's federal election (first in the Gold Coast), this feral may one day be your Bogan King.
1. Planescape: Torment
2. Fallout 1 + 2
3. Arcanum: Of Steamworks & Magick Obscura
4. Vampire: Bloodlines
5. The Witcher
6. Deus Ex
 
Mass Effect 2
Baldur's Gate II
Diablo II
Final Fantasy VII
Final Fantasy VI
Star Wars: KotOR
Persona 4
World of Warcraft
Final Fantasy Tactics
Chrono Trigger
 

squall211

Member
  1. Final Fantasy IV (DS remake)
  2. Final Fantasy XII
  3. Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne
  4. Final Fantasy Tactics
  5. Xenosaga Episode I
  6. Tales of the Abyss
  7. Chrono Trigger
  8. Xenogears
  9. Valkyrie Profile 2
  10. Valkyrie Profile
 
1. Chrono Trigger
2. Mother 3
3. The World Ends With You
4. Final Fantasy VI
5. Final Fantasy IX
6. Pokemon Gold/Silver/Crystal
7. Dragon Quest VI
8. Secret of Mana
9. Final Fantasy Tactics
10. Final Fantasy X
 

Lafiel

と呼ぶがよい
I'll divide my selections into 5 for each genre. (j-rpgs and w-rpgs).

W-rpgs

1. Fallout.
2. Wizardry 8
3. Baldurs gate 2
4. Icewind dale
5. Planescape torment

J-rpgs

1. Shin megami tensei : nocturne.
2. Xenogears
3. Dragon Quest V
4. Mother 3
5. Chrono trigger
 

Unicorn

Member
Pokemon G/S
Mother 3
Morrowind
Golden Sun
Tactics Ogre: GBA
Final Fantasy 5
Phantasy Star Online
Monster Hunter Freedom Unite
Borderlands
Fallout 3
 
1. Ogre Battle: March of the Black Queen
2. Ogre Battle 64
3. Tactics Ogre
4. Baldur's Gate 2: Shadows of Amn
5. Final Fantasy 6
6. Chrono Trigger
7. Valkyrie Profile
8. Lunar 2: Eternal Blue
9. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
10. Valkyria Chronicles
 
1. Final Fantasy VI
2. Final Fantasy VII
3. Chrono Trigger
4. Mother 3 (GEM)
5. The World Ends With You (GEM)
6. Mass Effect 2
7. Shin Megami Tensei Persona 3 FES
8. Pokemon G/S/C
9. Earthbound
10. Planescape Torment

'RPG' is the genre where I haven't played a majority of the really highly-regarded games - mostly because of how time-consuming they are.
 

Malio

Member
Just right off the top of my head, remembering memorable RPG'S:

Dungeon Master
Eye of the Beholder II
The Bard's Tale
Ultima Underworld
Wizardry 6
Wizardry 8
Lands of Lore: The Throne of Chaos
Tales of Symphonia
Fallout 3
Elder Scrolls: Arena
 

Kevtones

Member
Demon's Souls
Persona 3
Persona 4
SMT: Nocturne
Shadow Hearts
Shadow Hearts: Covenant
SMT: Devil Survivor
Skies of Arcadia
 

Hugbot

Member
-Persona 4
-Persona 3 FES
-Chrono Trigger
-KOTOR
-Diablo 2
-Pokemon R/B
-Super Mario RPG
-Phantasy Star Online Episode 1
-Phantasy Star Online Episode 2
-Fallout 3



Mad love for the Persona series, though, they're some of the only jRPGs I can stomach anymore. For a while I loved the genre, but I fell out of love with it hard during high school. I think the big thing is they're so easy to play in tiny chunks, and you have something to do besides combat and cutscenes.
 

barnone

Member
1. Pokemon G/S/C
2. Pokemon R/B/Y
3. Pokemon D/P/Pt
4. Pokemon R/S/E
5. Mario and Luigi Superstar
6. Mario and Luigi Bowser's Inside Story
7. Mass Effect
8. Dragon Warrior Monsters
9. Chrono Trigger
10. Dragon Age Origins
 
FFVI
Terranigma
Chrono Trigger
Chrono Cross
Planescape Torment
Baten Kaitos*
Baten Kaitos Origins*
Super Mario RPG
Skies of Arcadia
Secret of Mana(cant believe I forgot this)


*I'd like to nominate these two Baten Kaitos games as hidden gems because they are pretty underrated but they are awesome RPGs. I set both as hidden gems because to get full enjoyment storywise, you should play both.
 
filled mostly with hidden gems rather than mainstream favourites:

1. Final Fantasy Tactics
2. Demon's Souls
3. The Last Scenario. A free PC RPG maker game http://site.scfworks.com/?page_id=11. Probably the best of the lot. Highly recommended for oldschool RPG fans.
4. Exit fate. (see above)
5. Saga Frontier II - actually a decent game compared to all other Saga games. requires some persistance though.
6. Shadowrun -SNES
7. Disgea (Better than any other installment including La Pucelle and Phantom Brave)
8. Jean D'ark
9. Mario RPG -SNES
10.
 
Uncharted Waters: New Horizons
Fire Emblem Thracia 776
Rune Factory Frontier

You're not gonna find a gem more hidden than Uncharted Waters. I'm willing to bet about only 10 people on GAF's actually played this game.
 
I'm not doing 'of all time' because those lists are boring
But of this gen/past few years;
(In no particular order)
Folklore* (Hidden Gem)
Demon's Souls
Valkyria Chronicles
Final Fantasy XIII
Kingdom Hearts: Birth By Sleep
Persona 3:FES
Persona 4
Shin Megami Tensei: Devil Survivor
The World Ends With You
 

Pappasman

Member
1) Chrono Trigger
2) Fire Emblem: sacred stones
3) Persona 4
4) Final Fantasy VI
5) Pokemon Gold/Silver
6) The World Ends With You
7) Final Fantasy IV
8) Earthbound
9) Lost Odyssey
10)Final Fantasy Tactics Advance
 

ryan-ts

Member
Chrono Trigger
Chrono Cross
Pokemon Blue/Red/Yellow
Pokemon Silver/ Gold/ Crystal
Final Fantasy 6
Final Fantasy 4
Paper Mario
 

Rolf NB

Member
Dungeon Master
Wizardry 8
Final Fantasy X
Dragon Quest VIII
Gothic 2 [w/ expansion]
Diablo II
Demon's Souls
Disgaea
Grandia 2
Final Fantasy VII
 
1. Earthbound
2. Mother 3 (Hidden Gem)
3. Persona 4
4. Final Fantasy IX
5. Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door
6. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
7. Mass Effect 2
8. Mass Effect
9. Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King
10. Kingdom Hearts II

Limiting myself to just ten games is tough, as there are a lot of other great games I'd love to mention. I really think these games highlight some of the best the genre has to offer, however.
 

Entropia

No One Remembers
Final Fantasy VI
Skies of Arcadia Legends
Tales of Symphonia
Final Fantasy IV
Chrono Trigger
Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
World of Warcraft
Lunar: Silver Star Story Complete
Earthbound
Pokemon Blue
 

Talon

Member
Planescape: Torment [PC]
Deus Ex [PC]
Diablo II/Lord of Destruction [PC]
Baldur's Gate II/Throne of Baal [PC]
Pokemon Red/Blue [GB]
Chrono Trigger [SNES]
Vagrant Story [PSOne]
Phantasy Star II [GEN]
Parasite Eve [PSOne]

And again I'm reminded that the late 90s/early 2000s was the best era for RPGs by far.
 
Disclaimer: I tend to hate JRPGs with a passion.

1. Planescape: Torment
2. Elder Scrolls: Morrowind
3. Gothic 2
4. Gothic
5. Baldur's Gate 2
6. Quest for Glory Series (2 and 4 being the better ones perhaps)
7. Deus Ex
8. Vampire the Masquerade Bloodlines
9. Legend a.k.a. The Four Crystals of Trazere
10. Ultima VIII: Pagan
 

luka

Loves Robotech S1
Since everyone is going to end up listing pretty much the same games, I will just list some that no one else will:

Ar tonelico 1/2
 

2DMention

Banned
Dragon Quest 8
Final Fantasy IV (GBA)
Phantasy Star Online
Persona 4
Thousand Arms - Hidden Gem
Star Ocean First Departure
Shadowrun (Genesis)
Phantasy Star IV
Paper Mario 2
7th Saga
 

RurouniZel

Asks questions so Ezalc doesn't have to
Alright, sounds like fun! Here we go (for the sake of argument I'm going to stick to RPGs that have been translated into English). In no particular order:

1) Lunar: The Silver Star (Sega CD)
More than any other RPG I've ever played, Lunar: The Silver Star sucked me into its world and never let go. The gameplay is solid (albeit average even for its time), but it was the characters and setting that set this game out.
2) Lunar: Eternal Blue (Sega CD)
The perfect sequel to an incredible game. It improves on the original in nearly every way, fleshes out the world even further, and does an incredible job of being its own game while still tying into the original without using it as a crutch.
3) Final Fantasy VI (SFC, known as Final Fantasy III on the SNES)
With beautiful 2-D graphics, 14 possible characters, and a branching story matched only by the complexity of its characters, Final Fantasy VI is everything that is right about old school JRPGs. It's musical score is still one of the best ever composed, and definitely the peak of Uematsu's portfolio.
4) Final Fantasy VII (PSX)
Love it or hate it, this game started a revolution. In 1up's "The Essential 50", FFVII was called the "Star Wars" of videogames. And they're quite right. Gameplay, not much changed from VI, but it brought the formula into the mainstream and started a boom of localized JRPGs.
5) Chrono Trigger (SNES/DS)
You got your Dragon Quest in my Final Fantasy! Or is it your Final Fantasy in my Dragon Quest? Whichever the case, there's a good reason a huge portion of the JRPG community swears by this game. Also, the debut work of Yasunori Mitsuda.
6) Dragon Quest VIII (PS2)
In the PS2 era, many companies had an extremely difficult time finding the right way to transition the JRPG formula to the powerful PS2. Some cut their overworld maps. Some just went for high quality 2-D. And Level 5? They found a perfect design balance that perfectly translated the design of older JRPGs into a lush PS2 game without making the game look like a series of square tiles.
7) Disgaea: Hour of Darkness (PS2/PSP)
When Disgaea was first released, very few games went to the crazy depths that Disgaea did when it came to building and army and then grinding the fuck out of it. Over and over. Grind your characters, grind your items, reincarnate your characters and grind all over again. And somehow, they made this all fun. Plus, Prinnies.
8) The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past (SNES)
Probably the closest gaming has ever gotten to perfection (outside of Tetris). This gem features perfect design, control, balance, and difficulty curve. There's not much else to say except, wow.
9) Secret of Mana (SNES)
The essential RPG to own if you have friends over. It's amazing that Square-Enix just couldn't seem to get it right after this (or arguably Seiken Densetsu 3), because this is how you design a multiplayer RPG.
10) Valkyria Chronicles (PS3)
An incredible mix of turn-based and real-time elements, combined with a beautiful art style and a score to match. Valkyria Chronicles came out of nowhere and made its voice heard upon the great valleys of Gallia.

luka said:
Since everyone is going to end up listing pretty much the same games, I will just list some that no one else will:

Ar tonelico 1/2

This just BARELY missed the cut on my list. I nearly put it in there, but while I love it immensely I didn't consider it "essential". :-(
Can we still be friends?
 
Phantasy Star 1
Phantasy Star 2
Phantasy Star 4
Phantasy Star Online
Skies of Arcadia
Morrowind
Panzer Dragoon Saga
Valkyria Chronicles
Shining Force 2
Shining Force
 

Willectro

Banned
Pokemon Red/Blue
Chrono Trigger
Mass Effect 2
Dragon Age: Origins
Final Fantasy III
Tales of Vesperia
Pokemon Silver/Gold
Pokemon Diamond/Pearl


That's all I can think of atm.
 
In no particular order:

Chrono Trigger
Final Fantasy IV
Super Mario RPG
Golden Sun
Baten Kaitos
Tales of Symphonia
Skies of Arcadia
Pokemon G/S/C
Ogre Battle 64
Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance

Honorable Mentions:
Final Fantasy VI
Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
Tales of Vesperia
Pokemon D/P/Pt

None of them are hidden gems... They're all pretty well acknowledged.
 

Einbroch

Banned
1. Secret of Mana

I don't think I've ever... had so much fun playing a RPG as I have when my brother and I plugged in Secret of Mana co-op'd the hell out of it. We still fire this game up to play every once and a while and I can assure you it is not nostalgia. From the weapon upgrades to the secret upgraded spells, this game has it all. The characters are interesting, the graphics are colorful, the music is mindblowing, and the gameplay is fantastic. Simply astounding on every level.


2. Star Ocean: The Second Story

I don't think I've ever... put more time into a game as I have with this game. The developers crammed so much value into a single package that even if the game was sub-par it would be a great game. Fortunately, it's a great game to play. The battle system was deep, item creating was ambitious, the graphics were blocky but I loved the direction. As stated before, I must've put at least 200 hours into this game. The bonus dungeon by itself probably ate up 60 or so hours. Amazing value.


3. Final Fantasy VI

I don't think I've ever... felt so emotionally involved in a game. The music. My god. The music. Screw the game, I own 6 CDs of just this game's music and remixes. Nevermind the fact that this game had some of the most memorable characters of all time with graphics that could pass as paintings. Not to mention that this game has one of the best villians of all time. WA WA WA WA WA. It was a surreal experience from start to finish.


4. Grandia

I don't think I've ever... been so refreshed by a game. The characters and character development is what made this game outstanding. Justin's voyage and growth throughout the game was easy to relate to, the humor was amazing, and the battle system was completely fresh (to me). This is the game that got me back into RPGs after the SNES era, and I couldn't have asked for a better way.


5. Ragnarok Online *Hidden Gem*

I don't think I've ever... laughed as much as had while playing Ragnarok Online. An MMO? On my all-time RPG list? Gasp! Sure, the game was grindy. Sure, the game had glitches. Sure, the game wasn't the best to look at. Do I care? No. There are two reasons why this game is above so many others in my collection: the music and the friends. First, the music. On par with Final Fantasy VI and Secret of Mana, this soundtrack has some of the catchiest, most memorable songs ever produced. If you haven't heard them, check them out on youtube. In fact, three of the games songs are on my Zune's most played list. They're that good.

Finally, the friends. I met so many amazing people in this game. While I only keep in touch with two or three of them regularly, they always stick in my mind. They got me through my father's passing, and with them I shared some amazing moments. For that reason alone, this game will always have a place on my top 5 list.
 

Wiseblade

Member
These are in no specific order:

  1. Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door
  2. Pokemon Platinum
  3. Grandia 2
  4. Chrono Trigger
  5. Etrian Odyssey
  6. Mother 3
  7. Final Fantasy IV
  8. Fire Emblem
  9. Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn
  10. Panzer Dragoon Saga




 
Parasite Eve - Aya Brea

Xenogears - played it for the graphics (@ that time) and beat it for the story line

Lunar Eternal Blue - loved the character development & WD's translation

SMT: Nocturne - the most palatable intro to dungeon crawlers

Persona 3 - the beginning of a long line of highschool-calender-based RPGs

Final Fantasy 6 - darkest FF by far and lovely soundtrack by Uematsu

Breath of Fire 5 Dragon Quarter *hidden gem* - a dystopian Ground Hog Day

Valkyrie Profile - for its unique way of recruiting characters & addictive battle system

Mother 3 - you will never be as purposefully driven to change your circumstances

Chrono Cross - overall best music. one of the few OST that I could listen to back-to-back
 

John Harker

Definitely doesn't make things up as he goes along.
Chrono Trigger
Final Fantasy VI
Final Fantasy Tactics: War of the Lions*
Demon's Souls
The World Ends With You
Breath of Fire 3
Suikoden 2
Dragon Age: Origins
King's Field: The Ancient City
Warcraft II


Tried to touch a bit of everything/games I really enjoyed or I think epitomize various facets of 'rpg' from different eras. They are all gems, though I suppose the few that need more playing are Demon's Souls, King's Field, and The World Ends With You.

honorable mention: Diablo

*depends on how you're counting the vote. I think you should count votes for FFT/FFTWotL as one vote as to make it a fair count, but I do think the PSP version is superior if I had to recommend one.
 

artilect

Banned
King's Field 4: The Ancient City
Demon's Souls
Wizardry 8
Ultima Underworld
Persona 4
Phantasy Star IV
Earthbound
Brandish 2: The PlanetBuster
Vagrant Story
Ys Books I & II
 

RPGManiac

Banned
1. Final Fantasy VI
2. Chrono Trigger
3. Persona 4
4. Final Fantasy IX
5. Persona 3 FES
6. The World Ends With You
7. Tales of the Abyss
8. Dragon Quest VIII
9. Pokemon Gold/Silver
10. Final Fantasy X
 

szaromir

Banned
Fallout 1
Fallout 2
Fallout 3
Baldur's Gate 1
Gothic 1
Neverwinter Nights 2: Mask of the Betrayer
The Witcher
Chrono Trigger
Deus Ex
Vampire The Mascarade: Bloodlines

I haven't played Dragon Age or Mass Effect 2 yet.
 

Durante

Member
1. Planescape: Torment

Unordered:
Ar Tonelico 2
Breath of Fire: Dragon Quarter
Baldur's Gate 2
Morrowind
Neverwinter Nights 2: Mask of the Betrayer
Ultima VII
Vampire the Masquerade: Bloodlines
Valkyria Chronicles
Xenogears

Edit:
Did some switching around, just 10 is really hard.
 

Archie

Second-rate Anihawk
1. Baldur's Gate 2
2. Fallout 2
3. Freedom Force (I'd put this in the hidden gem section.)
4. The Witcher
5. Barkley Shut Up and Jam: Gaiden (seriously, this would also qualify as a hidden gem)
6. Heroes of Newerth (can this count OP? It is a RTS with RPG elements, but stats are reset at the beginning of each game. If it doesn't count let me know.)
7. Chrono Trigger
8. Diablo 2
9. Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic 2
10. Shin Megami Tensei: Nocturne
 

golem

Member
In no particular order

1. Wizardry 6 - Old school dungeon crawling at its best
2. Ultima 7 - Still untouched
3. Wasteland - Best RPG ever
4. Quest for Glory 2 - Awesome action adventure RPG
5. Fallout 1 - Great tactical fun, would Jagged Alliance count?
6. Mass Effect 2 - Slickest RPG ever
7. Demon's Souls - The state of the art in delving
8. Deus Ex - All around great experience
9. Planescape Torment - Amazingly compelling story
10. Buck Rodgers Countdown to Doomsday - Pinnacle of Gold Box goodness
 

Reknoc

Member
Terranigma
Dragon Quest V
Shin Megami Tensei: Lucifer's Call/Nocturne
Mother 3
Skies of Arcadia
Final Fantasy VI
Baldurs Gate 2
Planescape Torment
The Elder Scrolls: Morrowind
The Elder Scrolls: Daggerfall
 
First of all, excellent idea! There are always a lot of list threads and I always wish there would be a summary of those at the end. Good luck with making it!

My ten picks:

Chrono Trigger
Fallout 3
Final Fantasy VII
Final Fantasy IX
Final Fantasy X
Lufia II
Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga
Mystic Quest (a.k.a. Final Fantasy Adventure)
Tales of Symphonia
Terranigma
 

ph15h

Neo Member
  • Valkyria Chronicles
  • Demon's Souls
  • Final Fantasy VI (or whichever number had Terra. Forget the numbering)
  • Tales of Phantasia (2D Tales)
  • Golden Sun
  • Suikoden II
  • Chrono Trigger
  • Lost Odyssey
  • Earthbound
  • Knights of the Old Republic

-_- Wish I could pick more, but I guess that's my list.

Honorable Mentions: Star Ocean 2, Thousand Arms Tales of Vesperia, Tales of Symphonia, All the Pokemon games except Yellow and Crystal, Final Fantasy VII, Mother 3, The World Ends with You, Monster Hunter, Disgaea 1, Fire Emblem, Lunar 2, all of Blizzard's games, Kingdom Hearts Series, and the Mario RPG series (RPG, Paper, Super, and Luigi), Xenogears
 
Top Bottom