For those saying Phil is "wrong":
Phil: strange comments (annoyed by a respected journalist basically staring a fanboy war)
Phil: Xbox is having a good gen (which they are, didn't say best, didn't say great, like others have said the division is probably making more money than last gen, hence the good comment)
Phil: XB1S strong since launch (which they probably have been, the Black Friday and Holiday bundles were pretty fantastic and he's the one with the sales data)
Phil: Can always improve but proud of where we are (does that really need to be debated)
It's silly to debate.