-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Rise of the Tomb Raider 4K comparison: Xbox one X vs PS4Pro vs PC
- Thread starter Poster#1
- Start date
Wishmaster92
Member
I made this comparison yesterday. Ps4 pro vs x1x:
Because 4K has the extra graphics capabilities turned off, sure it would look sharper, but it would also look far worse and really show the big differences in fidelty. But it seems we have Salty Sony Ponies, Peppery PC Master Racers and Boastful X-bots in this thread.. so this Schwifty Switch kangaroo is clocking out before it really gets out of hand... time to get Schwifty Ya'll!
Beck
Member
It does seem strange. While not the same exact image, here's a PC shot from my comparison last year:
wumster3000
Member
I don't know about this comparison. The PS4 Pro version looks horrible. I don't believe it looks that bad. Also, I can't imagine the Xbox One X version looking better than the PC version. I may be wrong here, but something is fishy with this video.
icecold1983
Member
Ill wait for DF. I just want to see if the supposedly new aa works well. Even at 4k the pc version looks like absolute ass in any scenes with even a bit of contrast, specular or vegetation due to the extreme aliasing
ethomaz
Banned
My fault I really guessed it was DF lol
Maintenance
Member
Killroyskbg
Member
Yess but that was an easy buy since I already had an PS4. I don't have a an Xbox yet but was slightly interested in buying a XBX for multiplats such as this but to me judging by those screens I don't find the 500$ justified. Will wait though and look at the comparison later on my 4K tv since I bet the phone screen don't properly display them correctly.
kruis
Exposing the sinister cartel of retailers who allow companies to pay for advertising space.
What has the wrong gamma value to do with resolution??
wumster3000
Member
Judging by that video, there is a clear difference between PS4 Pro and X1X. I don't trust this video, but there is a differences, if to trust this source.
Mr Moose
Member
I made this comparison yesterday. Ps4 pro vs x1x:
The bricks aren't sticking out in the PS4 version.
Ryu Hayabusa
Member
WHAT?? It's only an alpha?
Amazing
Wishmaster92
Member
Lara comparison
WHAT?? It's only an alpha?
Amazing
Itll just be a get out . It may be downgraded/upgraded in certain places
RedAssedApe
Banned
i'd expect blurrier textures on the ps4 pro version regardless of the mode. wasn't that already the case when df did pc vs. ps4 pro shootouts a year ago?
ps4pro wins this shootout cuz of the walkie
Lara comparison
ps4pro wins this shootout cuz of the walkie
Talk with dev.
Rise of the Tomb Raider Xbox One X Enhanced - IGN Live: Gamescom 2017
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w7xvnEgUh3E
Rise of the Tomb Raider Xbox One X Enhanced - IGN Live: Gamescom 2017
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w7xvnEgUh3E
Mr. Phellps
Member
That PC footage is completely busted and even the quality of the PS4 Pro footage looks suspicious; why is it blurry at 1080p, where it should be sharp because the game runs at that resolution? Even base PS4 looks better than that.
Better wait for Digital Foundry.
Better wait for Digital Foundry.
Liliana Eileen
Member
First comparison thread and it's already turned to accusations of fanboys doing the comparisons. Man, DF threads are gonna be a bloodbath come November and onward.
Cyborg
Member
I made this comparison yesterday. Ps4 pro vs x1x:
Which is which? As a regular gamer I dont see difference!
hones question
Mr Moose
Member
Top PS4, bottom Xbox.
Top is Pro, bottom is X.
LordBaztion
Member
I would like to see a montage of 1X vs X1 to decide if it worths the upgrade.
Hawk269
Member
At work at cannot watch. Any highlights you can provide? Thanks!
Not really. Nixxes is making it. Interviewer tried to get some info how working on Xbox One X has been. But didnt get anymore then "easy"
Mr Moose
Member
Are you implying that DF is trying to make the PS4 Pro version look bad on purpose? Honest question - I haven't actually played the Pro version, but I've been considering picking it up. Does the game actually look better than what was shown in this video? I don't know if I've been spoiled by all the 4k goodness lately, but that video made the game look like 720p on the Pro which can't possibly be the case.
Rain City Gamer
Member
I made this comparison yesterday. Ps4 pro vs x1x:
6 > 4
Monster
Almost Unfair
Terrifying Clarity
^^^none of these come to mind when I look at these two screens side by side.
It's a Negligible difference, even on a 4k TV (on 1080p TV it would be the same)
I don't think that is worth $100-$150 more.
This is just one instance, but those are my thoughts.
LordBaztion
Member
oh the blurriness. Thank you.
I expect many videos pointing the differences of many games after launch.
AngelOFDeath
Member
Textures my good man. Take a look at the rock formation on the left, it is more defined in the X version, with what someone would call blurry in the Pro version. Like turning up sharpness, but as others mentioned, definitely wait for a DF comparison, with all modes compared, coming from the source machine itself.
DroneBrother
Banned
Dam they've really fine tuned the X version, it's a rare thing these days to see a console version looking better than a PC version
Rare indeed. Can you give some other examples? 😏
thehillissilent
Member
I would wait for Digital Foundry or NXGamer. The PC version purposely looks gimped in the video.
Rare as in doesn't exist?
Fredrik
Member
Tomb Raider (2013) on PC doesn't even come close to Tomb Raider Definitive Edition on PS4. But I doubt that Rise will get the same visual overhaul, it looks very very similar.
What bothers me here though is that there is no talk what so ever about the framerate. That's like the dumbest thing to ignore when comparing PC visuals to console visuals, pretty games on console rarely go above 30fps but can go up to 100fps easily on PC with the right hardware.
nycgamer4ever
Member
I see that mister media x is starting the campaign to justify the xbox one x already. This comparison suspect af. LOL
Lister
Banned
Aren't the only differences god rays and some animations on foliage and her gear? Also textures are still worse and so are the load times.
ethomaz
Banned
At least this time he doesn't need to create illusory double GPU unleashed power 10TFs to try to pass XB1 as a powerful machine.
XB1X is indeed powerful.
Wow, I was about to say that I was impressed at the extra work but the video creator clearly didn't put the Pro and the PC at their best. I wonder why?
"Doesn't even come close"
Come on now, I agree that the PS4 version has some better assets. But put the PC version at 4K/120fps, and full TressFX on and you don't consider that to be close? Hell, the IQ itself is much better unless you're willing to argue that 1080p > 4K.
"Doesn't even come close"
Come on now, I agree that the PS4 version has some better assets. But put the PC version at 4K/120fps, and full TressFX on and you don't consider that to be close? Hell, the IQ itself is much better unless you're willing to argue that 1080p > 4K.
rodrigolfp
Haptic Gamepads 4 Life
plus unlimited resolution, framerate and controller options. and semi nude mods lol
SenjutsuSage
Banned
Don't really need youtube comparisons, which are already suspect due to the compression that will be present, to know that the Xbox One X version of this game and most games will come about as close as any console can come to high quality PC settings at a $500 pricepoint, which is the reason it exists in the first place.
I can't wait to get my hands on the console.
Why would the xbox one x version have an issue that even the regular xbox one version doesn't?
I can't wait to get my hands on the console.
Why would the xbox one x version have an issue that even the regular xbox one version doesn't?
TGO
Hype Train conductor. Works harder than it steams.
This the same finding I had when I compared my direct capture from my PS4 pro to the capture in the other thread which someone just posted
The comparison shot was fussy and washed out but mine was vivid and sharp