Well, I don't know who expects anybody to look at a PS4 Pro to Xbox One X comparison and come away thinking they need to throw their Pro in the trash. The X is an upgrade over the S. So a comparison of footage to say "Is it worth the upgrade?" should be vanilla One to X.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Rise of the Tomb Raider 4K comparison: Xbox one X vs PS4Pro vs PC
- Thread starter Poster#1
- Start date
Well, I don't know who expects anybody to look at a PS4 Pro to Xbox One X comparison and come away thinking they need to throw their Pro in the trash. The X is an upgrade over the S. So a comparison of footage to say "Is it worth the upgrade?" should be vanilla One to X.
Mr. Phellps
Member
Xbox One version suffers from noticeable input lag. All versions handled by Nixxes (Xbox 360, PS4 and Pro) don't.
So there's some hope that, since Nixxes is helping with the Xbox One X enhancements, this will be fixed.
Fredrik
Member
Haven't played it in 4K but the resolution was never the problem imo, the PC version looks hires enough in 1080p too but also kind of lifeless in comparison, the extra animations for the vegetation and weather etc on DE makes a huge difference.
nismopower
Member
Whats next comparing original ps4 vs xbx and saying xbx looks better then pc...
Oh no wait how about comparing the pro vs xbox one s. Like philly spencer said it was comparing to....
Oh no wait how about comparing the pro vs xbox one s. Like philly spencer said it was comparing to....
Shpeshal Nick
aka Collingwood
Looking forward to jumping back in.
Fredrik
Member
From another thread:
This table is rather surprising after all the input lag talk on consoles, especially the XB1 version.
So I don't know, is it really the input lag that is the problem? (It never bothered me but I'm not a frame counter type of guy)
I agree, (Though the tradeoff is that Definitive edition Lara is lifeless
) but considering how much other things are better on the PC version, acting like they're worlds apart is a huge hyperbole.
rodrigolfp
Haptic Gamepads 4 Life
holy jesus. this numbers cant be right. dat vsync?
In the dev interview with IGN. The dev said. 60fps most of the time"
The video isn't by DF, just some rando on YouTube. Hence so many posts saying they'll wait for Eurogamer.
Duchess O'Death
Member
Lol did they just turn off hair physics on PC and say look at the hair xbox looks better? Wtf lmao!
Fredrik
Member
The textures and hair physics? To me it didn't change the outcome, PS4 still had the prettier version, imo.I agree, (Though the tradeoff is that Definitive edition Lara is lifeless
But this is a special case, it was almost a remake while the PC version was based on the 360 version. Same thing happened with DOA5LR btw. I'm sure there are other examples as well.
With Rise it's a bit different, to me it just looks like the XBX version have the Ultra settings applied, and the PC version isn't running at Ultra settings in the video for some odd reason. And like I said, the framerate is still unknown.
Fredrik
Member
No idea tbh, but it's from NX Gamer so I guess they're right enough. And TV lag is excluded in these figures.
TechnicPuppet
Nothing! I said nothing!
When DF do proper comparisons what PC setup will they use?
No point comparing the Pro/1X to a $1000 PC.
No point comparing the Pro/1X to a $1000 PC.
Garrett Hawke
Member
When they first showed it on PS4 it was missing fire effects in a tomb near the end of the game. Just means they're still optimising.
WHAT?? It's only an alpha?
Amazing
Garrett Hawke
Member
agrihd
I think X1X will have ultra PC textures + some other features but won't have anything new added a la TRDE (although I still wish that had come to PC).
Caayn
Member
To be fair. After having read the input lag article by Digital Foundry from last month I doubt the accuracy of those numbers. Take H5 for example, DF came around at 63.0ms whereas NXGamer had 125ms. Not a jab at NXGamer just a weird thing I and others noticed.
Respective GAF threads: DF, NX
It's still interesting to see how large or small the gap is between these "premium" consoles and a high-end PC.
rodrigolfp
Haptic Gamepads 4 Life
price is irrelevant since pc is not about perfomance in games only
Fredrik
Member
The specific numbers don't matter for this discussion though since all versions were compared the same "wrong" (?) way. The XB1 version clearly doesn't have horrible input lag compared to the PS4 versions at least, maybe compared to PC though which isn't tested here.
Caayn
Member
Point taken.
paragonpro
Banned
Oh boy, the next couple months of x v pro dawn of gaf is going to be fun. That being said, i think the x version looks great, but that pc comparison definitely isnt showing the game at its full potential. Lets keep in mind that, impressive as it may be, this is still a 500 dollar box that will always pale in comparison to what a 1000 plus dollar machine can do. I say this as someone who pre ordered an xbox one x
CyberPunked
Member
Why? Surely the correct comparison is showing what each platform is capable of -- you don't handicap one platform due to the drawbacks of the others.
Nah the fact that they made Lara look like a supermodel who can't emote in the remaster.
I think the PS4 version is prettier in some ways, but not IQ, they can touch it up but you can't do anything to make 1080p look sharper than 4K.
That's of course, not even mentioning the framerate. It's not 60fps on PS4 as much as people assume that it is.
Hawk269
Member
Is it not a bit ignorant to come to this conclusion based on 1 image of an incomplete version to cast aside what the advantages that the Xbox One X can provide?
In addition, the capture is taken from a video, which has some compression and artifacts as well. But go ahead and disregard the advantages for something that is still 2+ months out and only one screenshot to compare.
Lashley
Why does he wear the mask!?
Why compare the Xbox one X to the cheaper PS4 pro then, going by your logic
This is a shit comparison video btw
Garrett Hawke
Member
Huh?
Mr Moose
Member
No it wasn't.
http://press.na.square-enix.com/products/p286/rise-of-the-tomb-raider
I think they quoted the wrong person lol.
Lashley
Why does he wear the mask!?
quoted wrong person
longdi
Banned
The first thing that stood out when i watched the XBX trailer, was how janky the animations looked among the cleaned up visuals. I guess MS should asked that a big part their moneyhat goes into improving the animations. That would have show up more of the power potential. Now its like putting fresh coat of paint over an old motor
Head.spawn
Junior Member
What kind of shit post is this? It's the same animations on PS4/PS4 Pro/PC/XBO/360? (I dunno, haven't played that version).
You expect them to redo all of the games animations for a free update? Thats