• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The Curious Rise of Scientology in Taiwan

Status
Not open for further replies.

Piecake

Member
Scientology around the world is in broad retreat, but to be in Taiwan you would never know that. In an area slightly smaller than the combined size of Delaware and Maryland, with a total population of 23.4 million—roughly the same as that of the New York metropolitan area—Taiwan has 15 Scientology missions and churches. Per capita, it’s one of the most Scientology-friendly countries on earth. The island serves as a major source of donations and new members for the church, which has capitalized on L. Ron Hubbard’s early suggestions that he was a new Buddha. In a sign of Taiwan’s importance to the church, Scientology chief David Miscavige also attended the 2013 Kaohsiung reopening of the hotel as a Scientology megachurch.

According to documents described as leaks from Scientology's main database of internal statistics and published by Mike Rinder, a high-ranking defector, Taiwanese Scientology missions were three of the top 10 cumulative fundraisers for the church in 2014. In June 2015, according to data published on the Scientology-watching blog Sec-Check, the Taipei mission tied for first among Scientology churches around the world for weekly “stats” reflecting sales of books, hours of counseling, and new recruits. (Asked about these materials, a Scientology spokesperson described them as “stolen documents.” The church said Rinder was “dismissed from his position and expelled because of his dishonesty.”)

Taiwanese who want to understand outside perspectives on Scientology face a basic obstacle: Most critical articles on the church, and most forums where ex-Scientologists offer advice to people leaving the church, are in English.

Taiwan’s own media, while boisterously independent compared to mainland China’s, have shied from negative coverage of the church. While gossip-friendly newspapers have reported briefly on matters related to the divorce of celebrity Scientologist Tom Cruise, I could find few that had written on the group’s expansion on Taiwan’s shores. One of the few Chinese-language blogs that publishes critical items on Scientology is run by Anita Hsu, the Taiwanese defector.

As subtitled versions of the documentary Going Clear appear online, Scientology may gradually lose momentum in Taiwan, but Yang is not optimistic. In Taiwan, at least, the group’s affiliated organization—the anti-drug program Narconon, the Citizens Commission for Human Rights (an anti-psychiatry organization which claims to expose the field as “an industry of death”), and the Youth for Human Rights program, which promotes Hubbard writings alongside the UN’s Universal Declaration of Human Rights—continue to reach students, receive positive media coverage, and hold events with the government’s support, including meetings with the former president.

http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2016/07/scientology-in-taiwan/493493/

Sorry Taiwan. Pretty crazy that Scientology groups actually receive government praise and support.

Honestly didn't realize this crazy bullshit had any sort of traction outside of the US
 

msdstc

Incredibly Naive
Eww just let it die. Luckily David miscaivage is a total psychopath because it seems he's opened a lot of eyes.
 

shira

Member
Honestly didn't realize this crazy bullshit had any sort of traction outside of the US

Scams exist everywhere. People will give money to almost anything if they get something out of it.

Look at all these people buying rhino penis powder.
 

BocoDragon

or, How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Realize This Assgrab is Delicious
Bet ya this cult gains a foothold in many odd markets you wouldn't expect, and in 100s of years it comes to be seen as a legitimate world religion.
 

Ogodei

Member
Bet ya this cult gains a foothold in many odd markets you wouldn't expect, and in 100s of years it comes to be seen as a legitimate world religion.

The belief system is no more or less crazy than the belief systems of major world religions today were seen at the time. The problem is the power structure. None of the major religions started off as an explicit scheme to bilk their followers out of money. Other tie-ins, sure (like how many religions started as being state-sponsored, like Shinto), but cases like the Catholic "pay your way into heaven" schemes took 100s of years to develop in other religions and weren't anywhere near the ground floor.
 

BocoDragon

or, How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Realize This Assgrab is Delicious
The belief system is no more or less crazy than the belief systems of major world religions today were seen at the time. The problem is the power structure. None of the major religions started off as an explicit scheme to bilk their followers out of money. Other tie-ins, sure (like how many religions started as being state-sponsored, like Shinto), but cases like the Catholic "pay your way into heaven" schemes took 100s of years to develop in other religions and weren't anywhere near the ground floor.
Other religions have started by demanding submission to a particular political structure and even demand tithes. Think about the Zakat tax in Islam. You sure that other religions aren't about bilking money (and power in general)?

But I do agree that Scientology is one of the more boldly cynical scam origins of a religion... And we have the modern sources to prove it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom