xion4360
Member
as long as the same game is available on 2 or more platforms comparisons are going to be the thing, and IMO the only time they are even valid... otherwise its irrelevant to me.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
The Witcher 3: PS4 vs XB1 video (Gamersyde)
- Thread starter viveks86
- Start date
- Status
as long as the same game is available on 2 or more platforms comparisons are going to be the thing, and IMO the only time they are even valid... otherwise its irrelevant to me.
Grimgrillz
Banned
Is it possible this dynamic res is just 1080p during cut scenes and 900p gameplay?
xion4360
Member
yeah and thats not to say one is better or worse, it just so happens that you have a realtime lighting solution applied and thats always going to end up creating slight differences.
Its more useful to look at textures, resolution, AA... performance..
dont think its applied that way, like how some games lock framerate at 30 for cutscenes but unlocked or 60 for gameplay... I think dynamic resolution is based on performance load, so when its getting heavy it drops to 900 to try and keep performance up.
Possible, but most likely it is truly dynamic, just like resolution changes in Wolfenstein: TNO.
Yeah but there could also be situations where it can't entirely handle 1080p but the game switches to it anyway providing the frame rate doesn't drop below a certain number.
LOL was thinking the same thing
Surely though they havent opted for dynamic res over both axes?
ps3ud0 8)
Yeah, it's anyone guess. Did notice framerate suffered in the cutscenes though.
Black Republican
Member
PC wins
Better solution is to stab everyones eyes out then all will look the same, especially the x1 version.
93xfan
Banned
Nah, I have a ps4 as well.
hope they fix the frame rate on the Xbox one version though. Maybe let the dynamic resolution go a bit lower when necessary
Are you saying that only blind people can't tell the difference between them? Because that is an inherent fallacy.
No, he's saying, he'd rather render everyone incapable so they'll all shut up. I can get on board.
Fair enough. I'm all about that life.
MR ARCADE FOREVER
Member
Eagle eyes to see any difference
xion4360
Member
that would be a pretty boring world... you gotta spice up life somehow, and a little online this look better than based on evidence is preferable to trading blows over things lacking principle.
basically, its harmless fun...unless you get mad or have an agenda to defend one platform in which case, im on board with you.
Wrong thread, joking, or just lack the vocabulary to contribute?
ArkhamFantasy
Member
I'm not worried about graphics in this genre, i just want stable 30 FPS.
Bornstellar
Member
Looks like it's really splitting hairs, but probably the best comparison shot is at 1:17
Comparing the arms, XB1 looks a bit blurry compared to PS4. But really, who cares.
Whoa - didn't even realize that had both at first.
AzureFlame
Member
xion4360
Member
sorry, you will be disappointed if you want to from either console version.
some games are good enough to be played despite some shit, sounds like this is a really good game. If it interested you maybe dont dismiss it.
Every once in a while though, these practices need a little healthy dose of getting shit on.
nelsonroyale
Member
Looks like it's really splitting hairs, but probably the best comparison shot is at 1:17
Comparing the arms, XB1 looks a bit blurry compared to PS4. But really, who cares.
I can see it there. It is subtle, but the right side is a shade blurier.
psychotron
Member
Gamersyde videos were enough for me to pick PS4 over XB1. Pre-ordered digitally. All in on this mother.
xion4360
Member
its tiny tho, and chances are you wont be too sensitive to the dynamic resolution so screenshot comparisons are kind of useless.. the game looks nearly identical to completely identical in that regard, so the only worthy comparison is one in motion, that shows the performance.
nelsonroyale
Member
Sure. I expect the PS4 version to take it in performance based on the vids I have seen so far. Both seem to struggle abit though.
Apoleptica
Banned
The white stitches are slightly blurrier on ps4, but the chainmail is slightly shinier.Looks like it's really splitting hairs, but probably the best comparison shot is at 1:17
Comparing the arms, XB1 looks a bit blurry compared to PS4. But really, who cares.
WeAreStarStuff
Member
Both look good.
Jeezus, this is embarrassing.
Looks waaaay better on PC, why would someone buy this on consoles?
Jeezus, this is embarrassing.
WordsintheWater
Member
Looks a bit blurrier on Xbox One, but they both look great, can't go wrong with either
xion4360
Member
dont see white stitches anywhere, but im guessing you mean the stitches on the leather? there's no difference there other than angles. Textures look exactly the same. Its hard to even distinguish the two separate frames in that shot
Looks like it's really splitting hairs, but probably the best comparison shot is at 1:17
Comparing the arms, XB1 looks a bit blurry compared to PS4. But really, who cares.
swazzyswess
Member
random trees in both versions look they're caught in tiny hurricanes or something.... wtf?
No need to apologize lol, I'm just glad someone got it.Oh damn, didn't notice he said dynamic framerate lol
Sorry Noobcraft, that was clever
User 479360
Banned
Looks practically identical to me, other than maybe a couple of small differences. I really don't care about that type of thing too much, and just go for the version I want to play on.
MR ARCADE FOREVER
Member
Haha
- Status