-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
The Witcher 3: PS4 vs XB1 video (Gamersyde)
- Thread starter viveks86
- Start date
- Status
I made very clear (or at least I thought so) in the news that I did this video because people asked me to, but honestly it doesn't show much if anything besides some differences in framerate.
I don't like doing these comparison videos, so don't look too much into that one.
As for which version is better, the PS4 version is much smoother in terms of framerate than XB1, so the choice is clear. We'll have the replay of tonight's live stream up in a hour os so, and in this one we switched from the X1 version to PS4, and the difference is very noticeable.
It's doesn't mean the PS4 version is perfect though, it's very rarely locked at 30 fps from what I saw (first 90 minutes of the game, end of prologue).
Of course, we don't know if the current patch available for both consoles (v 1.01) is the day one patch or if there will be another before tuesday, but I doubt anyone would be willing to get a new patch live this close to launch...
I will be playing on PS4, so I am glad that it tends to run smoother. Thanks for that.
So, stupid dig at the x1 version aside, this is true?
The PC version obviously.
Chobel
Member
Yes
Dictator93
Member
the xb1 version has more feeling and emotion. as the camera pans and stutters you can literally feel the weight and nervousness in the cameraman's heart as he stares at the terrifying griffin. the ps4 version is fake and gamey with how the camera moves smoothly.
xb1 is the best translation of the books due to this fact.
xb1 is the best translation of the books due to this fact.
Xaero Gravity
NEXT LEVEL lame™
Well there are other factors, not just the ones he mentioned. Controller preference and the CE coming with exclusive physical items being a few examples. I know I was torn on which console version to get before settling on the PS4 one.
Chobel
Member
They said they'll think about it, they didn't confirm it' coming, and it just sounded like PR talk to me.
But even if this is true, you'll be waiting for months and the result still won't outperform PS4.
LMAO!
Never seen them state that for Xbox or PC. All they've really said is that they'll think about it when DX12 is widely available, which is the same thing they said about DX11 support for W2 and that never happened. So its possible, but I wouldn't read too much into it.
Fortinbras
Member
A friend who's already playing the X1 version just told me that there's constant stutter during gameplay.
So I guess the Xbox patch didn't fix the frame rate?
So I guess the Xbox patch didn't fix the frame rate?
You shouldn't have to explain yourself man, forget them. For a game thats pretty much identical, there are other legitimate reasons when the gap between the 2 are so small. Controller, eco system, friends are some I dont think anyone can argue about.
Hahaha
Careful. I once got banned for suggesting console bickering is silly when a superior PC version exists.
I'm pretty sure there's suppost to be another patch on launch day, though I may be wrong.
Pliny The Elder
Member
they look nearly identical except for slight blurry IQ on X1, shouldn't really make it a big thing as to which one to get except for the actual performance. Regardless, PC FTW! can't wait for this game to be officially released.
Shin-Ra
Junior Member
So framerate consistency and input commands aren't important to you any more?
Superior PS4 touchpad features, analog tightness, battery included!
Apoleptica
Banned
Wow the game is not out yet, we don't even have concrete professional comparisons and the ps4 fanboys are already shitting on the x1 version. Choosing a version due to a preference in controller or other console feature is perfectly fine people. And a possible dx12 patch has been common knowledge for months now, though it isn't guaranteed and might not even change anything.
Warnen
Don't pass gaas, it is your Destiny!
Like I said if there is any major differences I'll just get the ps4 version on next week, prob won't beable to play it till the weekend anyways. Xbox version shipped from Best Buys but got one way to work I can return and swap it out if needed.
A few fps won't bug me, screen tearing on the other hand is a personal pet peeve of mine and if Xbox was more then ps4 I'll drop it instantly.
Nope, the launch patch is 1.01 and it's been released for both versions.
Piku_Ringo
Banned
Looks amazing on both, can't wait to play it.
Hes taking a jab but the truth is probably not too off. X1 version looked blurrier throughout the videos.
This is pretty much the main thing to take home. Sub 30 FPS. Sad.
Night Angel
Member
No it's not, it's fucking endemic in the modern gaming industry.
Looks > frames is a terrible idea that seems to be the rule of thumb.
Jesus, already the fighting starts.
SUPERIOR TOUCHPAD FEATURES!
DX12 SECRET SAUCE!
I'd say CD Projekt did the best job they could of done for the console versions, still looks like an amazing game and will happily play it non-stop for the coming days.
SUPERIOR TOUCHPAD FEATURES!
DX12 SECRET SAUCE!
I'd say CD Projekt did the best job they could of done for the console versions, still looks like an amazing game and will happily play it non-stop for the coming days.
It does not surprise me considering how massive and detailed the world is. This is one ambitious game.
R3TRODYCE
Member
I agree.
Shin-Ra
Junior Member
Don't forget you're more likely to have more friends on PS4 and you can chat wired without a paid controller add-on!Jesus, already the fighting starts.
SUPERIOR TOUCHPAD FEATURES!
DX12 SECRET SAUCE!
Chobel
Member
I'm not saying don't buy XBO version, you have some legitimate reasons for choosing it, and in the end it's your decision. However that DX12 patch thing is dumb reason.
xion4360
Member
no one is shitting on xb1 version because of fanboy anything, the framerate on xb1 is just bad. Choosing one version over another on controller preference IS perfectly fine when the versions are otherwise identical or close enough.. that is really not the case here, anyone saying the game is identical is only looking at screenshots and ignoring the obvious performance difference. when a game runs bad to begin with, why go for the obviously even worse version!? its clear cut bias in that case and its fine but be honest and dont call anyone a fanboy when they point it out.
Super helpful in a single player game.
astroturfing
Member
so this will be the fourth big "AAA" game in a row that i play on my PS4 that stutters and drops frames. nice gen we have here :/
GTAV (not that bad though), AC: Unity and Bloodborne were the others.
Flying Toaster
Member
Regardless of PS4 or Xbox One I am just glad this game is coming to the consoles. More people need a chance to play it.
I double dipped. PS4/PC. But regardless I am glad is on the One and I am glad more people get a chance to play it.
I double dipped. PS4/PC. But regardless I am glad is on the One and I am glad more people get a chance to play it.
pics or it didn't happen
Shin-Ra
Junior Member
You don't chat and listen to custom music through your single player games? You haven't lived.
Totally unique to this gen.
publicpwnerer
Member
Is there a big framerate difference between the two?
I have no issues with the res, as I have the XB1 currently setup and I'm not wanting to swap it out for the PS4 until Batman, but framerate is inexcusable.
I have no issues with the res, as I have the XB1 currently setup and I'm not wanting to swap it out for the PS4 until Batman, but framerate is inexcusable.
Guille4000
Neo Member
So far there's an Xbox patch of 550 mb, it's suposed to get another patch on day one with the dynamic resolution.
Warnen
Don't pass gaas, it is your Destiny!
I agree, just thought that if it was coming might make up for the slight difference as is.
If DF puts up a good comperision before I get around to playing it I'll open to either at this point.
Hell why can't Sony just allow external hdd and turn off that fucking light on the controller... That would fix my issues with the ps4.
Saucycarpdog
Member
You really need to settle down, people can choose their platform of chose. Jeez.
xion4360
Member
dynamic res is not being patched in, its already there. the game is sure to get more patches, but the day 1 patch is probably 1.01 and thats already out.
Chobel
Member
You sure about that? Because AFAIK this 550MB patch is the day one patch.
Jawbreaker
Member
The frame rate difference is pretty noticeable when the camera is panning. I'm going PC on this one, but from what I've seen and heard in regards to early impressions, the PS4 version is the one to get on consoles. That shouldn't be surprising given the disparity between the systems, but we've had some anomalies this gen so far where the XBO bested the PS4 in one aspect or another (missing AF in particular).
astroturfing
Member
fuck that so hard. i HATE people trying to invite me to a chat while i'm trying to stay immersed in an RPG or whatever. why the hell would i want to talk to others if i'm focused on a single player game? i tried that once and the other person got mad because i didn't speak much... well what the hell do you expect me to talk about, what items i'm picking up or what? WHAT? i'm trying to concentrate on this boss fight, shut the fuck up about drama at work for the love of god..
it's madness i tell you. and custom music over the actual game soundtrack? more insanity.
According to blimblim who did this video, it's much smoother on PS4.
You're mistaken, the launch patch 1.01 has been released already.
- Status