-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
You are on your last life. What do you prefer your life counter displaying: x1 or x0?
- Thread starter chaobreaker
- Start date
Version 3.0
Member
But it is an extra life counter, at least in some cases, and I prefer it that way. There's no reason it should have to explicitly state that. In fact, I'd say the opposite - it should explicitly state if it's NOT an extra lives counter. It's counter-intuitive to count the life of my on-screen player in the counter as well. That means it's the only counter up there that doesn't go to zero.
theechrisfox
Member
Logic. Its good for you!
Why would you vote if you don't care?
Nocturnowl
Member
One of the great things about x0 is when you're not sure if it's there or not, as the x1 life fades into oblivion you hope to the gaming gods that the fabled zero life can bestow you with one more chance at redemption and on its reveal a feeling of relief washes over you. Then immediately following this things get tense, now you know for sure that this is it, the last shot, there's no more lives left to lose.
x0 has a feel of finality and adds a greater sense of weight to the proceedings.
x0 has a feel of finality and adds a greater sense of weight to the proceedings.
In most games where you have a lives indicator, you gain extra lives by collecting an item that looks the exact same as the indicator. Losing a life substracts one from the counter to bring your ass back on the field, just like a phoenix feather. So it makes sense to associate the counter with the amount of items you have left "in your pocket".
When you have zero left, you won't have another chance to come back, so better stack this shit or you'll be gone. That's why 0x makes sense.
When you have zero left, you won't have another chance to come back, so better stack this shit or you'll be gone. That's why 0x makes sense.
Exactly.
Ambience7817x
Member
x0
I see the counter as extra lives. If I'm on my last life i want to see x0 because i have no more lives left. Any game with x1 confuses me
I see the counter as extra lives. If I'm on my last life i want to see x0 because i have no more lives left. Any game with x1 confuses me
LurkerPrime
Member
I'd prefer x0, so there's no ambiguity about anything.
Zoidberg Jesus
Member
I like 0x, that way there's no confusion if I have 1 or 2 lives left. If I'm still alive and I have 0x, I know for sure that I'm on my last life.
AuthenticM
Member
x0
because I do not have any spare lives, or spare coints to "insert" to have an extra life.
because I do not have any spare lives, or spare coints to "insert" to have an extra life.
Rage quitting at x1 lives when you die in an auto save game.
If the save is corrupted the cat got written out of existence.
valkillmore
Member
Apparently I'm in the minority. Math, people. 0 x anything is always 0. If that's true, how am I still alive playing if I have 0 lives. Including the one I'm supposedly playing with at the moment.
Backup lives. How many more times you can die without getting game over. Basically it's all about if you want to include the live you're actively using.
strangedopamine
Member
x0 all the way.
I played Crash Bandicoot a lot when I was younger and that used x0. Also I always knew it signified extra or spare lives. I felt tricked when I first played Super Mario World a few years later and getting a game over with x1 left.
I played Crash Bandicoot a lot when I was younger and that used x0. Also I always knew it signified extra or spare lives. I felt tricked when I first played Super Mario World a few years later and getting a game over with x1 left.
Spring-Loaded
Member
It should say this below the GAF logo.
TheGreyHulk
Member
x0
I read x1 as saying I have 1 life available if I die.
I read x1 as saying I have 1 life available if I die.
valkillmore
Member
Yeah that's pretty much right. Or if they're explicitly called 'extra lives,' in which case it would make sense to support 0x.
It's so funny this is a topic. I've often thought about it lol.
sanji_blue
Member
I can't vote, but if I could I would choose x0. It's easier to understand that I have no lives left.
SteveWinwood
Member
X1
BECAUSE REASONS
BECAUSE REASONS
To Far Away Times
Member
x1.
As in you have your one life left, that's it.
As in you have your one life left, that's it.
I was about to say the same thing. I actually like x1 better just because... I don't know, but as long as x0 exists we should use that to clear things up.
One good trick is to always check how many lives you start with. 3 and 5 are common starting amounts, so if you start at x2 or x4 you probably have x0, while is it says x3 or x5 then x1 is probably your last chance.
binaryrevolt
Member
It has gotta be x0.
I've been conditioned to think of this as extra lives or "free men".
I've been conditioned to think of this as extra lives or "free men".
serversurfer
Member
The best thing about this debate is,
even when the x1 people don't get their way, they're still better off and never have cause to complain. 
Sleeping Lesson
Member
Nobody is going to confuse what x0 means. x1 leaves room for interpretation, and is inconsistent across games.
93xfan
Banned
Absolutely.
I cant believe this conversation has gone on for so long lol! XD
But like I said earlier in this thread: anything times 0 is = 0.
Therefore;
1 character x1 = 1
1 character x0 = 0
Because of this, I prefer x1. Because it is your current player character times 1. I think of it mathematically.
EDIT: What everyone else said about x0 being better I also agree with though. There is no confusion. But I think there is confusion because everyone was reading it wrong.
Ah, I see, so life is just an item to you?
Colorful Vocabulary
Member
I'm gonna have to say x1.
I see it as which life I'm on and not how many lives I have left.
I see it as which life I'm on and not how many lives I have left.
Wowfunhappy
Member
x0.
In a perfect world where everything made logical sense, it would be x1. But since some video games do x1 and some do x0, I prefer x0, since when I'm on x0, I KNOW for SURE that it's really my last chance.
In a perfect world where everything made logical sense, it would be x1. But since some video games do x1 and some do x0, I prefer x0, since when I'm on x0, I KNOW for SURE that it's really my last chance.