• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Kotaku: XB1 Slim 2016, More Powerful XB1 Scorpio/VR 2017, iterative boxes from now on

Why is it that every thread on incremental hardware there is this slippery slope of yearly refreshes? Makes no sense.

How long till new games dont work on new consoles? Also what happens when a new tech comes out.. that obsoletes the old.. do they have to stick with the old?
 

DeepEnigma

Gold Member
Digital Foundry Office:

anigif_enhanced-buzz-xksc5.gif


Guaranteed klicks for next 10 years for them.

Advertisers are flooding into their email inboxes as we speak, lol.
 
What does that have to do with the tools? Games run differently on every graphics card but PCs still exist.

I feel like you are being obtuse on purpose.

Or you have no idea what you're talking about, backpedalling to PC to try and change the topic and won't admit Phones and consoles are nowhere near the same with what they do, how they are marketed, and what the strategy is.

Phones and consoles aren't the same, I have to look and wonder what to buy between the two PS4's, I can by a G5 or a Priv and virtually everything will run the same, the devs will have the same tolls, not more powerful ones that they will likely prioritize, and producing and shipping phones doesn't cost anywhere near as much as a console launch. I doubt that if sony had 3 Xperia phones flop at $500 price ranges it would have done anything near a 3rd of what the PS3 did.
 

Markoman

Member
Where does Nintendo fall in all of this? Kind of looks like Sony and MS are squeezing them out of the .5 upgrade game.

People hoping for better 3rd party support for NX. Keep dreaming. If devs really have to spend more money/time/resources on multiple versions on the better selling machines, they will drop NX before they even touch it.
 

prwxv3

Member
How long till new games dont work on new consoles? Also what happens when a new tech comes out.. that obsoletes the old.. do they have to stick with the old?

If I had to guess PS4 vanilla will be phased out once ps5 hits. So you have about 6-7 years for a consoles life. PSneo will be phased out once PS5.5 gets released ect.
 

icespide

Banned
Or you have no idea what you're talking about, backpedalling to PC to try and change the topic and won't admit Phones and consoles are nowhere near the same with what they do, how they are marketed, and what the strategy is.

Phones and consoles aren't the same, I have to look and wonder what to buy between the two PS4's, I can by a G5 or a Priv and virtually everything will run the same, the devs will have the same tolls, not more powerful ones that they will likely prioritize, and producing and shipping phones doesn't cost anywhere near as much as a console launch. I doubt that if sony had 3 Xperia phones flop at $500 price ranges it would have done anything near a 3rd of what the PS3 did.

let's just clear this up. No one will ever design another console like the PS3 again, you should stop using it as an example. the PS3 is the poster child on how not to design a console
 

kiguel182

Member
Or you have no idea what you're talking about, backpedalling to PC to try and change the topic and won't admit Phones and consoles are nowhere near the same with what they do, how they are marketed, and what the strategy is.

Phones and consoles aren't the same, I have to look and wonder what to buy between the two PS4's, I can by a G5 or a Priv and virtually everything will run the same, the devs will have the same tolls, not more powerful ones that they will likely prioritize, and producing and shipping phones doesn't cost anywhere near as much as a console launch. I doubt that if sony had 3 Xperia phones flop at $500 price ranges it would have done anything near a 3rd of what the PS3 did.

Dude, clearly you don't have a grasp on reality and are creating scenarios that don't exist to prove a point. You are all over the place.

You have to look for what to buy on phones all the time! Like, what the hell are you on about? There's no point in talking to you since you are so far removed from reality it's not even funny.

Phones have all ranges of power. With apps not running on every phone the same. I seriously don't get your point (because well, you don't really have one).

I'm done with this conversation. No point in it and your rambling about the laptop doesn't help making you more credible.
 
That's not the same CPU or GPU. Also, the game runs bad.

http://www.notebookcheck.net/AMD-Radeon-R6-Carrizo-Benchmarks.144290.0.html

Here are the benchmarks for the setup you showed. It's bad and way worse than a PS4.

EDIT: Also, those are actual benchmarks and not "I believe" or "something similar".

It's only like a percentage off.

Also I can get different benchmarks at a different site, why the heck are you using benchmarks? They don't mean anything.

That's not the same APU, but also, thanks for confirming it can't run the game as well as an Xbox One

It's like you guys choose not to read things, I said in a previous post the two aren't far off.

Also yes, that video does show it running worse than the XO version of the game. But not THAT off.

I will admit that it won't run better than the two consoles.

HOWEVERE if the Laptop can run this than for the same price you know you can get a PC for about that same price that runs games better than the XO/PS4.

But I will admit I was wrong in saying that it (PC) being better than the "PS4k rumored specs is wrong.
 

prwxv3

Member
let's just clear this up. No one will ever design another console like the PS3 again, you should stop using it as an example. the PS3 is the poster child on how not to design a console

It was a terrible console design wise. The revisionist history with the ps3 (games lineup and hardware) has been really fucking annoying recently.
 
Phones have all ranges of power. With apps not running on every phone the same. I seriously don't get your point (because well, you don't really have one).

The vast majority of newer mid range and high end phones (even ones older than the newer mids) run apps and games virtually the same, when they rarely do the difference aren't that significant for the majority of games and software. The exceptiosn are the games aiming high that can't run on newer mid tier phones, but likely can run on all the higher ones.

We are talking about "significant" differences, on devices more expensive to produce than Phones.

If you still think consoles are phones the same I can't help you, I'm sorry but I have nothing more to say. It's illogical to compare the two.
 

icespide

Banned
Phones have all ranges of power. With apps not running on every phone the same. I seriously don't get your point (because well, you don't really have one).

The vast majority of newer mid range and high end phones (even ones older than the newer mids) run apps and games virtually the same, when they rarely do the difference aren't that significant for the majority of games and software. The exceptiosn are the games aiming high that can't run on newer mid tier phones, but likely can run on all the higher ones.

We are talking about "significant" differences, on devices more expensive to produce than Phones.

If you still think consoles are phones the same I can't help you, I'm sorry but I have nothing more to say. It's illogical to compare the two.

are they?
 
let's just clear this up. No one will ever design another console like the PS3 again, you should stop using it as an example. the PS3 is the poster child on how not to design a console

The PS3 is an example of how consoles are expensive, it's a perfect example, and I can switch it with the 360 which also had to take hits at first and it'll be the same story. The Xbox 360 is another consoles that when you go through marketing, production, copying, software, OS, retail, etc. It too costs more than phones do to release.

I mean look at how many phone companies are barely making money that have multip phones that are STILL in business?

You know what, you guys can just keep doing these consoles-phone comparisons. Whatever.
 

icespide

Banned
The PS3 is an example of how consoles are expensive, it's a perfect example, and I can switch it with the 360 which also had to take hits at first and it'll be the same story. The Xbox 360 is another consoles that when you go through marketing, production, copying, software, OS, retail, etc. It too costs more than phones do to release.

I mean look at how many phone companies are barely making money that have multip phones that are STILL in business?

You know what, you guys can just keep doing these consoles-phone comparisons. Whatever.

the PS3 and Xbox 360 are perfect examples of the type of consoles that will never be made again
 

Tookay

Member
Frankly, I think Sony and MS are going to have a hell of a time explaining this and not confusing somebody. Changing the 30 year-old ingrained notion of a console isn't going to be easy.
 

EvB

Member
Or you have no idea what you're talking about, backpedalling to PC to try and change the topic and won't admit Phones and consoles are nowhere near the same with what they do, how they are marketed, and what the strategy is.

Phones and consoles aren't the same, I have to look and wonder what to buy between the two PS4's, I can by a G5 or a Priv and virtually everything will run the same, the devs will have the same tolls, not more powerful ones that they will likely prioritize, and producing and shipping phones doesn't cost anywhere near as much as a console launch. I doubt that if sony had 3 Xperia phones flop at $500 price ranges it would have done anything near a 3rd of what the PS3 did.

You were saying?
ownedk3spd.gif
 

Pancake Mix

Copied someone else's pancake recipe
All Microsoft first-party releases on PC? That's an awful, awful idea for Xbox..

Also, trying to make consoles phones isn't going to go over well.
 

krang

Member
Digital Foundry Office:

anigif_enhanced-buzz-xksc5.gif


Guaranteed klicks for next 10 years for them.

I feel like it's the opposite. There'll be so many comparisons and convoluted "winning" scenarios that it'll just fade into obscurity when nobody can be bothered to unpick it all.

That's a good thing, IMO.
 

DeepEnigma

Gold Member
I feel like it's the opposite. There'll be so many comparisons and convoluted "winning" scenarios that it'll just fade into obscurity when nobody can be bothered to unpick it all.

That's a good thing, IMO.

Nah, people always need something to justify their purchase. Even if it is an extra blade of grass, or the like. Now the madness will be even more insane.
 
Done with this thread, we have not only people saying consoles=Smartphones (where a lot of them run things exactly the same and don't take away from tohers outside exclsuive features, the exact opposite of PS4k and PS4 based on rumored specs and other info) which is already one of the must nonsensical things I ever heard, but people think that if the Xbox 360 at $350 and Iphone 5 $650, that Iphone 5's are more costly to support that's not how it works.

If Microsoft released 3 $650 WIndows Phones at the times, in place of the 360, and they all sold 100k in totoal in 2 years, that would still not have lsot MS anywhere near as much money as the first years of the 360.

Consoles are more expensive, the base price of an item on the shelf has nothing to do with its overall costs.

But if people still want to believe that iterative consoles will work because =phones, they fine, believe! I give up.
 

Kaako

Felium Defensor
Well, I guess UWP is here to stay huh? :)

Oh, the UWP threads will be glorious (jk). lololol
Do you think this MS, Facebook & Oculus partnership will further strengthen the UWP by tying in exclusive(s) and exclusive deals to UWP?

And

Do you see this as a good thing overall for consumers?
 

Pancake Mix

Copied someone else's pancake recipe
Define Xbox.
Because it has a new definition now.

The box itself...which will apparently now change every year. Good luck with that idea.

No it will be good. After the bomb that was QB and the underperformance of H5 MS needs to sell more of their games. Most PC enthusiasts don't buy consoles anyway.

Maybe, but Sony and Nintendo don't make that dumb decision. Why get an Xbox now?

It might be more desirable for Microsoft because they have an established PC storefront though, but still..
 

DeepEnigma

Gold Member
Done with this thread, we have not only people saying consoles=Smartphones (where a lot of them run things exactly the same and don't take away from tohers outside exclsuive features, the exact opposite of PS4k and PS4 based on rumored specs and other info) which is already one of the must nonsensical things I ever heard, but people think that if the Xbox 360 at $350 and Iphone 5 $650, that Iphone 5's are more costly to support that's not how it works.

If Microsoft released 3 $650 WIndows Phones at the times, in place of the 360, and they all sold 100k in totoal in 2 years, that would still not have lsot MS anywhere near as much money as the first years of the 360.

Consoles are more expensive, the base price of an item on the shelf has nothing to do with its overall costs.

But if people still want to believe that iterative consoles will work because =phones, they fine, believe! I give up.

A minute later...

But are the types of consoles will have iterations of.

I'm sorry man I can't help you.
 

Papacheeks

Banned
according to the rumors, the PS4K and PS4 literally will do that

so many things that you are describing are either true already for smart phones, true for consoles, or its what Sony and Microsoft is trying to change to make true for consoles

Yea they will do that now, at launch when PS4 is still priority, as time goes on it will be a much different case, and that's what I fear.
 

etta

my hard graphic balls
He's obviously talking about the console.
And that's the problem now.
Xbox is clearly extending to PC and probably other devices in the future, it's now a platform. If you play Halo or Forza on PC you'll still be playing on the Xbox platform. But of course people who don't understand this shift will say stuff like "They're abandoning Xbox and moving to PC" or "What's the point of the Xbox One anymore"...etc.
They don't care where you play as long as you're still playing on the Xbox platform/ecosystem. That's what MAU is.
 
Top Bottom