• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Pokémon Direct June 5th 2019 - 1 PM GMT, 9 AM E.T

Which version will you be getting?

  • Pokemon Sword

    Votes: 27 55.1%
  • Pokemon Shield

    Votes: 15 30.6%
  • n/a

    Votes: 7 14.3%

  • Total voters
    49
  • Poll closed .
I don't dislike the dynamax gimmick. It's okay. I'm not thrilled about it either, honestly I would prefer more mega-evolutions but I guess they can't not bring something new each generation.

The battle UI is going for a flat style, not too awful I suppose. The Rotomdex can go fuck itself.

The region looks awesome and the mix of larger areas and roaming Pokémon is a step in the right direction. I'd like to see more of the cities though!

The Legendaries are really cool. Not as much as Solgaleo/Lunala but still. Shield wolf is amazing, I love how the shield can protect its sides and form a giant front wall when needed. Sword wolf is badass too though the design is a little all over the place. It must be tiring to hold that sword all the time during combat. I wonder if it levitates around him when he doesn't fight. I also wonder about the types, Steel seems pretty obvious for both of them but what other types can they have? I hope it's not Fighting.

Black steel raven is clearly the best Pokémon of the batch, a flawless design really. The others aren't bad, can't wait to see the evolutions of the sheep and Dreadnaw (great name).

On the human side, it's cool to have a new female professor and Sonia is truly beautiful. New champion is ok but ffs why does he have to have a Charizard. There's so many starters to pick from. I hope the rival is actually a real rival and that he gets some characterization.

Milo's anatonmy is inhuman. Seriously. what the fuck. Feet too small, legs too short. I know they're going for a buff look but he looks so wrong.
 

DryvBy

Member
This may end up being one of my GOTY. Since the 90s, I've dreamed of a real Pokemon game on my TV.

My brother is finally buying a Switch due to this.
 
C'mon man, you can't be this obtuse. Pokédex entries have explained away extra items since the beginning. Here's the Farfetch'd entry from Silver: If it eats the plant stick it carries as emergency rations, it runs off in search of a new stick.

Worse yet, here's Cubone's from Yellow: Wears the skull of its deceased mother. Its cries echo inside the skull and come out as a sad melody.

🤷‍♀️

i dont care if its explained in its lore, it irks me that items are included in a pokemons main design. I think if they had varied versions of species id be okay with it....
 
With Shield Face if he/she has the move Skull Bash...would it not be Shield Bash instead? DEF is going to be high from the front at the very least.

Any surprise attack from behind such as Astonish should make them faint instantly.

I guarantee someone has made a porn of her already sadly :(

With Jupiter's a Dynamax Cock no doubt! 😱😱
 
Last edited:

AV

We ain't outta here in ten minutes, we won't need no rocket to fly through space
i dont care if its explained in its lore, it irks me that items are included in a pokemons main design. I think if they had varied versions of species id be okay with it....

It's cool if you don't like the designs, but the explanation for the sword/leek/skull/etc is right there.

Although, what about Honedge? It's literally just a sword. That's where things get messy.
 
It's cool if you don't like the designs, but the explanation for the sword/leek/skull/etc is right there.

Although, what about Honedge? It's literally just a sword. That's where things get messy.
yep, my orig post, notice how I said *one" of my design pet peeves..... mons that ARE items... now that just opens a can of pet peeve worms. hahaha
 
Last edited:

Javthusiast

Banned
1559746750467259.gif


:messenger_fire:

You know artists are already at work on some of that rule...
 

Codes 208

Member
Im definitely in for raids and the return of lets go’s roaming pokemon. Im getting open world vibes so hopefully this one is less hand-holding as x/y-us/um

Also, with godzilla still fresh in my mind i welcome our dynamax overlords.
 
Last edited:
V

Vader1

Unconfirmed Member
Grookey, Corviknight and Drednaw are my favorite Pokemon so far from the new gen.
 
New champion is ok but ffs why does he have to have a Charizard.
Please tell me this is a meme. I can't escape this shilled manlet not a dragon.

Not watched the direct but saw the legendaries. I love the Sword dog, keep crying gen one babies. If you don't like what's in the game then don't buy it, it's that simple.
 

Codes 208

Member
New battle UI looks alright

19.jpg
Looks like an improvement over Lets Go, but remains simple. So i dig it. S/M’s was way too obnoxious. (Although US/UM was a nice improvement)
Please tell me this is a meme. I can't escape this shilled manlet not a dragon.

Not watched the direct but saw the legendaries. I love the Sword dog, keep crying gen one babies. If you don't like what's in the game then don't buy it, it's that simple.
*complains about a gen 1 pokemon*
*tells gen one fans to stop complaining*
Ok.
 
Last edited:

Saber

Member
The new UI looks simple, but not that simple to the point of looking like a mobile game. It's kinda fine.
 
Last edited:
Hire new guys maybe?
We don't know who designed the legendaries, it could be new guys. In any case, it's not like a new guy would necessarily come up with good designs. Fans underestimate how challenging it can be to come up with new designs, especially since that so many Pokémon already exist.

And whoever is responsible for the designs of the mascots, Game Freak made it very clear that they have no problem going with busy designs since at least Dialga and Palkia. It's been more than ten years so you'd think fans would have accepted that legendaries could be more or less reminiscent of Digimon. But no the dead horse still needs some beating.
 

Fake

Member
We don't know who designed the legendaries, it could be new guys. In any case, it's not like a new guy would necessarily come up with good designs. Fans underestimate how challenging it can be to come up with new designs, especially since that so many Pokémon already exist.

And whoever is responsible for the designs of the mascots, Game Freak made it very clear that they have no problem going with busy designs since at least Dialga and Palkia. It's been more than ten years so you'd think fans would have accepted that legendaries could be more or less reminiscent of Digimon. But no the dead horse still needs some beating.
Pokemon fanbase are in the same level as Sonic fanbase. They're not very picky and are easily pleased.
You see, some designs are good no doub, others mix bad and others terrible or repetitive. I actually quite like those wolf legendary design, but lets be honest... a sheep pkmn again? a tortoise pkmn? a dandelion pkmn? Only repetitive design. You can even search for fake pkmns artist on twitter/google with create even better design than those.
The truth is they do not need much effort to sell.
 
Last edited:

Saber

Member
2-3 more years and Pokemon will turn into Digimon. Just wait

Isn't that already?

I mean...Megas are a concept first created by Digimon. Also, Digimon is the one with the idea of a temporary evolution(digivolution), not to mention the digivices which are kinda like what triggers the Mega stones.
 

Mista

Banned
Isn't that already?

I mean...Megas are a concept first created by Digimon. Also, Digimon is the one with the idea of a temporary evolution(digivolution), not to mention the digivices which are kinda like what triggers the Mega stones.
Haven’t been around Pokemon since 3DS I guess. But it’s obvious how Pokemon designs are turning into Digimon
 
So nothing about the Pokemon bank??!??? Will there at least be connectivity for those that played GO to xfer their Pokemon??

I get the feeling they want people to start over and are not going to allow xfers this time.
 

jshackles

Gentlemen, we can rebuild it. We have the capability to make the world's first enhanced store. Steam will be that store. Better than it was before.
Pokemon fanbase are in the same level as Sonic fanbase. They're not very picky and are easily pleased.
You see, some designs are good no doub, others mix bad and others terrible or repetitive. I actually quite like those wolf legendary design, but lets be honest... a sheep pkmn again? a tortoise pkmn? a dandelion pkmn? Only repetitive design. You can even search for fake pkmns artist on twitter/google with create even better design than those.
The truth is they do not need much effort to sell.
To me it looks more like fans are always displeased, every time a new game is made you're going to hear "omg so ugly".

I agree that the Pokémon games can sell very well despite designs not pushing the limits of creativity. The Dandelion is the least creative of the bunch and definitely feels very repetitive in regards to Flabébé, Jumpluff, etc.

However I think that there can be great designs with animals we've seen before. The Greninja line comes to mind. The raven is also a clear example of that, he looks nothing like Honchkrow and is apparently well received. I'm willing to give the sheep a pass because there aren't many sheep Pokémon but yeah, there isn't much though in its look (then again, the same can be said of some old Pokémon). For the tortoise, I'm waiting to see the evolution but I'm not a huge fan of it for now. Overall the designs can be hit or miss.

It looks like the designers are playing it safe for the most part, I'd love to see them try Pokémon based on a capybara, a dolphin, a wombat, etc. But to be fair they always include some mons based on new animals in each gen. Guess we'll have to wait for the full Dex!
 
Last edited:
I'm in the UK. Don't make me go outside and show you how many dandelions there are. It's a true representation of this country. The dogs with a sword and shield is obviously a coat of arms thing. Didn't y'all watch Game of Thrones?

Gen I of Pokemon had only 3 designers on it.

Not sure how many Gen VII had but I know it may be at least 8 or more. The design process of Pokemon has to go through an approval first before they can be added.
 

Tipton32

Member
Great video for an explanation on why the Pokémon designs are so different from previous gens. One thing I will say that’s in the video that I agree with 100%. The newer gen Pokémon are designed like products on a shelf and not animals anymore. Such a shame. That gen 1 and 2 art is absolutely amazing.

 
Last edited:

Dr. Claus

Vincit qui se vincit
Great video for an explanation on why the Pokémon designs are so different from previous gens. One thing I will say that’s in the video that I agree with 100%. The newer gen Pokémon are designed like products on a shelf and not animals anymore. Such a shame. That gen 1 and 2 art is absolutely amazing.



Vastly disagree. Plenty are designed like animals, just like in Gen 1 and 2 there were plenty that looked nothing like animals. Geodude is a fuckin' rock with arms ffs.
 
V

Vader1

Unconfirmed Member
Pokemon fanbase are in the same level as Sonic fanbase. They're not very picky and are easily pleased.
You see, some designs are good no doub, others mix bad and others terrible or repetitive. I actually quite like those wolf legendary design, but lets be honest... a sheep pkmn again? a tortoise pkmn? a dandelion pkmn? Only repetitive design. You can even search for fake pkmns artist on twitter/google with create even better design than those.
The truth is they do not need much effort to sell.

Drednaw has elements from a tortoise, but his head is more reminiscent of a prehistoric armored fish like Dunkleosteus. Gen 1 might be my favorite gen, but this is plenty more creative than something like Horsea, Seel or Voltorb.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You should play Black/White
I second this. You could even play Black 2/White 2 afterwards, it feels like a different adventure if you abstain from visiting the post-league content in BW1. Plus the difference in regional Dexes means you can build a totally different team and fight vastly different teams from BW1.
 

MagnesG

Banned
Christ... Again with this talking pokedex?
Pokemon fanbase are in the same level as Sonic fanbase. They're not very picky and are easily pleased.
You see, some designs are good no doub, others mix bad and others terrible or repetitive. I actually quite like those wolf legendary design, but lets be honest... a sheep pkmn again? a tortoise pkmn? a dandelion pkmn? Only repetitive design. You can even search for fake pkmns artist on twitter/google with create even better design than those.
The truth is they do not need much effort to sell.
I would argue having the same origin animals is okay due to it's ecosystem and new region features. I mean if you really count 'repetitive design' we already had tons of it, but at least not on the same entry.

As for fake pokemon artist, please it's not that simple kind of situation. It's even the same thing with official ones, out of millions of garbage fake pokemon designs, only handful of them are truly great and acceptable on mainstream. Even then some of them are too complicated and tone-deaf. It's truly a subjective topic.

Also, I would believe the official artist are truly working hard on creating their designs, their effort is not to be dismissed that easily.

Edit: Why did you hate the rotom phone btw?
 
Last edited:

Tipton32

Member
Allo
We'd like a word

250px-102Exeggcute.png
250px-100Voltorb.png
250px-074Geodude.png
250px-081Magnemite.png

[/Q
We'd like a word

250px-102Exeggcute.png
250px-100Voltorb.png
250px-074Geodude.png
250px-081Magnemite.png
I probably should’ve phrased my post a little differently but god damn those designs are simple, great and get the point across. I kinda feel their elements are perfect whereas the newer ones have too much going on in terms of design where they come off more like a toy instead of a creature you might find in the wild in the Pokémon universe. I truly don’t think it’s a nostalgia thing with liking the gen 1-3 designs over the newer stuff. The art (especially in gen 1) is absolutely breath taking and you can see the passion put into it and see it clearly meant something to that artist. I do like a bunch of the newer mons but imo nothing beats the older gens. Nidoking being my favorite 😎
tumblr_ncxtp7dtow1rms5n7o4_1280.png
 
Top Bottom