-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Fredrik
Member
Art direction. Artistically Ghost looks better, way better imo.
I’m playing Valhalla on the XSX and it looks great at certain cherry picked locations but can look really dull too, it’s not consistent at all imho.
Meanwhile I’m playing Cyberpunk on an old 1080ti at 1080p and it still beats Valhalla on details
can’t even imagine what it looks like in ultra RT at 4K on a 3090.
Last edited:
Evil Calvin
Afraid of Boobs
I am playing both on XSX 4K with HDR and AC:Valhalla looks amazing at all times. MUCH better than Cyberpunk. But Cyberpunk is still good. Maybe you have your settings wrong. I have Ghosts on regular PS4 and looks great. I can only imagine it looks amazing on PS5. Did they release a next gen upgrade for that?Art direction. Artistically Ghost looks better, way better imo.
I’m playing Valhalla on the XSX and it looks great at certain cherry picked locations but can look really dull too, it’s not consistent at all imho.
Meanwhile I’m playing Cyberpunk on an old 1080ti at 1080p and it still beats Valhalla on details
can’t even imagine what it looks like in ultra RT at 4K on a 3090.
Last edited:
Evilms
Banned
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
Prison Mike
Banned
Thirty7ven
Banned
Cyberpunk because PC fans and XBOX fans had no other champion, and GOT because TLOu2 is evil.
Fredrik
Member
If you’re playing Cyberpunk on XSX you’re playing the Xbox One version, it looks nothing like the PC version which we can assume is what people voted for to get it to #2 on graphics, it’s not perfect in any way but there is a details, effects, density mix that I haven’t seen anywhere else.
Last edited:
D
Deleted member 17706
Unconfirmed Member
Great top 10, although Alyx not being in it is very sad. Understandable, though, since so few had the means to play it.
Here was my Top 9 (didn't have 10 this year) that I forgot to post in the voting thread:
1) Cyberpunk 2077
2) Half-Life Alyx
3) Animal Crossing: New Horizons
4) Assassin's Creed: Valhalla
5) Demon's Souls
6) Final Fantasy VII Remake
7) Ghost of Tsushima
8) Hades
9) Crusader Kings 3
And games that probably would have made it in if I played them/played more of them:
Tony Hawk Pro Skater 1 & 2
Persona 5 Royal
The Last of Us Part II
Nioh 2
Yakuza: Like a Dragon
Mario 3D All Stars
Immortals: Fenyx Rising
Doom: Eternal
Here was my Top 9 (didn't have 10 this year) that I forgot to post in the voting thread:
1) Cyberpunk 2077
2) Half-Life Alyx
3) Animal Crossing: New Horizons
4) Assassin's Creed: Valhalla
5) Demon's Souls
6) Final Fantasy VII Remake
7) Ghost of Tsushima
8) Hades
9) Crusader Kings 3
And games that probably would have made it in if I played them/played more of them:
Tony Hawk Pro Skater 1 & 2
Persona 5 Royal
The Last of Us Part II
Nioh 2
Yakuza: Like a Dragon
Mario 3D All Stars
Immortals: Fenyx Rising
Doom: Eternal
marcincz
Member
And your top 3 is?
D
Deleted member 17706
Unconfirmed Member
Every year there's always some bitter mother fucker that hates everything.
Last edited by a moderator:
D
Deleted member 17706
Unconfirmed Member
Other than complexity, what makes Divinity so fundamentally different to FFVII that they would not be considered the same genre?
D
Deleted member 17706
Unconfirmed Member
Or... maybe it's actually a really damn good game that resonated with lots of people.
Represent.
Represent(ative) of bad opinions
Aside from TLOU 2 being number 2 and not number 1, and Cyberglitch 2076 being in the top 20, good list.
Last edited:
Mista
Banned
Ribi
Member
Look decent? Best looking game out there and meanwhile death stranding gets in the list ...
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
So one copy/paste should be higher than another copy/paste?Animal Crossing at #9? Sony's first party Ubisoft game at #1?
D
Deleted member 17706
Unconfirmed Member
The game no doubt looks great, but doesn't it mostly rely on the the sort of 3D mapping data you see on Google Maps/Earth for the non handbuilt areas?
bender
What time is it?
Mozzarella
Member
The remake of FF7 is very linear, each character cannot be influenced in any way, your class or choices dont alter the game like they do in a game like Divinity. The combat is also more rpg-like than action, quests can be done in multiple ways depending on what role you choose to play. Many other things. Just try both games yourself and see that while both of them are named "RPG" they are actually nothing alike. I believe A-RPG and RPG should be two different genres.
I really recommend Divinity OS2 to any fan of turn based combat and RPG gameplay, this underrated game triumphs over its competition in its genre so easily imo, for example Persona 5. Combat in Divinity 2 is so much better and more tactical that after i played that game the persona 5 combat just doesnt do it for me anymore. And its not just the combat, Divinity 2 has great level design and deep rpg mechanics, the soundtrack is fantastic, and the characters are cool. It doesnt have the best story or best writing in the genre but its one of the best of all time when it comes to rpg gameplay.
Anyway dont wanna go too much off-topic here. I will say again that i think Action role playing games are killing the RPG genre, they are more mainstream and i understand the appeal, some of my best games of all time are actually Action RPGs but when it comes to rpg elements those games are generally very light on it and when people claim they are best rpg it somehow creates a confusion to old school rpg fans. I think its important to understand the difference between them and separate them as ARPG and RPG.
Go_Ly_Dow
Member
Love you guys and god bless NeoGAF. <3
D
Deleted member 17706
Unconfirmed Member
I've beaten Divinity: Original Sin 2 twice. It's a fantastic game that I would recommend to anyone. While it certainly has more branching paths than something like FF7, I certainly don't consider that the make or break factor in something being an RPG. Most of the choices and consequences you make are fairly minor in the grand scheme of things. You're still going to play through more or less the same content and linear overarching story. I don't necessarily see that as a weakness, though.
At a surface level and feature level, the two games are firmly in the same genre. FF7Re can even be played in a classic turn based mode where you can choose every command for your party (I wouldn't recommend it, though).
Evil Calvin
Afraid of Boobs
Yep. Looks good but hoping the upgrade isn't as long as they say it will be (6 months +).
Evil Calvin
Afraid of Boobs
Astro's Rescue Mission eats Playroom's lunch. Most people never played ARM.Astros Playroom beating Ori as best platformer! Get to fuck
Mozzarella
Member
Not only branching paths but each quest can be completed in many ways, not only quests actually, many parts of the game can be done in multiple ways, like stealing. I was surprised by how many ways you can experiment with this game to try things out, whether in combat or in the world itself (exploration) or in the side and main quests. A lot of stats, a lot of skills, all of them matter, all of them have their uses, thats neat! I wasnt just talking about main story.
FF7 Remake doesnt even have 10% of that rpg mechanics/elements. Keep in mind im not saying its bad to not have them, just that its either two different kind of games with clearly different focus (my point/argument) or one is a deep rpg and the other is a shallow one (which is an unfair point to make since i personally believe those genres are different and put their focus on different things).
As i said there are many factors but the decisive factor imo is whether the game is action or not. Action style combat makes the game ARPG which leans less on tactical positioning and stats and more on timing and dodging but since they are light on rpg elements they also have a glimpse of stats and tactics which is why people call them A-RPG.
Actually the classic mode for FF7 Remake is very poorly implemented that its a complete joke, its an afterthought. The game at its core is an action role playing game and to be honest even compared to other action role playing games this game still doesnt have much going for it in the "roleplaying" part. It could be an action game and it would still be partially correct.
Dont get me wrong though, the game is fun and i liked it, its a very good game but its not really a rpg in the same type as other rpg/jrpg games.
Persona 5/Dragon Quest is a JRPG
Divinity OS2/Pathfinder is RPG
Witcher 3/Mass Effect is ARPG
FF7R/Nier Automata is AJRPG
which looks ugly so people call them ARPG and be done with it.I can see you disagree with me on this, so after playing those many different rpg, you put them all together under the same genre, or do you separate them into sub-genres? if you do, based on what?
Last edited:
Mista
Banned
bender
What time is it?
I'd love to but have a hard time wanting to invest in the hardware for VR.
Touch fuzZy. get BizZay
Member
Yeah I'm pissed off Mario 35 didn't win GotY as well
That's what we're talking about rite
Last edited:
Hugare
Member
Would swap GOT with FF VII, but pretty good list
Found GoT to be competent in almost every way, but not exceptional in anything.
Felt like going through the motions most of the time. Story wasn't gripping.
FF VII, Cyberpunk and TLOU 2 had way more heart, so they resonated more with me
PS: Loved "Gafs thoughts" for each game. Great way to summarize what makes each game special.
Found GoT to be competent in almost every way, but not exceptional in anything.
Felt like going through the motions most of the time. Story wasn't gripping.
FF VII, Cyberpunk and TLOU 2 had way more heart, so they resonated more with me
PS: Loved "Gafs thoughts" for each game. Great way to summarize what makes each game special.
Last edited:
Touch fuzZy. get BizZay
Member
We have a top 20 and it scored well enough to be 21st, so it was close to glory on the opening post
I think I've been cheating on Gaf's thoughts and it got cut out of them. I was using hypohons to make longer words like "Combo-licious" and "Nostalgia-fueled" and I don't see any of those dumb longer words I made
iHaunter
Member
Easy to make it look that good when everything is that far away. It's not ground-breaking tech. Sorry.
D
Deleted member 17706
Unconfirmed Member
Not only branching paths but each quest can be completed in many ways, not only quests actually, many parts of the game can be done in multiple ways, like stealing. I was surprised by how many ways you can experiment with this game to try things out, whether in combat or in the world itself (exploration) or in the side and main quests. A lot of stats, a lot of skills, all of them matter, all of them have their uses, thats neat! I wasnt just talking about main story.
FF7 Remake doesnt even have 10% of that rpg mechanics/elements. Keep in mind im not saying its bad to not have them, just that its either two different kind of games with clearly different focus (my point/argument) or one is a deep rpg and the other is a shallow one (which is an unfair point to make since i personally believe those genres are different and put their focus on different things).
As i said there are many factors but the decisive factor imo is whether the game is action or not. Action style combat makes the game ARPG which leans less on tactical positioning and stats and more on timing and dodging but since they are light on rpg elements they also have a glimpse of stats and tactics which is why people call them A-RPG.
Actually the classic mode for FF7 Remake is very poorly implemented that its a complete joke, its an afterthought. The game at its core is an action role playing game and to be honest even compared to other action role playing games this game still doesnt have much going for it in the "roleplaying" part. It could be an action game and it would still be partially correct.
Dont get me wrong though, the game is fun and i liked it, its a very good game but its not really a rpg in the same type as other rpg/jrpg games.
Persona 5/Dragon Quest is a JRPG
Divinity OS2/Pathfinder is RPG
Witcher 3/Mass Effect is ARPG
FF7R/Nier Automata is AJRPG
I can see you disagree with me on this, so after playing those many different rpg, you put them all together under the same genre, or do you separate them into sub-genres? if you do, based on what?
There's so much genre blending that I find splitting things into subgenres to not be very constructive. More often than not, it just spurs arguments about subjective definitions like the one we're having now.
If a game puts you in control of a character or group of characters, allows you to make decisions for them that can affect how events in the game play out, and has progression/customization mechanics, that's enough for me to call it an RPG.
I wouldn't call FF7R an action game at all. Sure, it lets you mash buttons in real time, but its gameplay does not require quick reflexes or memorizing combos and timing or even really allow for those things to come into play. The only action elements in it really are more MMO-like mechanics where you need to move out of the way of certain attacks that are signaled well in advance.
Balducci30
Member
I don’t understand are the ori games actually good? For a casual gamer? Like they’re 2D