Vampire On Titus
Member
Easy for me because my current GOTY is extremely hidden, echoing
Fuz
's mention of Perfect Tides. I was more immersed in the small pixel-art island community of Perfect Tides than countless AAA worlds I could mention. The writer and director, Meredith Gran (best known for her comic series Octopus Pie), has such a knack for picking the precise details that evoke a place and time believably. I seriously doubt anyone could do early 00's/early internet/early adulthood nostalgia better. Plus, even though PT's story steals the show, the gameplay has subtle depth to it with many optional puzzles and scenes that encourage multiple playthroughs.
If you want to relive all the horribly awkward moments of your adolescence you thought were successfully stowed away for life, play Perfect Tides.
If you want to relive all the horribly awkward moments of your adolescence you thought were successfully stowed away for life, play Perfect Tides.