• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

PopGAF |OT4| asdfjkl;asdfjkl;

Status
Not open for further replies.

Cynosure

Member
21 – BACK TO BASICS, Christina Aguilera (2006)

zen86.jpg


Creating this album is probably hands-down the ballsiest move any notable female pop star has ever done since Madonna’s earlier transformations in the late 1980s. You will never see Beyonce or Britney Spears take a quintessential shit on their momentum to release a 1940s-inspired throwback album for the sake of making one. There’s a lot to respect about someone who has the artistic integrity to make a project like this a reality, but more respectable is the fact that this album is jarringly high-quality. It’s a long journey of an album, with plenty of distractions along the way, but at its core is an insatiable need on the artist’s part to entertain both the listener and her legacy. Back to Basics is a bit of an over-crowded album, and it’s obvious that Aguilera had much to get off her chest with the over-abundant track list, but there are dozens of brilliantly high-shining moments throughout that echo memories of Etta James, Tina Turner and Ella Fitzgerald. Aguilera’s voice is at its crispest here, and songs like “Hurt” have every making of a timeless classic. We can’t expect everyone to appreciate Back to Basics, but those who are willing to give it a thorough listen will no doubt appreciate its boldness and impeccable attention to detail. Aguilera gets a lot of flack from pop fans (and she tends to deserve a great deal of it) but no matter how you slice it, you still can’t say that your fave made an album quite like this.


Brightest moments: Hurt, Mercy On Me

ibdB8xQbkewx14.gif



I'm truly grateful she doesn't care much about album sales
A genuine artist *.*



 
Soul told me his top three once. Its was sad.

izfZgUhQk9F3P.gif

OMG don't use Willam against me you whore!

Those were my top 3 favorites, not the top 3 "best" ;__;

Bladenic said:
Great list Soul except 80% aren't even pop records lmao

I'm counting an album as pop if it finds mainstream popularity, or is accessible enough for the type of genre it is. Arcade Fire is the least "pop" in the list but a lot of its material could translate well to radio if given the chance, so it makes it. ;)

royalan said:
Soul-sis, that was an absolutely beautiful write-up on Back To (Slaying) Basics. Spot on. ;___;


Thank you Roy-sus. I put my heart on the keyboard for that one ;___;

DMeisterJ said:
Soul is saving Rih for the top 10. I can feel it. I wonder what the other three albums in the top 10 will be.

You might be surprised....

deal_with_it.gif



And Usher is totally pop you crazies, lol
 

Dr. Malik

FlatAss_
I am going to give her the benefit of the doubt. Before she started recording she mention her album was going to have a new sound and then she came out with Die Young... so either Dr. Luke wrote it or she was forced to write a couple of generic songs and not get her way

iOeaXcDuoSvJl.gif
 

Bladenic

Member
How stupid can you be, the first tweet is just fine, the second one was just.... She's trying to channel Rihanna and Nicki for twitter stupidity I see.
 

Trigger

Member
Does she not have media consultants? Who on earth told her to make this more of a story than it already is? Very stupid move........

She should have just ignored it or given a generic (sorry for their loss) type response at most.

Yeah, even if the song isn't popular due to the shootings, she didn't need to make up such a weird excuse.
 

cory64

Member
I am going to give her the benefit of the doubt. Before she started recording she mention her album was going to have a new sound and then she came out with Die Young... so either Dr. Luke wrote it or she was forced to write a couple of generic songs and not get her way

Whether she really wanted the song to be on the album or not, this situation is NOT the time to try to push the blame on her label & producers for that song.
 
How embarrassing.


Broken Spearit's level of disgrace

Its a good thing Brit is probably computer illiterate and has a team that handles her social media.

Poor dear.

Whether she really wanted the song to be on the album or not, this situation is NOT the time to try to push the blame on her label & producers for that song.

Completely agree. 100% inappropriate. Who will want to work with her now?
 

Bladenic

Member
I bet Ke#ha is having some sort of breakdown, her album flopping and now her single getting dropped, it's understandable that she's losing it.
 

royalan

Member
Keisha should keep going. Every step she takes now makes her more of a problem for RCAncient, which makes Xtina look tons better by association and guarantees she won't get dropped. *.*

YAAASSSS KEISHA!!! Keep digging that grave for your brand!!!
 
Oh Ke$ha girl. You were almost there with that first tweet and then you fucked it.

Does that means she forced herself to sing her own lyrics? lol
 

Mumei

Member
Usher's Confessions is definitely not pop. He's pretty pop now, but Confessions was R&B with some pop influences I suppose.

I was just having this discussion (about Kanye and Outkast) with charlequin a few minutes ago and their status as pop (I don't think so, even if they were popular with pop radio audiences and possibly fit Soulscribe's criteria of representing an evolution in pop sound even if not exactly "pop" themselves).

I am interested in how Soul is defining a "pop album," though.
 

Dr. Malik

FlatAss_
Just yesterday you hoes were applauding Kelly and P!nk for standing up to RCA so they could get their support on the projects they wanted to make and said that Xtina should do the same

I C this backpedaling
 

Mumei

Member
Just yesterday you hoes were applauding Kelly and P!nk for standing up to RCA so they could get their support on the projects they wanted to make and said that Xtina should do the same

I C this backpedaling

One of these things is not like the others
One of these things doesn't belong
Can you tell which thing is not like the others
By the time I finish my song?
 

royalan

Member
Just yesterday you hoes were applauding Kelly and P!nk for standing up to RCA so they could get their support on the projects they wanted to make and said that Xtina should do the same

I C this backpedaling

Pink and Kelly weren't trying to connect RCA to a national tragedy.

("But RCA greenlit Lotus. " -- Koodo)
 

Bladenic

Member
I was just having this discussion (about Kanye and Outkast) with charlequin a few minutes ago and their status as pop (I don't think so, even if they were popular with pop radio audiences and possibly fit Soulscribe's criteria of representing an evolution in pop sound even if not exactly "pop" themselves).

I am interested in how Soul is defining a "pop album," though.

Yeah, Soulscribe seems to be going with the literal definition of "popular music" which is fine, it's his list.

Also Marius this is not the same, lets not pretend. Kelly has been fighting her label and Clive Davis for years about her music, Ke}ha just tweeted that she didn't want to sing a song she has a writing credit for due to it now being dropped because of it's title. She's blaming the label. It's shameless.
 

Styles

Member

Dr. Malik

FlatAss_
Pink and Kelly weren't trying to connect RCA to a national tragedy.

("But RCA greenlit Lotus. " -- Koodo)

Just like America is trying to connect Die Young to a national tragedy and paint her in a negative light. She should be trying to divert attention away from herself.


I see her being opportunistic at this point and want her to continue
c3ed7b23.gif
 

Bladenic

Member
Call Me Maybe doesn't deserve worst song at all. I don't think it was deserving of it's slayage, but it's a good, maybe even great, pop song. Simple doesn't have to mean bad, and it was a perfect summer pop song.

The worst song from that list is undoubtedly Psy. Actually a few of those songs don't deserve those nominations IMO, Gotye and Leona especially.
 

botty

Banned
Call Me Maybe doesn't deserve worst song at all. I don't think it was deserving of it's slayage, but it's a good, maybe even great, pop song. Simple doesn't have to mean bad, and it was a perfect summer pop song.

The worst song from that list is undoubtedly Psy. Actually a few of those songs don't deserve those nominations IMO, Gotye and Leona especially.

Vote PSY with me.
c3ed7b23.gif
 
Yeah, Soulscribe seems to be going with the literal definition of "popular music" which is fine, it's his list.

Also Marius this is not the same, lets not pretend. Kelly has been fighting her label and Clive Davis for years about her music, Ke}ha just tweeted that she didn't want to sing a song she has a writing credit for due to it now being dropped because of it's title. She's blaming the label. It's shameless.

Pop music to me is a constantly changing hybrid genre. It will constantly change in sound depending on what the population wants to hear. Right now, the two main types of pop music are club hip-hop and electro-pop. Everything else at the moment would fall as a pop outlier. Kanye West and Usher's music were hugely popular at the time, and they helped push a rap/R&B sound that took over the mid 00's. To me pop music is completely phony. Alternative, R&B, Hip-Hop... these are all timelessly unique types of sounds. Pop music borrows from what's in demand and clams it for itself.

Even certain pop acts that we can't quite claim as Rock or R&B (like Britney, Gaga, Katy Perry) still borrow most of their sounds from established chords popularized by the main genres; they're just disguised by familiar electronic melodies.
 

Aguila

#ICONIC
First of all, Psy is not a song. Second of all:

Gangnam Style doesn't deserve worst song at all. I don't think it was deserving of it's slayage, but it's a fun song.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom