• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Here is how replacing your HDD on PS4 works (ComputerBild)


Rage_table_flip.png
 

tipoo

Banned
So is this dude going to do an actual teardown some day this week, or was that what he meant by "teardown"?
 

Number45

Member
I got this Seagate Momentus 1 TB 5400RPM for my PS3 and it has worked good. Do you guys think it'll be a good replacement for the HDD in the PS4?
If all you're interested in is increasing the size. If performance is something you'd like to improve (not that we know that it'll be a problem, but with a slow HDD you've got to think that some disk intensive operations will be sluggish) then it might be worth looking for a 7200RPM equivalent.

That said, 5400 is probably a safe bet until someone confirms whether there are heat issues with faster drives. Personally, I'll be sticking with the pre-installed HDD until I need to expand and by that time others will have tested various different drive types.
 

Hawk269

Member
Has there been confirmation on external HDD working on PS4? I have a spare 2tb Seagate HDD external that I would like to hook up to the PS4.
 

Number45

Member
Has there been confirmation on external HDD working on PS4? I have a spare 2tb Seagate HDD external that I would like to hook up to the PS4.
Nope. I'm sure they'll work for backups, but no confirmation that they'll work for system storage. Hope so, as I have a 2TB sitting around that I can use as well.

12.5 mm??? Did not see that coming, thought it would be the same as the PS3.
Makes sense given the increased storage requirements. Do we have any figures for the launch retail games yet?
 

netBuff

Member
What's the max mm on PS4? I'm considering the 500gb SSD from Samsung for the PS4.

If you're talking about the Samsung 840 Evo: That's an absolutely fantastic drive and an excellent choice for any SSD needs anywhere. I'll be feeding my PS4 one of these drives as well ;)
 

bryanee

Member
I can still use a 9.5mm HHD right, It doesn't have to be 12.5mm does it? Apologies for my ignorance on this matter.

edit - Nevermind, I looked back a few pages and yes I can.
 

tipoo

Banned
I'm waiting on some results before I get a PS4 with a SSD. 1TB should be more affordable in 2014 ;)

Keep dreaming. Prices do keep coming down, but for the high capacity drives I don't see 1TB being mainstream-affordable in a single year. A *refurbished* 1TB OCZ SSD from newegg is $1,299 right now, in a single year it's not going to be a few hundred.
 

dubq

Member
849 for regular price, but point taken. Still, I have a different take on "affordable".

Nah, I don't consider that affordable either.. I just meant that they're not as expensive as they were a year ago. Hopefully we'll see a further price drop in 2014. I mean, really, this shit shouldn't cost anywhere near that much money.
 

tipoo

Banned
Nah, I don't consider that affordable either.. I just meant that they're not as expensive as they were a year ago. Hopefully we'll see a further price drop in 2014. I mean, really, this shit shouldn't cost anywhere near that much money.

Seeing the price trend over the last few years, of course they will be cheaper, but still very much in the same ballpark. These haven't really been following Moore's law, to double transistors every 18 months. Whether it's manufacturers milking it or not, I expect to see just slightly under 1 dollar/gigabyte in 2014 on average, nothing drastic.
 

dubq

Member
Seeing the price trend over the last few years, of course they will be cheaper, but still very much in the same ballpark. These haven't really been following Moore's law, to double transistors every 18 months. Whether it's manufacturers milking it or not, I expect to see just slightly under 1 dollar/gigabyte in 2014 on average, nothing drastic.

Yeah, it's really unfortunate as I'd love to own one of that capacity.. but there's no way I'd shell out that much. I'm content with an SSHD for now, to be honest.
 
849 for regular price, but point taken. Still, I have a different take on "affordable".

Why a 1TB SSD for storage anyways? Keeping games on a smaller SSD and movies and media on a cheap large external hard drive will definitely be cheaper, and no worse performing as all the transfer rate in the world doesn't really matter for movies.

Because given the size of the nextgen games and PS+ 1 TB seems really little just for games. I have 1 TB on my PS3 and it's enough, but a 500 GB HDD wouldn't. Considering the gen started with 60GB HDD, I'm thinking even 2 TB won't be enough near the end of the gen, so definitely prepare to buy another HDD down the line.
 

Number45

Member
Because given the size of the nextgen games and PS+ 1 TB seems really little just for games. I have 1 TB on my PS3 and it's enough, but a 500 GB HDD wouldn't. Considering the gen started with 60GB HDD, I'm thinking even 2 TB won't be enough near the end of the gen, so definitely prepare to buy another HDD down the line.
I'm going to start the next generation the way I finished this one as far as PS+ is concerned. "Buy" everything, but only download it when I intend to play (and delete when I'm done) - I'll keep a bookmark to the MC page of the games I haven't played so I can read about them when it's time to download a new game.

Then after four months when I'm already building up a stupid backlog, I'll start deleting games from the list willy nilly.
 

jcm

Member
Seeing the price trend over the last few years, of course they will be cheaper, but still very much in the same ballpark. These haven't really been following Moore's law, to double transistors every 18 months. Whether it's manufacturers milking it or not, I expect to see just slightly under 1 dollar/gigabyte in 2014 on average, nothing drastic.

I don't think you're correct. I paid about $485 for a 256GB Samsung about 2 years ago. That same money will get you 750GB today.
 
I'm going to start the next generation the way I finished this one as far as PS+ is concerned. "Buy" everything, but only download it when I intend to play (and delete when I'm done) - I'll keep a bookmark to the MC page of the games I haven't played so I can read about them when it's time to download a new game.

Then after four months when I'm already building up a stupid backlog, I'll start deleting games from the list willy nilly.

But then you'll never play them. That's what happens to me on the Vita. Once I delete something I rarely play it again. And I start new games much later than I otherwise would because I have to wait to download them till I've cleared some space.

The whole point of having a digital library is instant availability, switching games on a whim. If you have to start waiting you might as well go physical IMO.
 

Number45

Member
But then you'll never play them. That's what happens to me on the Vita. Once I delete something I rarely play it again. And I start new games much later than I otherwise would because I have to wait to download them till I've cleared some space.

The whole point of having a digital library is instant availability, switching games on a whim. If you have to start waiting you might as well go physical IMO.
There are exceptions, but the vast majority of the time I won't return to a game I've finished so that's not really an issue for me. As for instant availability, I'll have the next game downloaded the night before or something so that's not cause for concern - I don't have multiple games on the hard drive because I try and play one (two tops, one story based and one arcade/bite-size) before I move on.
 

Ocelott

Member
500 GB will be just fine for a while since I am doing 50/50 Digital/Disc Based route. I will upgrade when the prices drop a little.
 

Silurus

Member
If all you're interested in is increasing the size. If performance is something you'd like to improve (not that we know that it'll be a problem, but with a slow HDD you've got to think that some disk intensive operations will be sluggish) then it might be worth looking for a 7200RPM equivalent.

That said, 5400 is probably a safe bet until someone confirms whether there are heat issues with faster drives. Personally, I'll be sticking with the pre-installed HDD until I need to expand and by that time others will have tested various different drive types.

It's a hybrid drive so faster than most 7200s even though the platter speed is only 5400.
 
849 for regular price, but point taken. Still, I have a different take on "affordable".

Why a 1TB SSD for storage anyways? Keeping games on a smaller SSD and movies and media on a cheap large external hard drive will definitely be cheaper, and no worse performing as all the transfer rate in the world doesn't really matter for movies.
At $0.60/GB that Samsung SSD is one of the best values in SSDs, regardless of capacity.

Anyway, the price isn't a barrier for me. Capacity is. You question the need for 1TB of storage, but I know that 1TB won't be nearly enough for me if I go all-digital (like I want to do) next gen. Forget movies and other media; I've filled my 500GB PS3 with nothing but games. And that only accounts for less than half my entire PS3 library, since I've bought mostly physical this gen. Unfortunately, 1TB is the current maximum capacity drive available that will fit in the PS4, regardless if it's SSD or HDD.
 

AndyD

aka andydumi
At $0.60/GB that Samsung SSD is one of the best values in SSDs, regardless of capacity.

Anyway, the price isn't a barrier for me. Capacity is. You question the need for 1TB of storage, but I know that 1TB won't be nearly enough for me if I go all-digital (like I want to do) next gen. Forget movies and other media; I've filled my 500GB PS3 with nothing but games. And that only accounts for less than half my entire PS3 library, since I've bought mostly physical this gen. Unfortunately, 1TB is the current maximum capacity drive available that will fit in the PS4, regardless if it's SSD or HDD.

I think the best option for all-digital users will be a SATA extender cable to an external drive. That way you can do a 2-3 TB drive right away. But I don't see the need day 1, aside from saving the trouble of re-downloading and installing games with a later upgrade.

Will be the prettiest solution? Definitely not. But if games are say 30GB each on average, I can see people maxing out a 500GB stock drive within the first year very easily. A 500GB only has about 420GB available to start, reserve another 50 for cache and apps and saves and whatnot, and you are in the 370 range, so about 10 full blown retail games.
 
I think the best option for all-digital users will be a SATA extender cable to an external drive. That way you can do a 2-3 TB drive right away. But I don't see the need day 1, aside from saving the trouble of re-downloading and installing games with a later upgrade.

Will be the prettiest solution? Definitely not. But if games are say 30GB each on average, I can see people maxing out a 500GB stock drive within the first year very easily. A 500GB only has about 420GB available to start, reserve another 50 for cache and apps and saves and whatnot, and you are in the 370 range, so about 10 full blown retail games.
Yeah. SATA cable to external 4TB drive is what I was thinking I might have to resort to if a better solution doesn't come up before I fill the stock 500GB HDD. Then, I'll just do a HDD transfer instead of having to redownload everything through PSN.
 
I'm a light console gamer so a 256gb SSD should be good enough for the first year or two at least.

Consider an external drive for storing movies, etc. on.
 
if we do a day one swap, is there a need to back up anything at all? or is everything needed stored on ram/flash/???

Probably. If not they'll likely have the firmware up for download on the website you can put on a USB stick just like you need today to upgrade a PS3 Slim's HDD.
 

goonergaz

Member
I'm a light console gamer so a 256gb SSD should be good enough for the first year or two at least.

Consider an external drive for storing movies, etc. on.

I was thinking similar things, 256gb would likely be good enough for a couple of years - in the mean-time prices drop.

very tempting...will be watching what happens between US & UK release and reading what differences are found
 

jcm

Member
You just don't get it.
If the OS doesn't have TRIM support, the SSD drive soon gets slower, loses space rapidly (and is unrecoverable) and has major reliability issues.

TRIM isn't standard, Win 7 was the first OS to get it, Linux (most used server OS in the world) only got it last year, and Android only got it recently after everyone noticing that their Nexus range became almost unusable 6 months in.
If PS4 OS doesn't have TRIM, you may as well throw your money in a fire.

I've been running a laptop with an SSD without TRIM for several years, with no issues that I've noticed.
 

netBuff

Member
You just don't get it.
If the OS doesn't have TRIM support, the SSD drive soon gets slower, loses space rapidly (and is unrecoverable) and has major reliability issues.

TRIM isn't standard, Win 7 was the first OS to get it, Linux (most used server OS in the world) only got it last year, and Android only got it recently after everyone noticing that their Nexus range became almost unusable 6 months in.
If PS4 OS doesn't have TRIM, you may as well throw your money in a fire.

Edit: yes I know about SandForce garbage collection, it hugely reduces men cell lifespan. I would never risk it on something you hope to have for 6-8 years of a gen.

Trim is all about write performance, it doesn't affect SSD life in any way (I don't know where you get "loses space rapidly" from). Even if the PS4 doesn't support Trim, random reading speed is what will benefit console gaming most; Slower writing won't be all that noticeable.

Wow, that thing is like $450 retail. Hope you're getting a good discount. I can't ever myself dropping that much for storage.

It is 100% worth it for PCs - maybe less so for a console, but still enough I'm getting a Samsung 840 Evo as well.
 

kartu

Banned
Need to know max supported size.
If the rumor that "most games install to HDD anyway" is true, and all those PSN+ freebies I'll run out of space quite soon.
 

goonergaz

Member
PS3 doesn't support TRIM and no issues here, still runs silky smooth and is much MUCH quicker than the 'fast' upgraded HDD I have in my other PS3.
 
Top Bottom