• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

2016 Summer Olympics |OT| August 5th - August 21st

Status
Not open for further replies.
i like it, because then it helps countries out that dont have the funding

otherwise floor finals would be like 4 americans. lol

just like chinese men on parallel bars would be top 3 probably as well.

I get the funding comment but it's still taking away the best in the world from competing. This is the Olympics, only the best should be competing.

EDIT: The noob is crying at the medal ceremony! Rook!
 
This is the Olympics, only the best should be competing.

Olympics is not about that. From the Olympic Creed:

"The most important thing in the Olympic Games is not to win but to take part, just as the most important thing in life is not the triumph but the struggle. The essential thing is not to have conquered but to have fought well."

the best in the world win the events, but limiting the each nation to two competitors makes space to have as many different countries as possible competing, which is what the Rings signify - all of the world together.
 
no. that would be simone biles by a loooooooooooooong shot

no, would be boring, and the committee agrees. used to be that way, then changed it for a reason to spread medals around.

I don't care how boring some may perceive it as, it isn't fair to the competitors.
 
Mannnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn


I don't know anything but I thought she was the best on the team
Nah. Gabby is the defending all around champ from 2012, but Simone Biles is being hyped as the best of all time. Though, looks like if Biles wasn't there, the next 3 would be capable of winning gold in all around. It's an amazing team.
 
no, would be boring, and the committee agrees. used to be that way, then changed it for a reason to spread medals around.
I don't find anything boring about watching the best in the world put on a show.
Olympics is not about that. From the Olympic Creed:

"The most important thing in the Olympic Games is not to win but to take part, just as the most important thing in life is not the triumph but the struggle. The essential thing is not to have conquered but to have fought well."

the best in the world win the events, but limiting the each nation to two competitors makes space to have as many different countries as possible competing, which is what the Rings signify - all of the world together.
It's a complete load of horseshit used to create bogus drama that the knockout is done at the Olympics rather than at the Trials like other sports do it.
 
It's a complete load of horseshit used to create bogus drama that the limiting is done at the Olympics rather than at the Trials like other sports do it.
I agree, but I still think it's an important rule to have. The Olympics was intended to be an event made to bring people of all nations together, not to become yet another dick-measuring contest.
 
Canada's Men Beach Volleyball team chocked against Lativa in the last crunch.

fuuuuu
 
It's really weird. it's like the replacement and the replaced are in the same team.

That's exactly it. And the interviewer had no mercy asking her about how it felt to realize she wouldn't be competing in all arounds. Gabby seemed to get lost in her thoughts trying not to cry.
 
I agree, but I still think it's an important rule to have. The Olympics was intended to be an event made to bring people of all nations together, not to become yet another dick-measuring contest.
I don't necessarily have a huge problem with the limit existing. I get the need for diversity, as much as I'd rather watch the best athletes.

I definitely have a problem with the implementation though. If you're going to knock someone out of competing, do it at the Trials and be done with it. Sports drama is great entertainment. Bogus drama that could have been solved months ago, is not.
 
Such a stupid rule. Should be the top best even if it might possibly end up all from the same country.

What is crazy is that Hernandez is potentially the second best all around on the US team, and she was not even given the opportunity to compete for it due to the coaches decision, because of the limited spaces. The top 4 probably would have all been Americans.
 
I don't necessarily have a huge problem with the limit existing. I get the need for diversity, as much as I'd rather watch the best athletes.

I definitely have a problem with the implementation though. If you're going to knock someone out of competing, do it at the Trials and be done with it. Sports drama is great entertainment. Bogus drama that could have been solved months ago, is not.

She did get knocked out at the trials or should have. She apparently had scores lower than even the alternates. She went to Rio purely because of marketing. She knows the rules and Biles queen automatically takes up one spot then she compete with Aly and Aly was better than her simple as is. At that point I don't give a fuck about her past history she didn't finish second from her teammates
 
I find the 2 per country rule to be bogus. If 3 of the top women are from the same country they shouldn't be penalized for it, tell the others girls to get better. /shrug
 
I don't necessarily have a huge problem with the limit existing. I get the need for diversity, as much as I'd rather watch the best athletes.

I definitely have a problem with the implementation though. If you're going to knock someone out of competing, do it at the Trials and be done with it. Sports drama is great entertainment. Bogus drama that could have been solved months ago, is not.

I doubt participants are bothered by it, I'm sure they rather get their shot at it than to get no chance at all.
 
She did get knocked out at the trials or should have. She apparently had scores lower than even the alternates. She went to Rio purely because of marketing. She knows the rules and Biles queen automatically takes up one spot then she compete with Aly and Aly was better than her simple as is. At that point I don't give a fuck about her past history she didn't finish second from her teammates

She had scores lower than the US alternates but placed third overall in the world at the Olympic qualifying round? Do you have a source for this?

I doubt participants are bothered by it, I'm sure they rather get their shot at it than to get chance at all.

Um. What? You can't be serious. Showing that you are the third best in the world at something and then being passed up by 5 other inferior athletes for a chance to prove it wouldn't bother you?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom