• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

American Idol X|V |OT| Please Be Excited

Status
Not open for further replies.
Last day in San fran
#idol is on now
Adana duru was okay.


Did they get whats her face to do the prelim judgin? Lol
Carly Smithson
Daniel seavey is in the top 24 reveal video

Guess his voice matured between audition and Hollywood lol
Hollywood week will be amazing since someone appears to have had. a seizure
 
I didn't get to see it Thursday, so I'm watching it now. So I guess I'll be talking to myself for the next hour, lol

-See, this is why EMPIRE has higher ratings than Idol: NOBODY GIVES A SHIT ABOUT THE JUDGES SO STOP MAKING THE SHOW ABOUT THEM. The show opens up with Harry playing this song on the piano (against a montage of shots of random contestants).

I barely tune in to listen to you critique the contestants, let alone watch you play the piano. Let's get on with it.

/rant

-Holy shit! Carly Smithson works for Idol???

dIrwnkz.jpg


-Harry is killing me with this know-it-all Mr. Music Teacher nonsense. "Make sure you go over every line and know what every line means." Yes, because that's what's we care about: whether the contestant understands the song.

(Can anyone tell that I don't like Harry? lol)

-Hunter has a great voice. Wish she would have sang more.
-Since when did they let 10-year-olds audition? - No, this boy sucks. He can hit the notes, but his tone is horrific
-THEY DIDN'T LET THAT SOPHIA GIRL THROUGH? This fuckin fraud of a talent show
-God fucking dammit I am so sick of Harry. Can they just put his crap online so I don't have to see it
 
womfalcs3 said:
Harry is the balance that makes this show remotely watchable. JLo knows nothing about vocals and music.
Click to expand...

My favorite is Keith. He's articulate and makes his points short and sweet....and he doesn't get all convoluted like Harry does. With Harry, I get the impression that he's trying to both critique the contestant AND impress everyone with his musical prowess.

"Blah blah blah cadenza blah blah blah allegro blah blah blah A-sharp"
 
MIMIC said:
My favorite is Keith. He's articulate and makes his points short and sweet....and he doesn't get all convoluted like Harry does. With Harry, I get the impression that he's trying to both critique the contestant AND impress everyone with his musical prowess.

"Blah blah blah cadenza blah blah blah allegro blah blah blah A-sharp"
Click to expand...
Agreed. Keith's critiques are personable and to the point.

JLo is useless, and Harry's so far up his own ass that any attempts at critique just come across as intellectual self-aggrandizement. It doesn't help that the show is shoving his painfully unfunny antics in our faces every five seconds.

NO ONE FINDS HIM FUNNY, IDOL PRODUCERS

STOP
 
Leona Lewis said:
Agreed. Keith's critiques are personable and to the point.

JLo is useless, and Harry's so far up his own ass that any attempts at critique just come across as intellectual self-aggrandizement. It doesn't help that the show is shoving his painfully unfunny antics in our faces every five seconds.

NO ONE FINDS HIM FUNNY, IDOL PRODUCERS

STOP
Click to expand...

Can I give you a hug? lol Because it felt to me like I was the only one (not even here, but on other boards) that despised Harry.

I'm passing the time watching "Reality Check", waiting for the Australian Open to start and I'm watching Melinda's and Slezak's comments on Savion.

Savion: I wrote more. I've been touring. I've been playing shows like crazy.
Melinda: Yeah yeah, he HAS to say that....

FUCKING LOL!

-Melinda: Somebody had the nerve to tweet me and say 'She stole that run from Tori Kelly.' Listen, I don't care if she stole it from Jesus. The fact that she can actually do it is all that matters.

I love Melinda xD
 
MIMIC said:
Can I give you a hug? lol Because it felt to me like I was the only one (not even here, but on other boards) that despised Harry.

I'm passing the time watching "Reality Check", waiting for the Australian Open to start and I'm watching Melinda's and Slezak's comments on Savion.

Savion: I wrote more. I've been touring. I've been playing shows like crazy.
Melinda: Yeah yeah, he HAS to say that....

FUCKING LOL!
Click to expand...
He was alright last season before the live shows when he was just himself. Now that the producers have their hands on him. He's annoying as fuck. Can't stand him anymore.
 
#idol posted a video of the blind guy performing during hollywood week. less of him please. he keeps reminding me of jason earles (the guy that played the brother in hannah montana)
 
I thought she was gonna go Yael's version, but she put her own twist on it.

Chris Sligh stop yelling
 
Hell, might as well crown him now. How is he any different than Caleb?

(I totally forgot Caleb's name and had to Google him, lol)
 
just spamming on twitter because of gaf's post limit. but I'm in with Jax. everyone else is forgettable.

just put the guitar down please. youre doing nothing but making you look bad.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

XIX Chopin Competition - Eric Lu from the US wins 1st prize, second American, first in 50 years
|OT| 
10
630
Unknown Soldier replied
Oscars 2026 |OT|
2 3
149
2K
DKehoe replied
American Primeval (Netflix)
|OT| 
4
2K
I collect VHS tapes replied
X-Files Reboot
2 3 4
164
2K
jason10mm replied
  • Locked
Trump X 6ix9ne
5
334
Coconutt replied
Top Bottom