Not that P4 wasn't a great game but I am beyond tired of the Atlus retreads lately. I'm supporting the Innocent Sin release late this month because we've never officially had it in the US before (even though I played the game with the excellent fan translation several years ago!) but what I really, really want is a brand new SMT title in HD.
Put it on the PS3, the 360 AND the Vita for maximum sales potential and watch the accolades (and sales) flow in. Stop teasing me with old stuff, Atlus. Catherine was and is a great step forward into the current gen and I want more of that, not remade stuff out of the back catalog.