• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

August 28, 2009. A day that will live in infamy.

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's kinda like saying "I knew my Mom was sick and dying of cancer... and she died today, because I knew about it, means it doesn't affect me at all cuz I braced myself."

That's just stupid... it still affects those who still look forward to their future, just because you don't like them and place no value on them doesn't mean others feel the same way.
 
andymcc said:
:lol :lol hahaha yeah that's it.

Yeah way to dismiss the rest of my statements, you laugh at one part of it. If bands and artists said what they really wanted to say all the time like the Gallagher's did, they would be shunned by the public, no matter how good their music was.

If a band is friendly and kiss ass, they are popular even if their work isn't their best anymore.
 
Jenga said:
Then how come we've never heard of them?

Once you listen to them, you'll understand why. American radio doesn't play rock music anymore. Look what what passes for rock music on American radio these days - fucking Nickelback.

Oasis blew up worldwide in 1994-1995, everywhere except in the U.S. It was part bad-timing, and their own fuck-ups that they were never able to break as big in America as everywhere else around the world.

The bad-timing part is because the type of rock-and-roll they do is not what was popular in the U.S. in the mid 1990's. The 90's in America were all about grunge rock, slitting your wrists, and walking around in a fucking perma-depression to the beats of Nirvana and Pearl Jam. Oasis is more of a feel-good type of band, with a lot of mid to up tempo songs and a few acoustic sing-a-longs.

They also fucked up on what was to be their first major U.S. breakthrough tour and called it quits and went home. They were constantly fighting. Liam wanted to go home because they were blowing up huge in the U.K. and Noel didn't want to do what was necessary to break into U.S. radio and become popular. He's quoted as saying that their American record company basically wanted them to go around the country and 'hug the fat kids of all the record store owners', which is not really the type of work he was interested in doing when you consider that back in the U.K. they were coming off the biggest outdoor concerts in the country's history - 250,000 people each night over 2 nights at Knebworth and were being hailed as the 2nd coming of The Beatles and were being treated like gods.

Most of their stuff from 1998-2004 isn't all that great because they went through lineup changes and Noel quit doing cocaine. They saw a pretty big resurgence in 2005 and began selling out huge stadiums worldwide - except for the U.S. This current tour was their biggest ever, playing to over 70,000 each night for 3 nights in their home town of Manchester, and also playing to 50-75k each night for 3 nights at Wembley in London back at the end of July.
 
People mock Oasis for not having been heard from since 1995 or whatever... but some of these people are the same people that defend their fave indie band that nobody or few people have heard of and success/big sales =! good but since it's Oasis and they hate their arrogant attitude, they use anything to put them down. You can't change their views on Oasis, and they can't change ours on Oasis...it's a long standing battle since the band's earliest days of making it big. Oasis made it to the top against big odds...their style of music was not that popular in their heyday after grunge was dying out... they didn't kiss ass, their music was so good people were buzzing about it... then when their music stopped the same quality people backlashed against Oasis big time for their big mouths... for calling themselves "The biggest band in the world", that people quote all the time as to mock them because they aren't.

"Dig Out Your Soul" debuted the 2nd highest Oasis album on Billboard 's top 5 in 2008 since they came out, the first being Be Here Now(in 1997) off pure hype after Morning Glory was their huge album. So enough of America had heard of them, but they just didn't want to continue hearing about them because the music is not to everyone's tastes (the latest album is more psychadelic and less songy) and they still find Oasis' members arrogant (the two brothers) and annoying.

Oasis screwed themselves with their attitudes, that some people love, others loathe.
 
JDSN said:
Is this like bad Pulp?

Much like Pulp, they haven't been big since the britpop boom in 1994-1997. But Oasis still do very well around the world in comparison. But musically are very different.
 
BlueTsunami said:
Radiohead next, please.

Radiohead died to me after Ok Computer. But I wouldn't take pleasure and rubbing it in people's faces if they split, unlike some people in here because I understand their impact on people and while lately not of my taste, I can once appreciate them.
 
I have no idea why I clicked on this thread... i never in a million years would guess there would be something incredibly horrible about my fave band breaking up...then I suddenly knew what they were talking about...then I realise I shoulda looked at the OP poster... shoulda guessed it was about some brit band, most likely Oasis.
 
Otrebor Nightmarecoat said:
jesus christ i thought something had happens to america (fuck yeah). Good thing its only this shit, way to hyperbole the shit out of things dick.

totally uncalled for.

This is a global forum and just because this isn't a big deal in America doesn't mean that its not a big deal elsewhere.

Case in point.. its front page news in every London newspaper.

http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/
http://www.guardian.co.uk/
 
Honestly, as much as I liked Oasis's early albums and was pleasantly surprised by some song s on their latest, this is a good thing.

It sounds like a terrible thing to say, but they were better when they were young and on the drugs. Now, Liam is just too dull and his voice is dying. Maybe Noel knows he can do better by himself or whatever. What Oasis was for me died back in the 90s, I always felt like they were going through the motions.

Lets face it, if this is really the end of the band, they will be remembered most for the songs they put out early on (first two albums, Masterplan). People tolerated their douchery back then only because they had good songs to back their shit-talking up. The good songs left a long time ago. Hopefully Noel ,without his (now worthless musically) brother holding him back, can now make some music with some enjoyment put back into it.
 
Damn im still sad about this... :/
But happy for Noel, im sure he is going to release a kickass solo album. I dunno about Liam.
Day one for both solo albums
 
Calcaneus said:
Honestly, as much as I liked Oasis's early albums and was pleasantly surprised by some song s on their latest, this is a good thing.

It sounds like a terrible thing to say, but they were better when they were young and on the drugs. Now, Liam is just too dull and his voice is dying. Maybe Noel knows he can do better by himself or whatever. What Oasis was for me died back in the 90s, I always felt like they were going through the motions.

Lets face it, if this is really the end of the band, they will be remembered most for the songs they put out early on (first two albums, Masterplan). People tolerated their douchery back then only because they had good songs to back their shit-talking up. The good songs left a long time ago. Hopefully Noel ,without his (now worthless musically) brother holding him back, can now make some music with some enjoyment put back into it.

Oasis is the gallagher brothers.

Noel doing solo, is just Noel doing solo. I want Oasis, not just a Noel solo project... honestly the b-sides released have been mostly Noel solo projects of him trying to sing the same style of song over and over again... they aren't the rock songs we loved.

I have been critical of Liam's voice even since the Morning Glory days when I heard him sing live honestly... but I think enough time I got used to it, and it seemed lately on this tour Liam is trying very very hard to save his voice because he knows it's starting to give... he was putting effort into his voice by not wrenching it everytime to the point it gives out... and he contributes to song-writing, sure he's not as good as Noel was back in the day but if given more time we coulda had so much better. Now we'll never know... in the group dynamic.

I too have noticed Oasis going through the motions, especially Noel, but I cannot fathom the band is finally over.

I am pretty pissed if Noel pursues this for real, Noel said in some interviews despite the differences between him and Liam he owes Liam for his fame and where he is today, or else he'd be some lowly thug in the Manchester streets.
 
bill0527 said:
Seriously, these fucking ignorant comments are almost ban-worthy.

They just released their greatest critically acclaimed album in over a decade last fall. They also sold over 2 million copies of it... which is probably 1,999,000 more copies than whatever shithead indie band you're fantasizing about these days. Dig Out Your Soul was a great album and easily their best since 1995. Oh and .. gasp.. for all you people that think they're nothing but 3 chord wonders - they also threw in some Sitar and Keyboards on a few songs in DOYS.
That bit about sales figures and indie bands was the argument of a philistine and really undermines your point. The mention of the sitar and keyboard was a bit lol, too. That's a gimmick.
 
pjberri said:
That bit about sales figures and indie bands was the argument of a philistine and really undermines your point. The mention of the sitar and keyboard was a bit lol, too. That's a gimmick.

It's not a gimmick, the band were moving in the direction of psychadelic music, a music style they are influenced by lately from the 60's (an era of music they love)... and the band member that utilised the sitar was actually a song written by a new band member (well newer than the gallagher bro's) anyways.

So either their music is too simple, but using other instruments is gimmicky? I just think you don't want to like their music and will poke in holes in logic to convince yourself and other people the band sucks. It's not gonna happen, leave us alone and let us mourn the band's breakup... can't even wait a full day or week before raining in on our parade, like we are not allowed to miss our fave band, despite it isn't one of yours.
 
Oasis sucked in the sense that they blatantly ripped off other bands, had shitty lyrics and Noel,Liam acted like idiots. That said, I think they're one of the best generic bar bands ever. They were totally in it for the money as soon as Noel joined the group and they clearly didn't give a shit.
 
Red Blaster said:
Oasis sucked in the sense that they blatantly ripped off other bands, had shitty lyrics and Noel,Liam acted like idiots. That said, I think they're one of the best generic bar bands ever. They were totally in it for the money as soon as Noel joined the group.

That argument is old.

They never made a secret about their influences or what they desired in life, they were up front about it all. We found it refreshing instead of the hypocrisy that people say yeah I am original and then they insert "generic" pentatonic blues run in their riffs or sample another song.

People that use generic and throw it around like they think their bands are the most original people on earth, get over yourself. We like the music we like, you like yours, so shut up like you know what you are talking about to sway us from thinking this news should be mean less or nothing to us.
 
I never liked them. Songs sucked ass, and I heard how they used to get wasted and perform like shit on stage, only play for 30 minutes, etc. No idea why anyone likes these assholes.
 
HurricaneJesus said:
I never liked them. Songs sucked ass, and I heard how they used to get wasted and perform like shit on stage, only play for 30 minutes, etc. No idea why anyone likes these assholes.
:lol fucking morons in this thread, jesus

I heard Liam kicked a small puppy once
 
FUCK YOU to those comparing Oasis to Creed.

This sucks, but I least I saw their last tour. Im pretty sure they'll get back together as they have a history of grievances and then they patch it up the way lads usually do.

And honestly, if another "Talk Tonight" gets made because of all this it will be worth it. God I love that song.
 
"Oasis is the best British Rock Band since the Beatles, OOOOOASSSIS RUUUULES!"

"I'm still wearing women's Underwear"
 
When I read some time ago that Noel and Liam hadn't spoken to each other in years, I was wondering how long till this happened. Expected a peaceful "Noel going solo" news, not more cancellations. Oh well.

* Plays Don't Look Back in Anger *
 
Meier said:
A day that will live in infamy.
Not...likely.

I like certain Oasis songs. Really. And they're occasionally good for another decent-sounding tune. But as much as this may bother some hardcore fans, this won't make much of a blip otherwise. The thread title alone... gah. Come on.
 
Only the brothers would be able to pull this huge dick move of epic proportions by having egos so large they couldn't possibly play 3 gigs for loyal fans who've basically made them into the stars they are today instead of just living their lives out as loudmouth Manc twats.

Hardly a surprise after last weeks events at V Festival to be honest, looks like whoever called them out last weekend in the papers was spot on (I can't remember who it was, James Morrison or someone)
 
MrSeaneyC said:
Only the brothers would be able to pull this huge dick move of epic proportions by having egos so large they couldn't possibly play 3 gigs for loyal fans who've basically made them into the stars they are today instead of just living their lives out as loudmouth Manc twats.

Hardly a surprise after last weeks events at V Festival to be honest, looks like whoever called them out last weekend in the papers was spot on (I can't remember who it was, James Morrison or someone)

they're dicks, no doubt, but this entitlement attitude is just silly. i don't think musicians or entertainers make any promises and they don't owe their fans anything. they make music, you give them money for music, you're even.
 
HurricaneJesus said:
I never liked them. Songs sucked ass, and I heard how they used to get wasted and perform like shit on stage, only play for 30 minutes, etc. No idea why anyone likes these assholes.

:lol You do realise that music is subjective right? That not everyone agrees that their 'songs sucked ass'.

Obviously you're entitled to your opinion but just to say 'Songs sucked ass ... No idea why anyone likes these assholes' is such a silly statement to make.
 
I'm in no way a fan but as most people, I liked their most famous songs. A bit bummed I couldn't see them yesterday night. I just think now that they are stupid for not being able to get their act together after all these years. Fucking divas...

At least the Yeah Yeah Yeahs concert was pretty awesome and the chick I saw instead of Oasis put out a pretty rad performance. And there's still a lot of great artists over the week end.

It's really a shame for those who came to France especially to see them. Fuck them.

EDIT :
Mistouze
user-friendly man-cashews

WAAAATTTTT, FUCKING MEGATON, I HAS GOT A TAG.

Now the question is : what the fuck could it mean?:lol
 
This is like 1/1000000000th as important as when the Smiths went away. Moz and Marr will make up, I just know it! :clutches roses:
 
bjork said:
This is like 1/1000000000th as important as when the Smiths went away. Moz and Marr will make up, I just know it! :clutches roses:

Pfff

I want my Misfits back!

Get your shit together guys!

Get back in shape Glenn
.
 
gdt5016 said:
Pfff

I want my Misfits back!

Get your shit together guys!

Get back in shape Glenn
.

Well then I want my original B-52's lineup back!

Come back from the dead, Ricky! :(
 
To steer from the negativity and arguing with people who are obviously here to troll Oasis and rub it in fan's faces...

I do hope this is just one of those cases where Noel says or does something rash, and then days or weeks later they get back together.

But there's just something so real about having this blog posted officially on their website.
 
I got into Oasis after playing Rock Band. Like most everyone, I had heard Wonderwall at some part of my life, but I wasn't familiar with anything else. I enjoyed Live Forever, Don't Look Back In Anger, and Rock and Roll Star in the game, so I checked out their other stuff.

My favorite album of theirs is Be Here Now. It apparently gets a bad rap, but I love every song on there, especially Do You Know What I Mean, My Big Mouth, and Stand By Me. The albums after their first three definitely don't measure up, but there are still enjoyable songs within all of them (the difference is you have to put up with some other ones, too). Go Let It Out is probably in my Oasis top 5.

Since I've only really been listening to them for two years, the news doesn't tear me up as much as some others. Likewise, I missed all of the drama of the 1990s rivalries, so that doesn't bother me either. Sure, other members have written more songs on the later albums, but aside from a couple, most of the best ones are still the ones Noel wrote. I hope they can just take a break and then put this behind them (it's been a very long tour). But if not, I will look forward to some Noel solo albums.
 
Randy5554 said:
My favorite album of theirs is Be Here Now. It apparently gets a bad rap, but I love every song on there, especially Do You Know What I Mean, My Big Mouth, and Stand By Me.

oh man the hate that album gets is absurd.. it's not my favorite but it has some real gems.

The songs you mentioned + Don't Go Away, All Around the World (overly bloated and long sure but it's a classic) + Fade In-Out
 
Randy5554 said:
I got into Oasis after playing Rock Band. Like most everyone, I had heard Wonderwall at some part of my life, but I wasn't familiar with anything else. I enjoyed Live Forever, Don't Look Back In Anger, and Rock and Roll Star in the game, so I checked out their other stuff.

My favorite album of theirs is Be Here Now. It apparently gets a bad rap, but I love every song on there, especially Do You Know What I Mean, My Big Mouth, and Stand By Me. The albums after their first three definitely don't measure up, but there are still enjoyable songs within all of them (the difference is you have to put up with some other ones, too). Go Let It Out is probably in my Oasis top 5.

Since I've only really been listening to them for two years, the news doesn't tear me up as much as some others. Likewise, I missed all of the drama of the 1990s rivalries, so that doesn't bother me either. Sure, other members have written more songs on the later albums, but aside from a couple, most of the best ones are still the ones Noel wrote. I hope they can just take a break and then put this behind them (it's been a very long tour). But if not, I will look forward to some Noel solo albums.

Did you ever download the Dig Out Your Soul pack for Rock Band? The album is probably one of the worst ideas to put into Rock Band, the song structure ideas are the simplest, even by Oasis standards... the only thing it was good for was the drum solo in The Shock of the Lightning, that's it.

I'm glad you like Be Here Now, it's an album that grows over time... it was panned because it was not Morning Glory, and a chance to be rid of Oasis in most people's views for their cocky attitude, that people cannot stand in stars...they want humble people who play the game, and they are the antithesis.
 
"I care about Oasis in 2009"

"Radiohead lost me after OKC"

"Never heard a Bloc Party song"

Are you somebody's dad? Jesus Christ, cranky old man.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom