• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Battlefront 2 Alpha Impressions

prag16

Banned
Man, fuck this game. I know it might sound hyperbolic, but that really bugged me in the first game. This sounds just as dumb.

What? No it doesn't. This sounds drastically better. The battle points system seems pretty solid and reasonable on the whole, from what we've seen so far.
 
Unknown at this point, the mode available in the alpha is basically prequel era walker assault
Ugh. Is it at least a better walker assault and more like battlefield rush?
I just want the thirdperson camera zoomed back like the previous game. Way too zoomed in right now, looks like shit.
Ugh
It does. There's a metric ton of customizations in BF1.
There is but I can also see them not having a lot of those in battlefront 2 because it's "casual" and people "don't like settings" or some other excuse. Also if the 3rd person FOV is super low by default that means that getting it to the original games would probably have a pretty big impact on framerate.
 

b0bbyJ03

Member
Wouldn't be a first with this series, it attracts an ungodly amount of irrational hatred. The thread after the debut trailer was full of naysayers crying downgrade 6 months before release. I have never seen as much digested crow in my life.

I'm generally here to be positive (you can check my history, I don't complain much), but I don't like this either. I think it stems from the precedent that the Battlefield games set. It's pretty awesome to be able to get in and out of vehicles. you can see all the ridiculous videos on youtube of people doing absurd shit in planes/choppers/ground vehicles by being able to jump in and out. It adds many layers to the gameplay. I think its unfortunate that they don't have it.
 

Vic_Viper

Member
How is spawning into a vehicle vs entering an empty one on the map a dealbreaker? It just seems like you wanted an excuse to not like The game.

This is how the first game was too lol. Yeah its not the best way to do vehicles imo but it works fine imo. If anything the old way caused getting vehicles, especially flight, a pain in the ass since people would just rush them or spawn directly in them. This way they spread them out more and is easier for everyone to get a chance to try it out.

I like that they are giving everyone the Maps this time instead of having them be pay for DLC.
 
Lack of destruction in this was a backwards choice by DICE. Pathetic how you can get in a tank or Starfighter and have zero impact on the environment. What kind of progress is this for a SW fps?
 

Machina

Banned
Do factions have specific traits or a normal droid does the same as a normal clonetrooper/stormtrooper?

Nah it seems normal droid and normal trooper are identical, but obviously specialist classes like Battle Droid and jump trooper have their own unique attributes
 
The eurogamer article stated that the best cards (legendary) can only be obtained via RNG.

The argument over how much RNG, or P2W grind is 'okay' misses the point. For the player, the best amount of RNG or P2W grind is zero.

But watch those goalposts move. Clearly I should think about EA's need to make money first, not about how it impacts my experience with the game.
 
The argument over how much RNG, or P2W grind is 'okay' misses the point. For the player, the best amount of RNG or P2W grind is zero.

But watch those goalposts move. Clearly I should think about EA's need to make money first, not about how it impacts my experience with the game.
Do you know what would impact your experience more? Paywalled maps, heroes, and weapons.
 

prag16

Banned
Not sure if this has been answered, but how dramatically has the gunplay changed? Did the changes to ADS, etc, turn it into a Battlefield clone in terms of the shooting?

Do you know what would impact your experience more? Paywalled maps, heroes, and weapons.

Yep. Some people will never be happy.
 

WadeitOut

Member
Loving it so far. I was a huge fan of the first one and I'm a massive SW fanboy though.

It looks absolutely stunning imo. This is about as much as I'm going to say with the NDA.
 

ZZMitch

Member
The framerate was solid as hell in the first installment, hoping like hell that's still the case.

I am playing on a two year old laptop (was pretty top of the line when I got it admittedly) and the game runs fine here with all settings at least medium. Never dropping below 30 FPS.
 

CSJ

Member
Its irrationally hyperbolic.

It's essentially the same as Battlefield 1. You spawn directly into the vehicles but if you bail out they explode so that the enemy team can't steal them.


Battlefront isn't a vehicle driven game, it never has been.

Make it so the enemy team literally cannot enter the vehicle instead of exploding it, maybe? Is that really too hard to conjure up in the imagination of a professional AAA game studio.

Come on.
 
Man, fuck this game. I know it might sound hyperbolic, but that really bugged me in the first game. This sounds just as dumb.
Yeah I really hate someone getting to use a vehicle based on merit rather than whoever memorizes spawns and then hogs the thing the entire match.
 
Make it so the enemy team literally cannot enter the vehicle instead of exploding it, maybe? Is that really too hard to conjure up in the imagination of a professional AAA game studio.

Come on.
Or just allow them to enter it because that's sandbox game play fuckery at its finest.
 

Brandon F

Well congratulations! You got yourself caught!
How do you get into vehicles in this game? Pleeeeease tell me you get into them on the ground and take off, none of that stupid coin collecting shit.

Came for this answer as well.

Oh and answered. Still sounds like vehicles are powerups rather than part of the map. Not a fan.
 

SummitAve

Banned
Yeah I really hate someone getting to use a vehicle based on merit rather than whoever memorizes spawns and then hogs the thing the entire match.

I personally think the emergent gameplay that occurs from having vehicles on the map outweighs the occasional shitty room that you can always just jump out of.
 
they've got cards for fighters and heroes now?

that could go poorly

weapon attachments lol
I'm not happy about the weapon attachments, but it looks like you can only have one modification. So at least it won't be bananas like COD and BF4.

The cards for heroes only enhance their latent abilities. For example Maul has a card that when equipped increased the damage and distance thrown of the choke throw ability.
 

Xyzzy J

Banned
There are people in here whose first thought is to put some random gamer on blast for breaking a publisher's non-disclosure agreement to share benign - indeed, positive - impressions of a video game they just played and thought was fun.

They don't even know the circumstances under which the person played the game or whether/how the NDA applies. They just want to make sure that, if someone arguably broke it, they're called to task for it.

Think about that.

Well, in that case, are you alright for a supplier to refuse to give you $20 worth of products you ordered after you already paid for them? If they do it on the basis that they've decided a lot of people don't like you? Wouldn't want to put the supplier on blast for breaking a contract for that involves a fairly insignificant amount of money and a buyer who many people don't like! It's only a contract, after all. No need for anyone to get too bothered.
 

Machina

Banned
Well, in that case, are you alright for a supplier to refuse to give you $20 worth of products you ordered after you already paid for them? If they do it on the basis that they've decided a lot of people don't like you? Wouldn't want to put the supplier on blast for breaking a contract for that involves a fairly insignificant amount of money and a buyer who many people don't like! It's only a contract, after all. No need for anyone to get too bothered.

I think streamers and screenshoters have a lot more to worry about than a random forum poster answering questions which 70% of the time I'm sure are already public record
 
Top Bottom