Support NeoGAF

[.Pennywise]

This match is part of the Game of the Generation Tournament. For rules, details and current brackets go to the Tournament thread (Click)

 

[Digity]

Bloodborne was garbage, MGSV all day.

 

[Joelenheimer]

I chose MGSV, but I understand Bloodborne will win this. It's a fucking great game.

 

[Dogman]

Well the thread already sucks

 

[Esca]

Bloodborne ftw

 

[Strider311]

So hard to choose. Metal Gear is one of my favorite series and I loved MGSV. But Bloodborne might be my GOAT.

 

[MightySquirrel]

Gotta go with MGS5. Gameplay vs hmmm... hm ?

 

[Astral Dog]

Whaaaa
Did Bloodborne won over The Witcher 3?

 

[mm928]

Bloodborne is not good.

 

[iHaunter]

Not even close, Bloodborne.

 

[Rickyiez]

Not even close x2 . Bloodborne

 

[SlimySnake]

Wait, what? how did mgsv win? botw was leading by like 15 points? wtf happened?

 

[Mr Hyde]

Did Bloodborne won over The Witcher 3?

No. This is for 3rd place. The Witcher 3 is pitted against Breath of the Wild in the finals.

 

[bender]

Wait, what? how did mgsv win? botw was leading by like 15 points? wtf happened?

Losers bracket.

 

[SlimySnake]

Losers bracket.

the fuck. when did they do the bloodborne poll? i never saw that thread.

it only lost by a few votes.

 

[Astral Dog]

No. This is for 3rd place. The Witcher 3 is pitted against Breath of the Wild in the finals.

sorry but if Witcher 3 wins this thing im gonna puke

 

[Beardsalt]

Bloodborne all day!

I‘ve played and finished every Metal Gear game dating back to the original NES classics. That being said, MGS5 was my least favorite and the Soulsborne series took over my interest for a declining MGS series!

My oponion so don’t be offended!

 

[rubhen925]

Bloodborne all day. While MSGV did have the best open world stealth elements. It had generic missions and structure outside of bosses and some main missions. Story was all over the place too. Bloodborne revolutionized the souls-borne series and revitalized gaming for the PS4 when it launched in 2015. Plus it just oozes atmosphere and is completely unique to every other game in the genre. It stands tall on its own.

 

[Kagoshima_Luke]

Complete tie for me. Both great games, but neither is the best in their respective series.

I voted MGSV, since it is probably the underdog and could use some help.

 

[bender]

the fuck. when did they do the bloodborne poll? i never saw that thread.

it only lost by a few votes.

You failed us. You are now only allowed to play the Witcher 3 with its' lackluster mechanics until the day you die.

 

[Beardsalt]

the fuck. when did they do the bloodborne poll? i never saw that thread.

it only lost by a few votes.

Funny thing is, it was the highest in votes at 896 (458/438) if I remember correctly!
It‘s as if all the PC and Xbox boys voted to make sure Bloodborne didn’t win!

Oh and before I’m labeled as a fanboy, yes, I’m a Soulsborne diehard!

 

[bender]

Funny thing is, it was the highest in votes at 896 (458/438) if I remember correctly!
It‘s as if all the PC and Xbox boys voted to make sure Bloodborne didn’t win!

Oh and before I’m labeled as a fanboy, yes, I’m a Soulsborne diehard!

We are all Nintendiots in the finals.

 

[SlimeGooGoo]

.

 

[bender]

 

[Tschumi]

MGSV but it's a foregone conclusion. Both stunning games.. just goes to show how DAMN good MGSV could have been with another act or two about Eli and the like.

 

[Wunray]

Mgs V plays better and has better gameplay mechanics, at the end of the day isn't a finished product, Bloodborne imo is the ps4 defining game and the game to finally give from the respect they deserved, while not on the level of TW3 or BoTW they are both masterpieces and among the greatest of all time.

Edit: just checked the time on the poll, bro we don't need 7 days to decide 3rd place its going to be Bloodborne.

 

[bender]

MGSV but it's a foregone conclusion. Both stunning games.. just goes to show how DAMN good MGSV could have been with another act or two about Eli and the like.

 

[Tschumi]

Who's that? Rudi giuliani? Bwaha~

For real did i say something deserving of a meme?

 

[bender]

Who's that? Rudi giuliani? Bwaha~

For real did i say something deserving of a meme?

Maybe I was too obtuse. Kiefer would have ruined any additional story in MGSV.

 

[Moonjt9]

Bloodborne all the way. I love MGS but I just can’t see Bloodborne losing. It’s one of the best games of all time.

 

[Tschumi]

Maybe I was too obtuse. Kiefer would have ruined any additional story in MGSV.

You betta WATCHIT boy

 

[Digity]

What is the story behind this picture? lol

 

[Explosive Zombie]

the fuck. when did they do the bloodborne poll? i never saw that thread.

it only lost by a few votes.

Call me a conspiracy theorist but every time Bloodborne got more votes so did Witcher 3, I monitored that poll and there was around a 20 vote gap between them for half the time, even as both kept climbing. In the first 100-200 votes they remained dead even most the match, though. So, basically, your vote wouldn't have helped.

 

[bender]

What is the story behind this picture? lol

Sometimes you need to let your balls breathe.

 

[Manji Uzuki]

Bloodborne as its the game of the gen for me. MGS was great as well but the story told through those damn cassette tapes was just awful.

 

[R6Rider]

Bloodborne

 

[Lakos]

MGSV

 

[Roufianos]

People voting MGSV obviously weren't good enough for Bloodborne. They didn't grow or improve. Nothing was risked and nothing was gained.

Man, the Souls community is among the most annoying in gaming.

 

[Jigsaah]

Can somebody explain why we are still voting on Bloodborne? Is this the losers bracket?
EDIT
Ok i actually read some of the posts. Who did MGSV lose to?

 

[BaneIsPain]

Abstain. Maybe will flip a coin later.

 

[Jigsaah]

People voting MGSV obviously weren't good enough for Bloodborne. They didn't grow or improve. Nothing was risked and nothing was gained.

Man, the Souls community is among the most annoying in gaming.

I beat bloodborne several times. I voted MGSV because I genuinely enjoyed the game more. The music is better, i cannot betray Snake (salutes) open world with lots of freedom. Fun modes, constant updates and events and imma simp for Quiet.

Add to the fact the both of these games are based on predecessors of sorts. I believe both games expanded upon their predecessors but I just feel MGSV had gone much further in that expansion. Both games make it into my top 10 i think. So it wasnt an easy choice.

 

[ReLaxative]

Kind of hard to pick those apart.

MGS:V has way more freedom of gameplay, while Bloodborne has a much deeper storytelling.

Still, I played Bloodborne twice as much, so I'll go with that.

 

[DonJorginho]

This should've been the real final.

 

[Digity]

Can somebody explain why we are still voting on Bloodborne? Is this the losers bracket?
EDIT
Ok i actually read some of the posts. Who did MGSV lose to?

Zelda Breath Of The Wild.

 

[ShirAhava]

BB is a good game released during a weak generation so naturally its overrated

MGSV would be one of the best games of any generation

 

[Jigsaah]

Zelda Breath Of The Wild.

Ugh. I can't say how I feel about that. I've never played it. I guess good for Zelda

 

[Boss Mog]

The only good thing about this whole tournament for me was that TLOU2 was unceremoniously dumped out in the first round by Persona 5.

 

[Kokoloko85]

My 2 favourites. Ill go with Bloodbourne because I love the lore and lovecraft story

 

[CrysisFreak]

Playing Bloodborne AFTER Nioh 2 is impossible. Absolutely disgusting. FYI recently found out by me like jeez it does not feel good nowadays.

 

[Resenge]

BB is a good game released during a weak generation so naturally its overrated

MGSV would be one of the best games of any generation