• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Blu-ray or HD DVD, GAFfers which do you support.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ok, So I know there is a continualy running takeover thread, but this will be a little different. I had the idea to make a thread like this several weeks back but havnt gotten around to it untill now.

So lets set some ground rules here to keep things organized.

There are 5 catagories of support:

Blu-ray
bluray.gif

If you have chosen to support Blu-ray
HD DVD
hd-dvd_logo.gif

If you have chonse to support HD DVD
Dual Format
hd_dvd_n_blu-ray_stacked_60pc.jpg

If yu are supporting both untill one format wins over the other
DVD
dvd_logo_01.gif

If you have chosen to wait on the fence untill a winner is decided
Not Supporting
If you refuse to support either format

Whatever catagory you fall under, (if it's one of the 2 next gen formats) list what type of player you have, and how many titles you have in there respective catagorys, Feel free to even list them, Unless you pick DVD, in which case maybe just give a number, no need to like your 300 DVD's. :)

As this thread grows I will update this first topic with a list of users, what format they support, number of titles owned, and player.



The List



Blu-ray (68):
acklame, PS3
Alkemist,
AlphaSnake,
Argyle, (12) PS3
Bad_Boy, (11) PS3
Blablurn, PS3
Black Deatha, (15) PS3
Carl2282, (3) PS3
captive, (21) PS3
Chrono, PS3
ChryZ, (4) PS3
chubigans, (15)
Ckid,
Cmdr. Solrak, (7) PS3
Cold-Steel, (1) PS3
CrushDance,
CurlySaysX, (1) PS3
CurseoftheGods (5) PS3
Dangerous Porno Pipeline, PS3
DCharlie,
distantmantra, (7) PS3
djkimothy, (6) PS3
dmann, (4) PS3
DoctorWho, (2) PS3
Erdrick, (21) PS3
EviLore, 922) PS3
Flo_Evans, (5) PS3
Forsete, (3) PS3
Gadeus, (2) PS3
ghostmind, PS3
iapetus,
Ignatz Mouse, (12) PS3
jakershaker,
jjasper, (10) PS3
Khalid-S,
Kleegamefan, (40)
Laguna X,
lupin23rd, (4)
mackaveli, (4) PS3
McBacon, PS3
Miburou, (14) PS3
MickeyKnox, (2?) PS3
monochromatic, PS3
Mrbob, PS3
mrklaw, (18) PS3
Onix, (11) PS3
OokieSpookie,
Pachinko,
painey, PS3
Petrarca, (63)
Phoenix,
Pimpwerx,
Pristine_Condition, (22) PS3
Rabid Wolverine, (4) PS3
S. L.,
Saint Ajola, (55) PS3
sakuragi,
snorggy, (4) PS3
SonnyBoy,
Spiderjericho,
Suikoguy, (15) PS3
sutdawg, PS3
TerryLee81, PS3
TheFallen,
xemumanic
XMonkey,
Zaptruder,
Zoe, (6) PS3

HD DVD (18):
Borci88,
ChrisJames, (17) 360 Drive
Crowza,
Days like these..., (8) 360 Drive
Meier, (8) 360 Drive
Miktrebla, (14) 360 Drive
purnoman3000, (16) 360 Drive/Toshiba HD-A2
Sallokin, (3) 360 Drive
Sh0k, (30) 360 Drive
Snookie, (7) 360 Drive
TAJ, (73) Toshiba HD-A2
TheJesusFactor, (2) 360 Drive
The Main Event, (15) Toshiba HD-A2
VanMardigan, (3) 360 Drive
Vark, 350 Drive
VictimOfGrief, 360 Drive
Warm Machine, 360 Drive
WULFER, (7) 360 Drive

Dual Format (18):
AgentOtaku, (7) BD, (3) HD
Bebpo, (16) BD, (9) HD
BobLoblaw, (14) BD, (11) HD
DarkJediKnight, (14) BD, (5) HD
druie, (2) BD, (4) HD PS3, 360 Drive
IJoel, (9) BD, (9) HD PS3, 360 Drive
JediMasterMatt,
jet1911, (5) HD 360 Drive
lessthanthree, PS3, 360 Drive (leaning BRD)
ManaByte, (20) BD, (8) HD PS3, 360 Drive
Matrix, (16) BD, (10) HD PS3, 360 Drive
NomarTyme,
OverHeat,
plagiarize, (4) BD, (11) HD PS3, 360 Drive
rage1973,
Triz, (leaning BRD)
wasting, (12) BD, (32) HD
Zylander,

DVD (21):
broadwayrock
celpacius
Cheesemeister
DSN2K
f_elz
Gamecocks625
gollumsluvslave,
heavy liquid
Hotarubi
Jake XXX
jey_16
Kabuki Waq
Kindbudmaster
marvelharvey
norinrad21
Shard
Solo
tnw
unomas
VPhys
woxel1

Not Supporting (10):
Bildi
bud
djtiesto
Giard
GSG Flash
hadareud
Shinobi
SonicMegaDrive
Souldriver
xabre
 
bluray.gif


Player: Playstation 3

Titles: 15
Mission Impossable Ultimate Mission Collection (3 titles)
Tellidega Knights (PS3 pack in)
Kingdom of Heaven
Sky Captain:And the World of Tommorow
Superman Returns
Terminator 2: Judgement Day
Crank
Goodfellas
The Departed
Reign of Fire
The Prestige
Reservior Dogs
Casino Royale
 
I'm supporting Blu-ray by default, because I'll be getting a free player for it in the PS3 (and hopefully a free copy of Casino Royale to go with it). I'm borderline not supporting at the same time, because I don't see Blu-ray movies as impulse purchases for me at their current price point - I buy the vast majority of my DVDs in the three for ÂŁ10 type sales at HMV and similar, so until HD movies hit that sort of price point my collection will remain small.
 
vhscq5.jpg



But seriously: not supporting any format at the moment. I'll eventually buy the format that wins. Right now it's too risky, expensive and (sometimes) fanboyish to really support a format.
 
bluray. I have about 18 titles here or in the mail.

No particular politics behind the switch. First I was HDDVD only as bluray releases were supposedly terrible. Then I got a PS3 so I was dual format, but preferred to buy on HDDVD as blind purchases were 'safer'.

But due to needing to buy a new amp I sold my toshiba E1 and discs. There are enough bluray movies to sustain me (plus I have HD movies via satellite) and so I'll wait to see if Universal come over.
And quality is much better than initial launch, so its a safe bet.



And I've sold most of my DVDs and have no intention of buying any more - its a dead end format so I won't throw more money into it than I already have.

ALL movies will benefit from HD.
 
I'm planning to buy a PS3 when it launches in the U.A.E , Dubai on March 23 so obviously I am supporting blu-ray. I also will definitely buy some blu-ray movies to take full advantage of the PS3's feature. Its there already so why not make use of it? :)
 
Easy answer!...I wanna watch most movies and most blockbusters in high def.

63 titles so far, Casino Royale is my latest addition :D

bluray.gif
 
I'm supporting digital distribution because that is where the future is, for music, games and movies. It's already supplanting CD's as the preferred medium for music and it'll supplant disc based formats as the preferred medium for high definition video content.
 
I don't have a television, so pretty much if I want to watch movies it's going to be on my computer. It has a DVD drive. I pretty much only rent movies anyway, so it's going to be awhile before I start supporting Bluray.

My company is in the Bluray manafacturers alliance though.
 
DVD thanks

I'm only going to be interested in upgrading when technology has advanced far enough to project full colour holograms into my living room. (possibly in Wii2?)
 
HD DVD for me. I have the 360 add on and 7 titles.

Batman Begins
V for Vendetta
Casino
The Departed
Superman Returns
King Kong
Miami Vice


I havent been all impressed with the Blu-Ray titles coming out. The only one right now I wish I had on HD DVD is Casino Royale.
 
Blu-ray: PS3
2 Titles: The Departed, Superman Returns

Originally, I had no intention of supporting either format, but when I acquired a PS3, I decided to buy a movie to see how the quality was. I was reasonably impressed, and was even more so by the second title I picked up, The Departed, so I decided to switch over to Blu-Ray. However, I rarely bought any movies at all before I started watching Blu-ray movies. I only owned 3 DVDs: (The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly), Pulp Fiction, and Reservoir Dogs.
 
Chrono said:
Well I have a PS3 so it's Blu-ray for me. The fact that it's the superior format also helps. :p
The fact that it will be obsolete in a few years, and HD-DVD will reign over all, will help us supporters of HD-DVD get a bigger ego.
 
Neither, I'll stick with DVD until HD digital distribution becomes viable (probably pretty damn soon).
 
I'm sticking with DVD. I don't have a HDTV, all I own are seasons of The Office and Seinfeld, and my wife and I rarely buy DVDs so we rent them from Blockbuster.
 
hd_dvd_n_blu-ray_stacked_60pc.jpg

i have the hd-dvd drive for the 360 and the PS3.

I have 11 HD-DVDs and while i only have 2 Blu-Rays right now, casino royale is in the post and Rocky Balboa will be coming to me soon. since getting my PS3 i've bought more Blu-Rays than I have HD-DVDs.

HD-DVD

The Thing
Serenity
Pitch Black
Slither
Chronicles of Riddick
The Fog (original Carpenter version and an import)
Clerks 2
Terminator 3
Land of the Dead
American Werewolf in London
King Kong

Blu-Ray

Saw 3
The Terminator
Casino Royale (in the mail)
Rocky Balboa (preordered and coming soon)
 
bluray.gif

Blu-Ray via PS3

Titles include:

Talladega Nights (I have yet to see this one)
Superman Returns
Fifth Element
Kingdom of Heaven
The Prestige
The Departed
Casino Royale
 
Cmdr. Solrak said:
Blu-Ray via PS3

Titles include:

Talladega Nights (I have yet to see this one)
Superman Returns
Fifth Element
Kingdom of Heaven
The Prestige
The Departed
Casino Royale
i was hoping my PS3 would still come with a copy of talladega nights when i bought it.

i wanted to see if microwaving a blu-ray has the same effect as microwaving a CD or a DVD. :)
 
Blu-Ray by default.

Kingdom of Heaven
Talladega Nights (ugh!)
The Departed
Superman Returns
The Prestige

In the mail: Casino Royale. :D
 
I'm going to get a Ps3 down the road so it'll be BR for me. I'm not going to kick out an extra $200 for HD-DVD. If it came with my 360, I may have purchased some titles for it.
 
bluray.gif



40 or so titles, including my newest addition, Casino Royale :D


If a Universal movie I like comes out, I just buy the DVD version :P
 
Kleegamefan said:
bluray.gif



40 or so titles, including my newest addition, Casino Royale :D


If a Universal movie I like comes out, I just buy the DVD version :P
i couldn't wait for Universal to go agnostic to own The Thing in HD.

of all the catalogue titles i've seen, it's the one that benefited the most from it too.
 
djkimothy said:
So like, does the manufacturing plant have a conveyor belt directly to your house?

Or you must know the delivery guy by name. ;)
Petrarca is, for better or worse, easily the strongest Blu-Ray supporter on these forums, and he's never pretended otherwise.

he sure knows how to support a format.
 
Blu Ray (got a PS3)
-Casino Royale
-Saw III
-The Prestige
-The Departed
-Open Season
-Black Hawk Down
-Kung Fu Hustle
-Kingdom of Heaven
-Talladega Nights (got the shit version free, watched 2 mins I seriously think it is a DVD transfer on a Blu ray disk)
-First Blood
 
jjasper said:
Blu Ray (got a PS3)
-Casino Royale
-Saw III
-The Prestige
-The Departed
-Open Season
-Black Hawk Down
-Kung Fu Hustle
-Kingdom of Heaven
-Talladega Nights (got the shit version free, watched 2 mins I seriously think it is a DVD transfer on a Blu ray disk)
-First Blood
it isn't, but it's one of the worst rated Blu-Ray transfers out there.

it still boggles the mind as to why sony picked that one to show off the format over here.
 
plagiarize said:
it isn't, but it's one of the worst rated Blu-Ray transfers out there.

it still boggles the mind as to why sony picked that one to show off the format over here.

They've learnt the error of their ways and are sending us late launchers a copy of Casino Royale!

Kinda.
 
plagiarize said:
well, Casino Royale is a smart move, espescially in the UK.

Talladega Nights on the other hand... was just bananas.

Seriously, there so many better films to choose from. Hell, I would have been happy with Fifth Element despite it's low PQ.
 
Blu-Ray. Casino Royale and Crank will be my first two purchases. But I'm still skeptical of the format, not enough releases on Blu-Ray.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom