I don't understand your argument. How are these two statements contradictory?
And how is it a "narrative" when
Infinity Ward has come right out and said so?
I think this disagreement comes from 2 different view points from the information we have, neither bit of information is technically contradictory.
1: PC has higher quality assets than next gen
2: The footage we have seen is PC and not very impressive.
The two way's of looking at it are:
1: The footage shown was equivalent to the next gen version and the PC version will be better.
2: The footage shown was just the PC version and next gen will be uglier.
As we haven't seen the Next gen version yet we have no way to actually tell which is which.
In my opinion, the version shown is the PC version and the console version will be worse, I'm aware they said representative, But they said that for the Battlefield 4 presentation at the Microsoft conference at E3, we know how that turned out...It was just straight up the PC version on max settings, no compromises.