One thing I will agree with Colin on is that MS need to do something about their first party content cos it is
dire.
I can't see Crackdown 3 being a big seller, and Sea of Thieves is a very weird one (people seem to be hot on the Destiny model so I don't want to totally write it off).
On top of that, the previously mentioned lacking support with indies and JP studios compared to the competition.
Look at the enormous turnaround Sony has had since the early PS3 days with it's exclusives. MS need to invest in it's first party material, and stop relying ont he Halo/Gears/Forza trifecta with a couple token efforts on the side.
I think the only reason colin is cool with the scorpio is either the following scenarios:
A) ms is losing the war and desperately wants a do over with a new gen (he stated this)
B) assuming the scorpio will have next gen leap which in turn justifies its existence unlike the marginal pro upgrade.
Either way you can't just ignore the current xb1 userbase.
If either of these scenarios happen then of course, but I think it's a pipe dream, and much like PS4 Pro pre-reveal, I think people are over egging this and going to be disappointed.
They're both upgrade boxes for a reason but people keep treating them as new consoles.
I may well be wrong though.