The OT is being flooded with reviews and it's hard to keep track of. Maybe also discuss the game's reviews here as well. Feel free to add more and I'll update accordingly.
RPGSite - 85
Edge - 9
IGN - 9.0
1UP - A
PCGamer - 94
Gamespy - 4/5
Joystiq - 4.5/5
Eurogamer - 9
Gametrailers - 8.7
Destructoid - 9.5
TheSixthAxis - 9
Videogamer - 9
IncGamers - 10
C&VG - 94
WorthPlaying - 9.7
Strategy Informer - 9.5
Guardian - 4/5
Metro - 5/5
Telegraph - 4/5
Bit Gamer - 90
Ars Technica - BUY
Rock, Paper, Shotgun - Recommended
GamesTM - 8
MTV Multiplayer Blog - BUY
RPG Fan - 90
VE3D - 4.5/5
X360A - 94
Gamersyde - 5/5
Nowgamer: 360 (7.5), PS3 (7.1)
Dealspwn - 9
Gamespot - 8.5
GameBanshee - Recommended
Shacknews - Recommended
Giant Bomb - 4/5
OXM - 8.5
Non-English
Meristation - 9
Vandal - 9.4
Gamestar - 85
PC Games - 84
4Players - 87
RPGSite - 85
Edge - 9
IGN - 9.0
1UP - A
PCGamer - 94
Gamespy - 4/5
Joystiq - 4.5/5
Eurogamer - 9
Gametrailers - 8.7
Destructoid - 9.5
TheSixthAxis - 9
Videogamer - 9
IncGamers - 10
C&VG - 94
WorthPlaying - 9.7
Strategy Informer - 9.5
Guardian - 4/5
Metro - 5/5
Telegraph - 4/5
Bit Gamer - 90
Ars Technica - BUY
Rock, Paper, Shotgun - Recommended
GamesTM - 8
MTV Multiplayer Blog - BUY
RPG Fan - 90
VE3D - 4.5/5
X360A - 94
Gamersyde - 5/5
Nowgamer: 360 (7.5), PS3 (7.1)
Dealspwn - 9
Gamespot - 8.5
GameBanshee - Recommended
Shacknews - Recommended
Giant Bomb - 4/5
OXM - 8.5
Non-English
Meristation - 9
Vandal - 9.4
Gamestar - 85
PC Games - 84
4Players - 87