• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Director Survivor: Ridley Scott (Alien, Blade Runner, Gladiator..etc)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Cheebs said:
Since it is getting close, I need to mention the fact. You MUST state which version of Kingdom of Heaven you are basing your vote on if/when you choose to vote it off. If you don't I will not count it! Since the theatrical and director's cut of the film are totally different films I feel this is necessary.
Click to expand...

So, if the theatrical cut was voted off, the director's cut would remain? Right now, it's between Gladiator and KOH, so further elaboration would be nice. My vote, if I'm reading things right, would be:

Kingdom of Heaven: Theatrical Cut.
 
Wii said:
If you couldn't even be bothered to see KOH, why would it be better than Gladiator?
Click to expand...
Yea, I'm going to have to even out that vote.

Kingdom of Heaven (because I've never bothered to see the DC since the TC was that ****ing bad)
 
Cheebs said:
Since it is getting close, I need to mention the fact. You MUST state which version of Kingdom of Heaven you are basing your vote on if/when you choose to vote it off. If you don't I will not count it! Since the theatrical and director's cut of the film are totally different films I feel this is necessary.
Click to expand...
There's directors cuts for all the remaining films (not too sure about Gladiator)
Why should KOH get special treatment just because the theatrical sucked

Voting off Kingdom of Heaven: Director's Cut (and thus automatically voting off the Theatrical since the DC is vastly superior)
 
Kingdom of Heaven. (And which version, it does not matter, the remaining Scott films are better then both versions. The only thing superior about the Directors cut is more early plot development, but that is countered by more Bloom. Knowing why she exactly shaved her head at the end did not make it a better flick).

Everyone voting off Gladiator before this trash deserves to be both spayed and neutered.
 
Gladiator is gone

8. Thelma & Louise
7. Matchstick Men
6. Legend
5. Black Hawk Down
4. Gladiator

New Round
Alien (1979)
Blade Runner (1982)
Kingdom of Heaven (2005)

Since it is getting close, I need to mention the fact. You MUST state which version of Kingdom of Heaven you are basing your vote on if/when you choose to vote it off. If you don't I will not count it! Since the theatrical and director's cut of the film are totally different films I feel this is necessary.
 
Blade Runner is so overrated, but like I said, it has huge nerd cred so it'd probably win anyway.

Blade Runner should go this round.
 
I am a bit surprised I have to admit, I see a lot more BR votes than Alien the last few rounds. I would think that BR would be a lock to win this.
 
Gladiator and Kingdom of Heaven (which the Director's cut i would really like to see)
 
Kingdom of Heaven. If the final bout is anything other than Alien vs. Blade Runner, GAF confirms its shitty taste yet again.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Ridley Scott says Hollywood is “drowning in mediocrity”
2 3
112
1K
Men_in_Boxes replied
Blade Runner 2099 (2026)... Amazon Prime
2
51
2K
Harkonnen replied
RIP Scott Adams
2
61
1K
negator2vc replied
Alien III - any good?
37
953
m14 replied
Drew Struzan, artist of 150 iconic film posters for Star Wars, Back to the Future, Blade Runner, passes away at 78
43
677
jason10mm replied
Top Bottom