I think it would be even more interesting if the people complaining would read the actual write-ups. Cause you know, context.
To be fair, I wouldn't want to play FFVI or VII today. Chrono Trigger, eh. Even LttP feels dated if it weren't for its immaculate level structure.
give me $20 dollars so I can order it and read it, and I'll get back to you
It would be interesting if the people complaining posted their own lists, though.
Many of us critiquing the list have posted some detailed thoughts at least.It would be interesting if the people complaining posted their own lists, though.
Dark Souls starts out with shit gameplay till you start leveling up also
wind waker the second best zelda game
i don't know man
I can see the argument in that. A lot of the dungeons in LttP aren't really that complicated. Only a few stand out and even then I think LA did it better.LttP's copy-paste boxy dungeons (which our own Viewtiful JC wrote pretty good criticism about a few years ago) have aged a lot worse than the pretty briskly paced Chrono Trigger.
Oh yeah a skill tree that would significantly improve Dark Souls.
LEVEL UP!!! SKILL POINT UNLOCKED!!!
WOULD YOU LIKE A SLIGHT DAMAGE BUFF OR A BIT MORE HEALTH!!!
I always find these kinds of lists ridiculous given how utterly different in genre, scope, and intent its occupants can be.
How can you apply a grade and rank Spec Ops, Fez, Mass Effect 2, Call of Duty, Tetris, Persona, GTA etc when they are all so completely different from one another?
Yes, Yes, I know — "Opinions; how do they work?" but you all know what I mean.
The more I re-read the list and this thread, the more it bugs me. These people are supposed be professionals. It really is a shit list. Like, nonsensical levels of shit.
I'd put it down to Edge being Edge, but then so many people seem to respect them. Just makes you wonder why, I suppose.
I can see the argument in that. A lot of the dungeons in LttP aren't really that complicated. Only a few stand out and even then I think LA did it better.
That actually was one of the most egregious parts of the list to me.WTF SOTN is 63??
The more I re-read the list and this thread, the more it bugs me. These people are supposed be professionals. It really is a shit list. Like, nonsensical levels of shit.
I'd put it down to Edge being Edge, but then so many people seem to respect them. Just makes you wonder why, I suppose.
Journey's 42. Too low but it's there.This list has katamari Damacy, Warioware etc but not even 1 Final Fantasy or Gran turismo... wtf
Not even Journey !
FF12 is on the list.This list has katamari Damacy, Warioware etc but not even 1 Final Fantasy or Gran turismo... wtf
Not even Journey !
You just gave me a glimpse into a terrible alternate reality. Like when Biff got the almanac.
Dark Souls, a most people can't even finish without guides where to go and don't have any story at all if you don't watch youtube videos that explain that weird stuff - Yeah, it must be best game of all time.
Dark Souls, a most people can't even finish without guides where to go and don't have any story at all if you don't watch youtube videos that explain that weird stuff - Yeah, it must be best game of all time.
I love Dark Souls for the gameplay, but it's no where near the best games of all time
The only Halo on the list is Halo 3 on 35... How about the game that invented Matchmaking and made Online Console Multiplayer big: Halo 2?
This whole list is a bad joke. Destiny on 32, what the hell...
....have you played Driveclub lately?What the fuck is DriveClub doing there. That game is garbo. Forza, GT heck even Project Cars is better.
Dark Souls, a most people can't even finish without guides where to go and don't have any story at all if you don't watch youtube videos that explain that weird stuff - Yeah, it must be best game of all time.
I love Dark Souls for the gameplay, but it's no where near the best games of all time