• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

GAF, I'm being catfished, but what for exactly?

Status
Not open for further replies.

scotcheggz

Member
OK, this is the story so far. I'm on a dating website (OkCupid) and last week I received a message from a girl (hurray!) who lived on the other side of the world (boo!). I replied anyway, because she was pretty hot and fuck it, I'm a dude on a dating website, what else am I gonna do, sit around staring with teary eyes and my empty inbox all night?

We got chatty and they were pretty cool, very laid back. They asked me to chat on a messaging app, so I said sure, they gave me their ID and I added them. We didn't text much, but they were pretty forward sending me photos of 'herself' (not flifth), they didn't seem to angle for photos back and I sort of got the vibe they were fishing for compliments a bit, which I didn't really go for. thing is, she actually was hot. I did what any, we could say paranoid, but lets say curious young man would do and reverse image searched them. It turned out that many of them were from a blog of an ex-model, probably not that well known in her country, but you know, more than me in mine. I wasn't hugely shocked, but I was interested as to why they were catfishing me and for what gain. I figured until anything obvious came up, or until my curiosity wanes, I'd just keep playing along and see what happens. I really wasn't doing much else at 4am.

This went on for a few more days, they let out quite a lot of personal info, which most of it I confirmed as true for the model whose pictures they were using via google. This has now been going on for about a week. We only exchange a handful of messages per day and they have yet to reveal any seedy intentions.

Thing is, their inconsistancy bugs me. Some of the info they've told me I can confirm to be true for the model, such as her age, when she stopped modelling, even the age of her dog, I confirmed it all on this models blog in about 2 minutes sitting around at work. But they use an account name on the messaging app of the models professional psuedonym, which is quite weird considering the model quit a couple of years back and presumably dropped the name at the same time. It's sort of bizzare when they seem to nail a lot of the details and not things like this. I mean, I've seen a few sketchy looking profiles in my time, what with tinder and such and they generally tend to aim for the lowest hanging fruit. They're often just about one step up from a nigerian widow wanting to transfer a quadtrillion USD into my bank account and just as subtle with their intentions.

So whats the point GAF? They haven't asked me for any personal details, in fact, I don't think they even know my first name. They made it pretty clear that financially they're very sound. You couldn't even really say they're trolling or fantasising over some weird text-only online relationship, since I'm hardly going in balls deep with my messaging, I'm pretty vacant if I'm honest, just giving them enough conversation to keep the little game going so I can satisfy my own curiosities. Are they trying for the long game? Or are they really just that lonely? I'm pretty chill and if they wanna chat, I kinda wanna explain that they don't have to pretend to be someone they're highly unlikely to be just to get me to do that.

So what if they're not a catfish? Highly doubtful. I 99.9% believe they're full of it. What about the .1%? This theory has a few very weak little nubs going for it, firstly they speak the language from the country they say they're from. I know because I do too and I've thrown it out there already. Their replies didn't seem auto-translated at all and that's usually easy to spot. Secondly, the messaging app tells you their location if they don't hide it and they are where they say they are. Thirdly, a little more interestingly, they sent me a couple of photos from fancy photo shoots which dont reverse image search at all, I found them with magazine text all over them, I found a few scans and promos but nothing with just the straight photos. This just adds to the inconsitency though, it seems at times they've gone to a lot of effort and other times none at all.

Anyone on GAF have any ideas what they're after? At this point it has to be said, I'm hooked. Maybe not in the way they wanted, but I am definitely intrigued by their mindset and motivations. Maybe that's the point? Maybe they just want people to try and figure out the mystery of who they are and what the fuck they want?! I'm totally fine with chatting to weirdos and I'm not afraid of ID theft or financial milking, since I'm not going to fall in for any of that, but am I missing something GAF? Is there any other, slightly more subtle cons that I need to look out for in my adventure for catfish closure?
 
It might be true. I once met a Canadian singer modelling chick on WoW, was able to confirm through uh, reeeesearch that she was who she said she was. She was adorable. But crazy. Wanted me to send her a picture(....she wanted to know if I was handsome.), and then she would always want me to be on talking with her.

She seemed like a loner who wanted attention. And uh....if you want proof that you're not being catfished, ask a specific type of photo that you know she hasn't modeled as.(Maybe she has a hobby, be like 'wow can I see your collection?'.)

Either way roll for it if the only thing that's putting doubt in your mind is the fact that her username doesn't match up.
 
They're probably chatting to heaps of dudes at once, casting a wide net, keeping the boat tugging until someone drops some info they can use.

I used to get messages from these "too good to be true" types all the time, but 99% of the time, the dating website had banned their profile within hours.
 
Maybe a lonely guy who wants to have an e-friend?

If this turns out to be true, which I assume I'll find out in the next week or so, I kinda wanna say "dude, tell me your real name and lets chat". I have a fair bit of time to kill when I'm working so chatting to lonely strangers is fine for me lol.

It might be true. I once met a Canadian singer modelling chick on WoW, was able to confirm through uh, reeeesearch that she was who she said she was. She was adorable. But crazy. Wanted me to send her a picture(....she wanted to know if I was handsome.), and then she would always want me to be on talking with her.

She seemed like a loner who wanted attention. And uh....if you want proof that you're not being catfished, ask a specific type of photo that you know she hasn't modeled as.(Maybe she has a hobby, be like 'wow can I see your collection?'.)

Either way roll for it if the only thing that's putting doubt in your mind is the fact that her username doesn't match up.

Well, that'd be great and all, they'd probably be quite interesting and have an interesting life to chat about, but I dunno, I just can't buy it in this case.

They're probably chatting to heaps of dudes at once, casting a wide net, keeping the boat tugging until someone drops some info they can use.

I used to get messages from these "too good to be true" types all the time, but 99% of the time, the dating website had banned their profile within hours.

probably true and explains why they seem to want to continue to chat when I'm not really turning on the charm and like I said, honestly pretty vacant.
 
I met and befriended a somewhat successful country singer on a random chat website once. We talked over webcam, she went on tour, now she's married. It's not as unlikely as you think.
 
probably true and explains why they seem to want to continue to chat when I'm not really turning on the charm and like I said, honestly pretty vacant.

That's a dead giveaway. If they're throwing out pictures of a hot girl, they'll certainly have no shortage of people to talk to.
 
Sounds to me like you want to believe, but at the same time you don't want to.

Well, I'm not gonna lie, a very tiny part of me thinks it would be cool to chat to someone with their lifestyle. On the other hand, I work with models probably 2-3 times a month so that's not that out there for me aside from the fact that this one had slightly more fame. Also though, I'm not sure what I'd gain when they live so far away, they may just as well be a greasy old dude for all the difference it makes to me. I'm mostly just interested in their motivations.
 
Some people are in it for the long con. Knew a guy I used to work with. Talked to a girl that lived in another state for a year online and phone. Then the stories started. Her identity was stolen and she was stranded can she have money? Her air conditioner broke and she had a kid but no money please help. He wanted to meet her but she never could. Even claimed she got arrested and was in jail (she was innocent) to get out of it. I finally convinced him to drive down there himself and just show up. Girl was living alone in a nice house, had a nice car, and sporting the newest iphone. She was not hurting. Probably had several dudes lined up.
 
Well, I'm not gonna lie, a very tiny part of me thinks it would be cool to chat to someone with their lifestyle. On the other hand, I work with models probably 2-3 times a month so that's not that out there for me aside from the fact that this one had slightly more fame. Also though, I'm not sure what I'd gain when they live so far away, they may just as well be a greasy old dude for all the difference it makes to me. I'm mostly just interested in their motivations.

Yeah, to put it blunt OP this IS the Internet and it's got some weird ass people surfing it.
 

lol well, case in point with my OP really lol.

Ask to her to have a video skype conversation.

Could do, we're really not that chatty but if it went on long enough I could. I might have to start engaging the texts a bit more, which is not something I'm that thrilled about. I'm sort of keeping it at arms length.

Some people are in it for the long con. Knew a guy I used to work with. Talked to a girl that lived in another state for a year online and phone. Then the stories started. Her identity was stolen and she was stranded can she have money? Her air conditioner broke and she had a kid but no money please help. He wanted to meet her but she never could. Even claimed she got arrested and was in jail (she was innocent) to get out of it. I finally convinced him to drive down there himself and just show up. Girl was living alone in a nice house, had a nice car, and sporting the newest iphone. She was not hurting. Probably had several dudes lined up.

Yeh, that's what I thought about with the long term plan, pretty much bang on with that documentary which I think is actually called catfish? I can't really see myself getting that invested though, I think my curiosity will give way to boredom before that happened.

Ask for proof of life -- a picture of her with a shoe on her head.

Man, I remember waking up to the thread on Something Awful years and years ago where I think the shoe on the head thing spawned with dudes getting women on livejasmin to do this. Simultaneously the funniest and most depressing morning read ever.

Anyway, maybe I'll have to gently press the issue before I find out their deal. I hope they don't just bail though. If it is a lonely dude I'd love it if he'd stick around and chat to me a while, tell me why he does it etc. I'm genuinely intrigued.
 
There used to be someone in popgaf that used to catfish here I forgot who but it was weird, dont know why they would do it
 
Some people are in it for the long con. Knew a guy I used to work with. Talked to a girl that lived in another state for a year online and phone. Then the stories started. Her identity was stolen and she was stranded can she have money? Her air conditioner broke and she had a kid but no money please help. He wanted to meet her but she never could. Even claimed she got arrested and was in jail (she was innocent) to get out of it. I finally convinced him to drive down there himself and just show up. Girl was living alone in a nice house, had a nice car, and sporting the newest iphone. She was not hurting. Probably had several dudes lined up.

That dude is a chump.
 
They're probably hoping you'll send gifts or wire them money.
 
lol well, case in point with my OP really lol.

Just saying, if you're looking for people to talk with to kill time/boredom, there are plenty of people here who are up-front about their desire to talk and what they want to talk about, as opposed to someone trying to hook someone in by pretending to be a female on a dating website, who may or may not be after your kidneys.
 
Yeh, that's what I thought about with the long term plan, pretty much bang on with that documentary which I think is actually called catfish? I can't really see myself getting that invested though, I think my curiosity will give way to boredom before that happened.

Exactly. He loved her, he was a lonely guy and any attention was needed attention. It ended up costing him 10k and a broken heart.
 
You could be the guy that went to China, only to get turned down.


tumblr_inline_n8lw2dkPPL1qfp53l.gif


What was the ending to this funny yet sad story. The guy should of locked down 'in love' status before hopping on a plane to china.
 
I remember I once got catfished for no reason. No money, no blackmail, nothing. I don't think it was a bot, and if it was, it was a damn smart one. A skilled catfisher, too, because the photos couldn't be reverse searched, she had accurate basic information and chose an address that wasn't fake to meet up at. I drove around a neighboring city trying to meet up with them, but realized they were fake fairly quickly. To this day I don't know their motivations. The answer probably isn't that intriguing (probably just a teenager trying to feel powetful) and if it is, chances are you don't want to find it out. I'd just drop things with the catfish entirely. Nothing good can come of it.
 
I remember I once got catfished for no reason. No money, no blackmail, nothing. I don't think it was a bot, and if it was, it was a damn smart one. A skilled catfisher, too, because the photos couldn't be reverse searched, she had accurate basic information and chose an address that wasn't fake to meet up at. I drove around a neighboring city trying to meet up with them, but realized they were fake fairly quickly. To this day I don't know their motivations. The answer probably isn't that intriguing (probably just a teenager trying to feel powetful) and if it is, chances are you don't want to find it out. I'd just drop things with the catfish entirely. Nothing good can come of it.

Or he can come out of it with an interesting story
 
I remember I once got catfished for no reason. No money, no blackmail, nothing. I don't think it was a bot, and if it was, it was a damn smart one. A skilled catfisher, too, because the photos couldn't be reverse searched, she had accurate basic information and chose an address that wasn't fake to meet up at. I drove around a neighboring city trying to meet up with them, but realized they were fake fairly quickly. To this day I don't know their motivations. The answer probably isn't that intriguing (probably just a teenager trying to feel powetful) and if it is, chances are you don't want to find it out. I'd just drop things with the catfish entirely. Nothing good can come of it.

Yeh you're probably right. Your post and this post:

Have you even seen catfish?

The point/ scary part is that they want nothing.

Kinda scare me away from rolling with it a bit. There's a certain amount of awareness on my part at the moment which I'm riding to try and see if they reveal any conclusion but maybe I shouldn't bother and just either call them out and force the issue to find out whats their point or just sack it off entirely. Curiosity killed the cat and all that though...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom