• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Ghost In The Shell (2017) Trailer

Status
Not open for further replies.
batou looks terrible and the film looks .... okay techinically but most modern day films with a budget looks good. Not feeling scarlett as the lead. All wrong.

Jup. I'll wait for another anime. Visual style is one thing but I think the writing will be hollywood trash
 
I am pretty optimistic about this, I know Snow White and the Huntsman overall wasn't such a great movie, but I was pretty surprised by how great it looked. Most of the issues came down to the story, and a wooden performance from the Kristen Stewart. This movies already looks gorgeous, and has a pretty good story to draw from, so as long as the actors turn in a good performance I think this will be great.
 
I really liked the trailer aside Batou and Major. I like Scarlet but she just isn't working for me here but although may be more of a problem with the direction for the character.
 
Why in the world is Batou a dwarf. Shoulda gotten Ron Perlman

The Major having a lesbian love interest doesnt sit with me well as I thought she was asexual but if they use it in way of her discovering herself im ok with it

Eh, in the movie she's asexual. In everything else she's bisexual. I think both of them work considering she probably isn't too concerned about sex or gender
 
I have some nitpicks that make me cautious about the film. I'm willing to let this stand as it's own this, but scenes that directly callback to the original don't help to make its case.



But that opening sequence makes me hype. The fact that they're using the original score is even better.
 
Confirmed for having zero knowledge of the Major's original character. Only in the Oshii films is she super stoic.

Isn't that version of Gits this is based on? i mean, i have nothing against Masamune Shirou but i even prefer Arise because of how it also takes more cues from the movie.
 
I was holding out hope for this one based on the mini clips being released, but all hope is lost.

Meh, would rather see Netflux funding more original anime than anime adaptations.
A new season of Knights of Sidonia that rewrites the manga's ending please.
 
Meh, would rather see Netflix funding more original anime than anime adaptations.

No doubt, but Netflix will be paying attention to their data of Death Note views on their platform as well as Ghost In the Shell's box office, and I suspect they're notice the interest and demand will be pretty high for them to continue making these adaptations. I don't think it'll affect their funding original anime as that's much cheaper.

Death Note on Netflix doesn't really seem to be going for any kind of faithful adaptation route.

What does the adaptation being faithful or not, have to do with anime in general being adapted to film?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom