i don't really know if KS holds up by itself without the expectations you have going in, knowing that it was developed by a bunch of randos who lurked /vg/ or whatever, and how it really subverts your expectations. You think it'd be huniepop-tier but actually it's kinda just really good. Wildly inconsistent though.
Mind you, I don't do this with generic Hollywood porn or similar (I rarely watch that stuff to begin with). But we're getting a bit off topic here, so I'll switch subjects..
I watched the PAX Rumble and it was great! Nice that they didn't keep having technical issues, and it was great to see pretty much everyone play a character. We've come a long way since the first ones!
on one hand pubg is worldwide phenomenon and it makes sense to include it in the favoring for goty list with how much time everyone has spent with it
on the other hand i'm not sure how to feel about the precedent of adding early access games to goty... if a game is good but unfinished it should prob still count. but I do like the idea of only evaluating a finished product.. though games are never really 'finished'