jooey said:a Halo Reach truther? really?
I mean this is just something that is bigger than the two of us. I wouldn't expect you to understand.
big ander said:Halsey was told that the next waves of Spartans couldn't happen because of the lack of available candidates and that the funds had been diverted. What if higher-ups just decided to go ahead with using so-so prospects and didn't want to tell her?
That's the only theory I've come up with. If they were Spartan IIIs, wouldn't they have different letters in the call sign? Plus, according to the halo wiki, Reach happened after S-III Alpha and Beta companies died, but before Gamma was trained.
I think there's an opportunity for the new Spartans to be something else, but I don't think they can be Spartan 3s.
I think Bungie has made it sufficiently clear that they won't let a main plot point have any relation to a book outside of the scope of the story. Also, I don't think the writers at Bungie are capable of taking an idea alien to most halo players (spartan III project) and interweaving it with the fall of Reach without fucking it up big time.