I am 100% in agreement with this. I think trained dogs or a dog school would be great. Maybe trained, docile cats for those that don't like dogs, but that would be more difficult. But something more than a piece of paper, and it needs to be restricted to certain animals.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
In other Delta flight news: Dog bites man (on the face)
- Thread starter Earthbound64
- Start date
- Status
I also suggested the school for people that insisted that it has to be specifically the dog they already own. But if their dog fails (barks WAY too much, nips at other dogs/people, won't listen to basic commands, won't settle down, can't deal with crowded places), then no REAL certificate for you!
I wish this was a real thing, but something something money/need charities etc. to fund.
Edit: For cats, maybe retired Hollywood cats? Where else can you find trained cats that seem to be calm, no matter the situation.
Slackbladder
Member
Hmm. The dog is put in a kennel and that's it? What if this had been a child? Is that dog dangerous or not? Dogs can be put down for biting someone in the UK, though maybe if it's regarded as not being dangerous by a vet or dog handler it may not. But still, it could've been far worse and could happen again.
Monocle
Member
There's something soothing about the image of Mr. Nibbles feasting on the marrow of the guy at the supermarket who brings a return to the express lane.and my emotional support snapping turtle.
So because someone somewhere has abused it, let's just eradicate it completely... Sounds exactly like people that believe welfare recipients are just moochers and use food stamps on nothing but avocado toast.
Granted those examples are different because it certainly seems like the abuse is more common with this than with welfare. Regardless, why throw the idea out altogether when maybe the government can implement a system for this and have doctors screen cases better.
The casual mental health dismissal is really bad in this thread.
NinjaBoiX
Member
mercenar1e
Member
i bet when the dog was gnawing on the mans face the owner probably said something along the lines of he/she never knew the dog to anything like that before. i hope the man sues the shit out of the passenger and delta.
My Honey Badger is the most surly violent emotional support animal around. When you need emotional support he goes for your balls and suddenly you don't need emotional support anymore!
Octavianus
Banned
and my emotional support snapping turtle.
I'll be your emotional support snapping turtle if you want
Crossing Eden
Hello, my name is Yves Guillemot, Vivendi S.A.'s Employee of the Month!
Wow it really bothers you what people refer to their pets. Emotional support animals are a thing. Maybe consider the feelings of someone who feels the need to specify that and what they're going through compared to just randomly getting a pet.
RenegadeXV8
Banned
You can legitimately take pets with you on a flight if they're small enough (generally under 10lbs) to fit in a carrier under the seat. You're also never supposed to remove them from the carrier. I did this when I had to move to a different country.
Problem is a lot of people abuse the shit out of pet policies so stuff like this happens, then they have to pile on more restrictions which ends up punishing everyone else. I remember seeing a woman's 2 "emotional support" dogs piss everywhere in an airport and she didn't give a shit.
Problem is a lot of people abuse the shit out of pet policies so stuff like this happens, then they have to pile on more restrictions which ends up punishing everyone else. I remember seeing a woman's 2 "emotional support" dogs piss everywhere in an airport and she didn't give a shit.
Bubba_Sparks
Member
Was about to post the same thing lol!
Mr.Shrugglesã
Banned
This is why they should make pitbulls illegal.
elrechazado
Banned
The emotional support dog scam is bullshit. I don't want your dog on my airplane.
outunderthestars
Banned
This right here.
You need your dog, cat, turkey, miniature pony, whatever? Fine. You should have to buy the entire row of seats. I shouldn't have to sit next to your pet....
$69 is all it takes. Took 5 seconds to find a site, and it looks like it would take maybe two minutes to fill out the order form.
Congress needs to revisit that legislation.
Graphic photos of injury, plus more details and photo of dog here:
http://fourleggedfriendsandenemies.blogspot.com/2017/06/ronald-kevin-mundy-jr-claims-his-dog-is.html
That dog seems a bit big to sit on someone's lap during a 5-6 hour flight. The dog owner had a middle seat and was going to have the animal just sitting there.
cromofo
Member
People with dogs on public transport are the worst.
Especially when they can't control their dogs and they end up sniffing everyone and barking. I was on a ferry ride last week and some woman brought a dog INSIDE the sitting area while she could've easily gone outside in the open area. The dog didn't stop barking for 45 minutes and she just sat there like a dumbass.
Piss off. I wanted to throw them overboard. Not everyone likes dogs/cats and not everyone wants someone else's animals around them.
Especially when they can't control their dogs and they end up sniffing everyone and barking. I was on a ferry ride last week and some woman brought a dog INSIDE the sitting area while she could've easily gone outside in the open area. The dog didn't stop barking for 45 minutes and she just sat there like a dumbass.
Piss off. I wanted to throw them overboard. Not everyone likes dogs/cats and not everyone wants someone else's animals around them.
Emotional support pets? Oh fuck off.
Of course I understand that pets are incredibly important for some people's emotional wellbeing but they've actually given them a tag now? Like they're essential or something?
Let's be honest, if it's not a guide dog you can do without.
There's a hell of a lot more service dogs than guide dogs that may need to be on planes with their handler.
You have mobility assistance dogs both for those who can semi walk on their own and those in wheelchairs or other mobility devices, hearing assistance dogs, seizure alert dog, allergy alert dog, psychiatric service dog ( which covers ptsd for soldiers, first respondents and civilians, autism dogs, etc) etc . Some of these dogs will be trained properly by facilities that have been doing this for years, some of the dogs will be trained properly by their owners with the help of certified dog trainers, some of these dogs will be trained by idiots who may genuinely need them but refuse to wait for a facility dog and can;t afford or won't pay for the dog to be trained by a professional.
An emotional support animal is less than a service animal but more than a pet. Many still do tasks for their handlers ( pick up objects, open doors, alert to certain stimulants , use an emergency phone if handler falls or becomes unconscious) but their handler does not have a recognized disability and therefor the animal cannot be a service animal. Again you will have well trained and poorly trained individuals among those you encounter.
Do not judge every service or emotional support animal you see based on the bad cases and for godsake don't confront someone about it unless their animal is being unruly and even then be polite ( unless you know the animal is trying to eat your face.)
The asshat who took a poorly trained animal onto that plane just made progress for disabled individuals the world over who need a service or support animal that much harder.
Zoe
Member
God damn, just reading all of that pisses me off.
People are going to dismiss the site because of the anti-pit bull angle though.
thesoapster
Member
Only anecdotal, but the few times I've seen emotional support pets, they're clearly not trained service animals. I don't care if it's real or not for the most part (personally I find the concept ridiculous), but if they're going to be granted the same privileges as a motherfucking seeing dog, they should be trained to the same standard!
Zoe
Member
And that's the problem. They shouldn't be granted the same privileges--there is no law that requires it. Companies are doing it as customer service at the expense of their other customers.
lvl99 Pixel
Member
Big dogs make me nervous enough without being stuck in the sky with them
Technosteve
Banned
I think you have Toxoplasmosis
I work in the hotel industry and while I will not say that "there is no such thing as an emotional support animal" I will say that this is a practice that gets abused nearly all of the time. We're actually not allowed to ask for any sort of paperwork or certification verifying whether or not the animal is indeed officially an aid. We also cannot prevent them being brought into most areas where we would normally not allow animals. Obviously, certain animals are off the list but big ass dogs being considered as such is not unusual.
H.Protagonist
[-_-]/
They need to scrap this whole "Emotional Support Animal" thing and just create a new, official sub-section of the Service Animal part in the Disability Act that's regulated, registered, and properly tested (both animals and humans) to weed out all the abusers. There need to be actual standards or stuff like this will keep happening and people will keep exploiting it.
Domcorleone
Member
Look at who the dog bit.
Mammoth Jones
Member
Yup. Very much so.
GoldenEye 007
Member
They're probably doing it in fear of being challenged I assume under ADA in some form. Moreso than for customer service.
I do agree a solution would be required oversight with an actual training requirement and certification. Owner must get the dog from an approved trainer, or take their existing animal for training at an approved facility. If it passes, then certification.
Hickbilly Deluxe
Banned
Clockwork
Member
The dog shouldn't have been on the plane.
Also to certain people:
Stop confusing emotional support dogs with service dogs. I think most if not all the criticism is towards the former. Nobody should be able to self identify their pet as some support animal allowing them to bypass certain restrictions without a real certification process (from both a behavioral and training perspectives). Spending 5 minutes filling out a web form and paying $80 doesn't count.
Also to certain people:
Stop confusing emotional support dogs with service dogs. I think most if not all the criticism is towards the former. Nobody should be able to self identify their pet as some support animal allowing them to bypass certain restrictions without a real certification process (from both a behavioral and training perspectives). Spending 5 minutes filling out a web form and paying $80 doesn't count.
Mr.Shrugglesã
Banned
Just like oversized people should be required to pay for multiple seats, people taking planes with large animals should be required to buy out the whole set of seats.
The dog was not a labrador, lol:
This is common with a lot of bad pit bull owners, they claim their dog is a mixed labrador or somesuch breed to get around city ordinances which is another common problem.
The ADA does not recognize or cover any of these bullshit "emotional support" animals, Delta needs be sued over this incident and boot them all off their flights. Ridiculous this guy was taking a vicious fucking pittbull on his lap on the flight under the guise of a support animal.
emotional support animals are not covered under the ADA. They are not service animals (which must be trained to perform a specific task)
The dog was not a labrador, lol:
This is common with a lot of bad pit bull owners, they claim their dog is a mixed labrador or somesuch breed to get around city ordinances which is another common problem.
The ADA does not recognize or cover any of these bullshit "emotional support" animals, Delta needs be sued over this incident and boot them all off their flights. Ridiculous this guy was taking a vicious fucking pittbull on his lap on the flight under the guise of a support animal.
Without getting into a futile argument about what is and isn't a PitBull (they are the sweetest breed, you know) that Mundy guy needs to go to jail and his dog needs to be removed from him.
GoldenEye 007
Member
I assume they aren't. But I'm thinking a company doesn't want to deal with potentially settling a precedent and going through court proceedings.
Also the optics of "going after" those with ESAs.
- Status