• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Manga Discussion/News Thread |OT5| We Post on Wednesdays

Status
Not open for further replies.
To be fair, it's still quite accurate per the reader-base. I question ColossalLazy, gundamkyoukai, and Tribes of Trusty though. At least one of them is on the wall of shame.

Read allot of stuff i just don't post about it in this thread since it started out more of a shonen topic than anything else.
I remember a time i was talking about wolf guy and someone recommend me a hentai manga i read it but did not post about in this thread .

I know we are free to talk about which manga we read in here but i don't think it's right to talk about certain types .

I now have to read post about incest damn you aunt tits but i still love manga GAF :)
 
Sengoku Youko 41:

Best chapter since the lead protagonist change (of course it focused more on the previous cast). Glad the previous main characters still have a role in the story, even if it is much smaller.
 
Immortal Regis vol 1
189b501c6ac80ac865284133b3a5b0bf33b7c2c8.jpg


This wasn't bad at all. Pleasing to the eye and enough action to draw me in. The death of the dude though reminded me a lot of Highschool DxD (since I saw the anime for that before reading this, I have no idea which came first nor I'm interested in checking). Thanks guys for convincing me to pick it up.

Sing Yesterday For Me vol 3
3e4f04ca2129bd24d945ea31a91a5477ed1c8967.jpg


I liked Takako (Kinoshita's sister) which was introduced in this volume. Getting a job to help fund the club's movie, considering what happened to crow girl Haru in the past and the school's stance on it was a brave decision and it was cool that Shinako, this time, actually helped.
I don't really like Minato, so I keep hoping that Haru will be able to get with Riuko, one day in the future.

Detonation Island vol 10
69a87e06ddd4fb0073309d5485392723bc2a51d7.png


Takashi got the beating he, imo, deserved, though he showed guts. Still what he did after wasn't really smart and even though he might feel he gave back what he received, he looked like a low life and nothing more, in my eyes.
Kumiko is still hanging around the Zeros, and I kind of like her. I wonder if she'll get together with Takashi's sidekick.
The whole trouble with the drunk yakuza dude is blowing up and I hope Shinji (smirk dude from the cover who got dragged into this) will be alright by the time Takashi and gang will go to his rescue.

Say I Love You vol 8
00388439df69b2d5c714a9e6318e1da5ca152bab.png


Loved this volume, what with Mei not turning away from the beauty competition at her school in order to face against Megumi. Seeing the whole thing was worth it and even the conclusion felt realistic in its own way.

Drifters vol 1
42a29b18c90180eb13926d039e79482a5ab5307e.png


I expect awesome stuff from Kohta Hirano, but I admit I wasn't ready for this first volume. Bloody, violent and fucking cool.
Toyohisa is a great protagonist for my standards and I love the other two drifters that are with him. I expect big things from Oda Nobunaga, given what they have done in just 1 volume.
The only disappointing thing is that Jeanne d'Arc is on the enemy's team. I love Jeanne =(

Qwaser of Stigmata vol 12
16072210f26cfd88d3fa0362351f90f9949d0c96.png


Good battles, lots of tits, a couple enraging moments. Basically the usual stuff one would expect from a volume of Qwaser.
Sasha's trick to defeat Nami made him look like a badass (not like it was really needed but hey!), though the end result wasn't exactly as planned.
End of volume is what made me rage a bit... and now to wait for vol 13.

Space Brothers vol 13
4397fe99a4e2f0a61aee62bc0fc73d8eff73a11d.jpg


Mutta's flight training was crazy. As usual, he got the type of weird instructor that only certain people could put up with and thanks to that there were some nice scenes and exchanges.
Seeing the two brothers doing the same things for Sharon was heart warming.
The bicycle scene was hilarious.

Beads Club
6b0341dd61879cfa2fdadde175f342c20a9cdf50.png


As I'd expect from Kyousuke Motomi, this was funny, with silly faces and moments of badassery. The fact it's a single volume also works in its favor, given that the whole love story goes full steam ahead with no waste of time.

Love Button vol 2
ebb00274f9b68553f600c20e2aec1048024ab474.gif


Eito's sadistic side makes the interactions with Nina funny, though the best part of the volume is Nina's sister Aoi, which had me fooled too until Eito blew her cover in front of Nina. Seeing Aoi's embarrassed face was great.

Toraneko Folklore vol 1
0c6ce362c9d8b4d665901d0965c31117a4d1fba3.png


I like this.
Toto is an interesting main character, or rather, a main character I can like. He looks scary and the way he behaves instills fear into the people around him, but he's actually a nice dude who wants to make some friends now that he's got into a new school.
The two people he ends up befriending (not before scaring them shitless on the first day of school) ends up getting him involved in some dangerous fights, as the school he enrolled in seems to have some troubling mysteries.

There are only two fights in the first volume, and the action in them wasn't anything special, but I liked the interaction between the characters and Toto, as I wrote before, is a type of MC I like, so I'm interested in reading volume 2.
 
Qwaser of Stigmata vol 12
http://i.picpar.com/16072210f26cfd88d3fa0362351f90f9949d0c96.png[/ig]

Good battles, lots of tits, a couple enraging moments. Basically the usual stuff one would expect from a volume of Qwaser.
Sasha's trick to defeat Nami made him look like a badass (not like it was really needed but hey!), though the end result wasn't exactly as planned.
End of volume is what made me rage a bit... and now to wait for vol 13.
[/QUOTE]

What chapter did this go up too?
 
A Bride's Story? Do you mean Otoyomegatari? If so, it's really good. It's one of the only very historically accurate mangas I've seen not set in Japan... that kind of accuracy to the setting is outstanding for manga, and almost never happens. And the series is good, too.
No, I mean A Bride's Story or Waifu Story. No unnecessary weaboo (waifu is slang so it's OK). And I said it before, wake me up when it stops being boring.
Read allot of stuff i just don't post about it in this thread since it started out more of a shonen topic than anything else.
+1 smutgaf ;)

In all seriousness, TLRD is my limit and even then I skip some stuff. I'm fine with the seinen stuff like Kono S cause it's manga for adults. But get turned off by some stuff like Monster Girls, which I find gross. So yea, I talk about all the manga I read. I just prefer to talk about the more edgy manga cause that's the fun stuff. Who gives a fuck about what I thought regarding the last shitty chapter of Magico. And as upandaway said, give us some hype shounen.
So you get it
Flawless. We are friends from now until the next time one of us quotes the other.
Say I Love You vol 8
00388439df69b2d5c714a9e6318e1da5ca152bab.png
I'm jealous. So...
did it get smutty or what?
 
Space Brothers vol 13
4397fe99a4e2f0a61aee62bc0fc73d8eff73a11d.jpg


Mutta's flight training was crazy. As usual, he got the type of weird instructor that only certain people could put up with and thanks to that there were some nice scenes and exchanges.
Seeing the two brothers doing the same things for Sharon was heart warming.
The bicycle scene was hilarious.

Why is this not in english? ;_;
 
Space Brothers vol 13
4397fe99a4e2f0a61aee62bc0fc73d8eff73a11d.jpg


Mutta's flight training was crazy. As usual, he got the type of weird instructor that only certain people could put up with and thanks to that there were some nice scenes and exchanges.
Seeing the two brothers doing the same things for Sharon was heart warming.
The bicycle scene was hilarious.

If you are following the anime, do you know how many volumes they covered so far?

In all seriousness, TLRD is my limit and even then I skip some stuff. I'm fine with the seinen stuff like Kono S cause it's manga for adults. But get turned off by some stuff like Monster Girls, which I find gross. So yea, I talk about all the manga I read. I just prefer to talk about the more edgy manga cause that's the fun stuff. Who gives a fuck about what I thought regarding the last shitty chapter of Magico. And as upandaway said, give us some hype shounen.
Kono S is more creepy than Monster Girls
 
Since i don't give a shit about aunt tits or tlrd anymore, ill try out smutgaf flavor of the week

nisekoi chapter 1
Qk0Hm.png

idk if i can do this if they give me this shit so early on.
 
mqQ6L.png

lol, mangaka tried to do that naruto thing when the leaves blow around everywhere during a dramatic moment, but the difference here is that this looks likr shit man.
 
Jesus, Mysticwhip. I never realized how hardcore of a Naruto fan you were.
i dont even watch the anime, but you never really noticed me man. we had our slam dunk/vagabond moments, but that.....was so long ago.

nisekoi
this isn't really smut,more like a romcom sitcom, but there's a question i need answered before i continue, is there actual progression in this manga or is it like tlrd or aunt tits where pretty much every arc/chapter is the same shit?
 
People think Nisekoi is smut? I always thought it was just another generic rom-com. Yeah, there's some fan service, but it isn't in-your-face like it is in Aunt Tits or Prison School or Kono S.
 
yea it isn't, jut a regular sitcom manga. so far, the best thing about it are the yakuza guys trying to get the two main characters close, but so far nothing really interesting. I think I'll stop here.
 
I guess my brain just subconsciously ignores most Naruto posts.

First official recommendation as a SmutGAF member:

Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai

I've been informed this counts as smut so here you go. Seriously speaking, this is a pretty hilarious comic and if you enjoy Slice-of-life stuff then check it out.

I'm not good at this
 
I guess my brain just subconsciously ignores most Naruto posts.

First official recommendation as a SmutGAF member:

Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai

I've been informed this counts as smut so here you go. Seriously speaking, this is a pretty hilarious comic and if you enjoy Slice-of-life stuff then check it out.

I'm not good at this

Old, man. :( We've gone through multiple spinoffs and an anime already!
 
Say I Love You vol 8
00388439df69b2d5c714a9e6318e1da5ca152bab.png


Loved this volume, what with Mei not turning away from the beauty competition at her school in order to face against Megumi. Seeing the whole thing was worth it and even the conclusion felt realistic in its own way.
It's been so long since I read this =( /jelly
Beads Club
6b0341dd61879cfa2fdadde175f342c20a9cdf50.png


As I'd expect from Kyousuke Motomi, this was funny, with silly faces and moments of badassery. The fact it's a single volume also works in its favor, given that the whole love story goes full steam ahead with no waste of time.

Toraneko Folklore vol 1
0c6ce362c9d8b4d665901d0965c31117a4d1fba3.png


I like this.
Toto is an interesting main character, or rather, a main character I can like. He looks scary and the way he behaves instills fear into the people around him, but he's actually a nice dude who wants to make some friends now that he's got into a new school.
The two people he ends up befriending (not before scaring them shitless on the first day of school) ends up getting him involved in some dangerous fights, as the school he enrolled in seems to have some troubling mysteries.

There are only two fights in the first volume, and the action in them wasn't anything special, but I liked the interaction between the characters and Toto, as I wrote before, is a type of MC I like, so I'm interested in reading volume 2.
Hmm Same mangaka as Dengeki Daisy. Will check it out. Toraneko also looks interesting.
Some of the new volume covers in the OP need to be updated:
Dat Magi cover, I suppose I should get started some time.
I guess my brain just subconsciously ignores most Naruto posts.

First official recommendation as a SmutGAF member:

Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai

I've been informed this counts as smut so here you go. Seriously speaking, this is a pretty hilarious comic and if you enjoy Slice-of-life stuff then check it out.

I'm not good at this
The H-game was amazing.
 
Smutgaf is actually pretty tame considering the sort of manga that is produced. I'd rank your stuff as pg13 to soft R.



I'm going to attempt and read Seven Ages of Shakespeare by Harold Sakuishi again. Maybe I can ignore the bad translations. I just skimmed a newer chapter and it seems fine.
 
@Nisekoi - Yeah, it's not smut at all ... just something a lot of us read. Because adorable reaction faces etc.

And because we hate ourselves I guess. Depends on who you ask on how Nisekoi is!
 
I can't get it out of my head that Nisekoi is only popular due to Double Arts and its regular scanlations. Haganai is pretty popular too but isn't discussed for the opposite reason. The slow and irregular scanlation schedule.


Smutgaf should read G-Maru Edition. Theres only about a volume out but its pretty funny and from the Ichigo %100 mangaka.
 
I can't get it out of my head that Nisekoi is only popular due to Double Arts and its regular scanlations. Haganai is pretty popular too but isn't discussed for the opposite reason. The slow and irregular scanlation schedule.


Smutgaf should read G-Maru Edition. Theres only about a volume out but its pretty funny and from the Ichigo %100 mangaka.

G-Maru Edition is alright I would say. I love Kawashita's art, and I appreciate her ecchiness, but she should really team up with a writer. A well written romcom with her art would be the bomb right now.
 
The spoilers seem to be confirmed.

How can Madara lose at this point? He's in complete control of his own immortal body now.

Power of 5 kage friendship

Seriously though, it doesn't make any sense that Madara knows how to use Edo Tensei. I'm still laughing about the fact that Madara is powerful enough to own all 5 kages at once but lost to that guy that got owned by Hiruzen while fighting him with both his brother and Orochimaru at the same time.
 
Magico has been canceled. This week is the last chapter.

Other series in the bottom five for this week:
Pajama na Kanojo
Beelzebub
Bleach
Kurogane
 
Naruto spoilers are just what i was expecting with Madara being broken .
OP spoilers also out the person that knock out Law is a new character plus other stuff.
 
Power of 5 kage friendship

Seriously though, it doesn't make any sense that Madara knows how to use Edo Tensei. I'm still laughing about the fact that Madara is powerful enough to own all 5 kages at once but lost to that guy that got owned by Hiruzen while fighting him with both his brother and Orochimaru at the same time.
because kishi only just decided to make him powerful when he introduced madara.
 
Also remember, this is just the bottom five for one week. Bleach is normally hanging out around the 10th place mark, with Beelzebub around the 7th.
 
Naruto

"(Not much new information in this summary, except based on T's summary apparently Madara didn't Edo Tensei himself, but rather canceled his summoning contract with Kabuto, giving himself free reign over his body.)

Itachi disappears. Sasuke sees him off. The Edo Tensei shinobi disappear one after the other Dan is able to move his body of his own will now, so he dissipates Chouza's barrier and uses his Reikano Jutsu to go to Tsunade.

Madara attacks the Kage before disappearing. Tsunade takes damage and her Byakugou no Jutsu wears off. At the same time, Madara's soul leaves his body so Tsunade believes they won, but Madara's soul returns to his body and he attacks with Susano-o. Dan arrives in time to control Tsunade and saves her in the nick of time. The two are reunited. Dan kisses her on the forehead and says "I was able to save you in the end... I guess being brought back by Edo Tensei isn't all bad..." and disappears. Tsunade gets some chakra from him(not sure about this) and her vitality is restored.

Madara's soul returns because as long as he knows the seals for Edo Tensei, the dead person who was revived can cancel the contract. In other words, he can move in an undying body with infinite chakra with no restraints."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom