-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Mario Maker Rumor Discussion Thread
- Thread starter Nirolak
- Start date
mohsinkhan
Member
Kinda cool, maybe we get it for 3DS aswell?
Meh. I always thought the best levels in LittleBigPlanet were the developer-made ones that came with the game. Even the absolutely most highly rated levels here on Gaf weren't as good, I thought. (Although I didn't play all of them.)
Something like this is less about the power and depth of the tools than it is about the social network and discovery system behind it, which is not an area that I give Nintendo a lot of trust in.
Something like this is less about the power and depth of the tools than it is about the social network and discovery system behind it, which is not an area that I give Nintendo a lot of trust in.
Yeah super dissapointing tbh
Wow.
devious.one
Member
Working title maybe? Seems like they could have got a little more creative with that.
I can't really think of many games that could fill a 90 minute discussion. One with lots of customization could be one of them.
PhoenixDawn
Member
I doubt it's their "bomb" if they're being so loose about setting up posters of it 5 days before their show actually starts. It's more likely another ~$15 downloadable title that will be available right after the show similar to NES Remix.
HawthorneKitty
Sgt. 2nd Class in the Creep Battalion, Waifu Wars
I hope these credible sources are fucking with us; not fond of e3 leaking.
Freezie KO
Banned
Nintendo is seriously this out of ideas? They can't even be bothered to rehash their own games. We have to do it for them?
SporeCrawler
Member
sounds like a plausible scenario
Sorcerer Supreme
Member
This would've been incredible in 3D Worlds. I don't want to play user generated levels from Super Mario Bros.
It's Nintendo, they've had what, one remotely good E3 conference in the last 5-6 years? Never expect anything out of them.
OmegaSmash
Member
I agree. Imagine a 3D World stage maker DLC, with options for main stages and Captain Toad stages.
PensivePen
Member
This E3 is leakier than something that leaks a lot.
I don't see this being a 3DS game so I doubt it. I'm honestly expecting the 3DS conferences to be Majora's Mask 3D.
SatoAilDarko
Member
Kind of crazy but a 2D Mario editor was something I thought could be announced as a way to get a yearly holiday Mario title while being unique to NSMB and 3D World.
This is the first time any of my wild ideas have be close to right (I thought you would get to draw sprites too). Maybe wild dreams can come true. Wow.
This is the first time any of my wild ideas have be close to right (I thought you would get to draw sprites too). Maybe wild dreams can come true. Wow.
Did you really expect otherwise?
Bel_Air_Jeff
Banned
it's a great idea. I still think it might be fake..
"We heard you wanted some new games. Please understand, we are very busy working on our QoL project. In the mean time, here is a level editor to make your own games! You can share them with your friends via punch cards that you can fax to each other."
I love you, Nintendo. That's why I tease.
Hey Freezie, dw we know you love Nintendo despite all your posts that say otherwise
90 minutes to discuss a remake, doubtful.
As for a Mario Maker could be great but if it's restricted to NES era gameplay I probably wouldn't bother because there isn't much variety there.
Wow, what? They're right.
Hot Coldman
Banned
this reeks of eshop
there's no way this'll be the 90 minute secret 3DS game
there's no way this'll be the 90 minute secret 3DS game
Spieler Eins
Member
sixteen-bit
Member
little big planet clone?
Freezie KO
Banned
I do love them. I hate their current direction.
vagabondarts
Member
Waitaminute... Did this break on GAF!?!
Woffls
Member
Uhhhh huh :/
This will not be a significant reveal for Nintendo. It will get get a few minutes of talk in the 3DS section, and some streaming for the Treehouse thing later.
Could be interesting. I remember I had a Mario clone on my calculator in school and a separate level creator app which we used to make levels in. Very fun.
Don't know why I bring that up when I could also talk about SMW romhacks. Some seriously amazing ones out there. If they could provide something similar to Lunar Magic, that would be incredible.
LOL you got it buddy.
Don't know why I bring that up when I could also talk about SMW romhacks. Some seriously amazing ones out there. If they could provide something similar to Lunar Magic, that would be incredible.
LOL you got it buddy.
Stumpokapow
listen to the mad man
My evaluation of the rumour:
+ It's totally plausible that something like this could leak from the E3 show floor
+ The would-be source of the photo isn't someone claiming to have secret insider info, they're someone claiming to have seen something they weren't supposed to have yet.
+ The banner, name, and concept do not seem like the typical kind of invented fan nonsense; it's not Zelda: Curse of the Crushed Bone Skull Warrior or whatever.
+ The idea easily interacts with NFC, and fits well with the idea that Nintendo is having a roundtable about a game they're announcing
+ It sort of follows up the NES Remix and I guess reflects a kind of direction Nintendo's been poking at recently
+ McWhertor is presumably saying he has confidence because he knows this is in fact real, but it's not clear how he knows, because if it was from some sort of long-lead pre-E3 event, he'd presumably be NDA'd and commenting on this would probably not be ideal
- It is clear to me that the original site just ran whatever got sent to them, and did absolutely no due diligence in checking the source or asking for followup
- The photo is low quality as hell, which is a classic hallmark of fake stuff
- The other banner images, eg Pikachu, look a bit like stock art and not as much like banner art.
Yes, New Super Mario Bros Wii. Someone posted photos of Nintendo's section of E3, all under thick drapes, but the shape of the shadows visible under the drapes was unmistakable and people (I'm pretty sure our very own Crushed/EmCeeGramr) identified it.
+ It's totally plausible that something like this could leak from the E3 show floor
+ The would-be source of the photo isn't someone claiming to have secret insider info, they're someone claiming to have seen something they weren't supposed to have yet.
+ The banner, name, and concept do not seem like the typical kind of invented fan nonsense; it's not Zelda: Curse of the Crushed Bone Skull Warrior or whatever.
+ The idea easily interacts with NFC, and fits well with the idea that Nintendo is having a roundtable about a game they're announcing
+ It sort of follows up the NES Remix and I guess reflects a kind of direction Nintendo's been poking at recently
+ McWhertor is presumably saying he has confidence because he knows this is in fact real, but it's not clear how he knows, because if it was from some sort of long-lead pre-E3 event, he'd presumably be NDA'd and commenting on this would probably not be ideal
- It is clear to me that the original site just ran whatever got sent to them, and did absolutely no due diligence in checking the source or asking for followup
- The photo is low quality as hell, which is a classic hallmark of fake stuff
- The other banner images, eg Pikachu, look a bit like stock art and not as much like banner art.
Yes, New Super Mario Bros Wii. Someone posted photos of Nintendo's section of E3, all under thick drapes, but the shape of the shadows visible under the drapes was unmistakable and people (I'm pretty sure our very own Crushed/EmCeeGramr) identified it.
TheFLYINGManga_Ka
Member
It's cool if it's a Mario editor. I hope they include 16bit sprite sets as well.
Dead Prince
Banned
mario vs dk?
Not everyone who disagrees with your opinions are trolls. A lot of people would probably agree 2010 was Nintendo's only good conference of the 2010s.
That said, I doubt this is anything big. Probably just a NES Remix type title. A shame that it's not a 3D stage builder, because there's not many of those and there's already a lot of 2D stage builders.
There's a sign above it that's very clearly the Smash logo. Not saying those titles won't be there, but probably not in this section of the booths.
spyroflame0487
Member
I think the real news here is that we see Villager, Pikachu and Kirby on the larger signs. Obviously they're labeled with the Smash logos but...well.. I think we're due for a Animal Crossing on the Wii U, A Pokemon game on the Wii U and a Kirby game on the Wii U.