• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Metal Gear Solid V Has The Most Needless Sexualization Since Bayonetta (Spoilers)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Raiden, a character who was designed to appeal to females, running around naked is not a form of the camera lingering on sexual attributes? They even do sight gags where something gets in the way of Raiden's junk at the perfect time (which ends up drawing your eyes right to that area)

I think you said it all when you pointed out that it was done for a gag. Also I'd keep in mind Kojima's reaction to the fan response to Raiden was to put a gay character in MGS3 who looked exactly like him that you strip and trap in a locker.
 

Sephzilla

Member
I think you said it all when you pointed out that it was done for a gag. Also I'd keep in mind Kojima's reaction to the fan response to Raiden was to put a gay character in MGS3 who looked exactly like him that you strip and trap in a locker.

Just because there's a sight gag doesn't meant it isn't sexualized though
 

Crossing Eden

Hello, my name is Yves Guillemot, Vivendi S.A.'s Employee of the Month!
I agree with the basis of this comment, but I think you're confusing sexism and sexualization in this comment.
It's sexism because the main reason why her scenes are so "unique" in the way they're framed is because she's a woman. The outfit is sexualization, the way she's treated in a multitude of scenes is sexism.

How can you say that when MGSV was the first Fox Engine game? we haven't even seen a true next-gen game yet.

You think MGSV was all the Fox engine is capable off? think again.
Because a)UE4 and Cry engine exist and most likely have way better documentation for 3rd parties and b)Japanese companies rarely license their engines out. I also never implied that MGSV is the pinnacle of Fox Engine, in fact iirc i've implied the opposite in other threads by expressing that I wish the game wasn't crossgen.
 

IcyEyes

Member
3ZZ4

This is pretty gross ...

I saw just a couple of minutes ago the rain scene with Quiet and it was pretty nice to be honest.
The real issue with this game is the camera (as far as I seen) ... They really didn't manage to use a proper shaky camera. Of course it's not a dealbreaker.
 

Theecliff

Banned
I'm just laughing at people getting so offended by it in the first place. It's a video game. Directed by Hideo Kojima. What do you expect? He's well known for his pervy style by now, surely?
because people wish for less of this stupid shit in a piece of media that they personally enjoy?
 

Sephzilla

Member
It's sexism because the main reason why her scenes are so "unique" in the way they're framed is because she's a woman. The outfit is sexualization, the way she's treated in a multitude of scenes is sexism.

I was specifically talking about your comment regarding the torture sequence (sorry, i didn't make that more clear that's my bad)

In what world is partially nude sight gags the same as sexualized torture porn?

I at no point said they were the same and have already stated that the Raiden stuff isn't as bad as the Quiet stuff.
 
It's as if you guys are so keen to be outraged that you're not seeing that I'm actually agreeing quite heavily with what you're trying to say about Quiet's visual presentation. My p.o.v however, is that I don't see her as just an object of sexual desire. But whatever, repeating myself is a waste of time. Proceed.

I mean, I don't necessarily disagree with you, I just couldn't pass that up :p

I guess, related to your post, for me, all of this fanservice, sexism, objectifications, etc. actually does harm her character for me, because it's so forced. Like, it's hard to take her character seriously when she's literally presenting herself for Snake, posing, erotically moaning/giggling, etc.

In film criticism, a fairly common adage is "I can see the strings". Something comes off as so forced, so contrived, that it takes you out of the experience.

When I see Quiet, I don't see an interesting, complicated character (at least, consistently). I see Kojima rubbing his chin and typing acceptance notes after his team demoed an area to him, like "move the cattle prod right above her breasts and make sure we zoom in there" "when Quiet turns around in the chopper, make sure she pauses so we get a good view" "whenever possible, introduce a female character by sexy bodypart first".
 

Morrigan Stark

Arrogant Smirk
Raiden, a character who was designed to appeal to females, running around naked is not a form of the camera lingering on sexual attributes? They even do sight gags where something gets in the way of Raiden's junk at the perfect time (which ends up drawing your eyes right to that area)
Gags. Exactly. It's played for humour, not titillation. Never heard of anyone say "that's so hot". Maybe some did (some people will find anything arousing really), but the intent was still humour, not objectification.

And even if we agreed on Raiden, that's one guy. Compared to how almost every female character in MGS gets sexualized and objectified to absurd degrees, it's not exactly equivalent at all.

In what world is partially nude sight gags the same as sexualized torture porn?
In the world of Mental Gymnastics (tm), I'd say.
 

Galang

Banned
As said already Bayonetta was supposed to be sexualized and there was nothing wrong with it. It's not something you should have played if it bothered you
 
Yes because women literally burn up and start smoking when they touch salt water. And there's literally no way else to convey that her skin was burning than by zooming in her on breasts more than anything else. And yes, a man pissing himself is most definitely for titilation and not comedy. Mr.Kojima-San was definitely not thinking of sexualizing Quiet in anyway shape or form in those scenes, her breasts being the most prominent thing in the frame of her torture scenes was definitely innocent in context. Yep, no sexism here. In fact, the opposite is true.
3ZZ4


Jesus christ the willful ignorance, do you know how long animation takes and how many iterations a scene can go through, it's so ridiculous to argue that this shit isn't on purpose.
The only time in those gifs that her breasts are zoomed in on are when her chest his being shocked (which makes sense), during the water torture her breasts are either at the bottom or top of the frame most of the time.
Quiet is absolutely a sexualized character, but I don't think they tried to push any sex appeal during her torture, I think people see that is only a side effect of her outfit.
 
It's sexism because the main reason why her scenes are so "unique" in the way they're framed is because she's a woman. The outfit is sexualization, the way she's treated in a multitude of scenes is sexism.

Full Definition of SEXISM

1
: prejudice or discrimination based on sex; especially : discrimination against women
2
: behavior, conditions, or attitudes that foster stereotypes of social roles based on sex

Is that the case ever here? "We hate her because she is a woman?" Nope they hate her because shes a sniper that killed alot of people. "We hate her because we want to have sex with her?" Once again no, they want to torture her for killing all the men.

Reading too far into things sometimes doesnt help

Edit: it is fair to be offended. I am not knocking you on that. that is your own personal opinion. My issue is you basically trying to make it a fact this is what it really was and no other way to interpret it, while shooting objective facts from the game down.
 

Karkador

Banned
Gags. Exactly. It's played for humour, not titillation. Never heard of anyone say "that's so hot". Maybe some did (some people will find anything arousing really), but the intent was still humour, not objectification.

And even if we agree on Raiden, that's one guy. Compared to how almost every female character in MGS gets sexualized and objectified to absurd degrees, it's not exactly equivalent at all.

The scrubby ass kid who couldn't possibly fill Solid Snake's shoes and is basically there to troll the fans is definitely the sexual fantasy everyone was waiting for
 

Sephzilla

Member
Gags. Exactly. It's played for humour, not titillation. Never heard of anyone say "that's so hot". Maybe some did (some people will find anything arousing really), but the intent was still humour, not objectification.

And even if we agreed on Raiden, that's one guy. Compared to how almost every female character in MGS gets sexualized and objectified to absurd degrees, it's not exactly equivalent at all.

Why can't it be both?

(To further drive this home - I don't think the MGS2 naked Raiden stuff is as bad as the Quiet stuff in MGSV. I just wanted to point out that there has been some male sexualization in the series as well. It's just not on the same level as what the female characters get)
 
Full Definition of SEXISM



Is that the case ever here? "We hate her because she is a woman?" Nope they hate her because shes a sniper that killed alot of people. "We hate her because we want to have sex with her?" Once again no, they want to torture her for killing all the men.

Reading too far into things sometimes doesnt help

Generally, I can't stand using dictionary definitions as rebuttal, especially in something as complex as sexism/misogyny. However, this

prejudice or discrimination based on sex

certainly is true in this context. Quiet, and some of the other women in the game, are treated/animated/looked at differently (by the camera) solely because Kojima wants to maximize their sex appeal.
 

Fredrik

Member
I've only played a few missions, hadn't seen Quiet in the game until now, and I usually don't care about this sort of stuff but wow those videos with the posing and shower was just too much. This is not acceptable in my opinion. It's not the lack of clothes that is the problem, it's the camera work and poses. Honestly not sure if I want to use her as a companion now. Makes an otherwise serious game look incredibly juvenile and quite ridiculous really.
 

Mesoian

Member
The scrubby ass kid who couldn't possibly fill Solid Snake's shoes and is basically there to troll the fans is definitely the sexual fantasy everyone was waiting for

On a purely design basis, it is. Raiden is one of the better sexualized male designs in video games. They just...don't use it that way at all because that's not what their demographic wants.

I've only played a few missions, hadn't seen Quiet in the game until now, and I usually don't care about this sort of stuff but wow those videos with the posing and shower was just too much. This is not acceptable in my opinion. It's not the lack of clothes that is the problem, it's the camera work and poses. Honestly not sure if I want to use her as a companion now. Makes an otherwise serious game look incredibly juvenile and quite ridiculous really.

You will. You will suck it up even if you don't like it. Quiet is, by far, the best companion.
 

Morrigan Stark

Arrogant Smirk
The scrubby ass kid who couldn't possibly fill Solid Snake's shoes and is basically there to troll the fans is definitely the sexual fantasy everyone was waiting for
Definitely, and there totally wasn't a backlash from the fanbase who totally didn't hate him and everything about him. Just like the sexualized male outfit from FF Mevius was accepted with open arms as the gender-equalizing thing that it was and oh wait
 
I mean, I don't necessarily disagree with you, I just couldn't pass that up :p

I guess, related to your post, for me, all of this fanservice, sexism, objectifications, etc. actually does harm her character for me, because it's so forced. Like, it's hard to take her character seriously when she's literally presenting herself for Snake, posing, erotically moaning/giggling, etc.

In film criticism, a fairly common adage is "I can see the strings". Something comes off as so forced, so contrived, that it takes you out of the experience.

When I see Quiet, I don't see an interesting, complicated character (at least, consistently). I see Kojima rubbing his chin and typing acceptance notes after his team demoed an area to him, like "move the cattle prod right above her breasts and make sure we zoom in there" "when Quiet turns around in the chopper, make sure she pauses so we get a good view" "whenever possible, introduce a female character by sexy bodypart first".

See those idle animations in the game are what I have a real problem with. I can tolerate everything else but the first time I noticed those, I couldn't help but roll my eyes. Of course, it undermines her character in quite a big way, but the saving grace for me is that she is a fighter, and she's not just locked up in a castle waiting for me to save her after beating the final boss.

But yes, the problem is the inconsistent of her character. No doubt.
 

Phocks

Member
See those idle animations in the game are what I have a real problem with. I can tolerate everything else but the first time I noticed those, I couldn't help but roll my eyes. Of course, it undermines her character in quite a big way, but the saving grace for me is that she is a fighter, and she's not just locked up in a castle waiting for me to save her after beating the final boss.

But yes, the problem is the inconsistent of her character. No doubt.
I thought the animations were strange at first until I realized she has feelings for Snake, so in a way it makes sense.
 
See those idle animations in the game are what I have a real problem with. I can tolerate everything else but the first time I noticed those, I couldn't help but roll my eyes. Of course, it undermines her character in quite a big way, but the saving grace for me is that she is a fighter, and she's not just locked up in a castle waiting for me to save her after beating the final boss.

But yes, the problem is the inconsistent of her character. No doubt.
she's just locked up in a cage waiting for your beck and call instead
 

Karkador

Banned
On a purely design basis, it is. Raiden is one of the better sexualized male designs in video games. They just...don't use it that way at all because that's not what their demographic wants.

Shinkawa and the modeling team are actually very good at capturing and abstracting anatomy, and I'd wager that they have probably designed people of different genders and body types who have been intentionally or unintentionally arousing

But that's just the art team, and with that said, I don't think they really had a say in how jokey and not-sexy Raiden's characterization or eventual nudity would be.
 
she's just locked up in a cage waiting for your beck and call instead
Except she's not locked up, she can and does leave the cage whenever she wants, she only plays along because she wants to be a part of what's going on. The only reason she was put in the cage to begin with was her connection to Cypher, it had nothing to do with her being a woman.
 

Fredrik

Member
You will. You will suck it up even if you don't like it. Quiet is, by far, the best companion.
Playing a game on easy is no fun though, I'll just have to think I'm playing on a harder difficulty and using her is like cheating. Might make it easier to motivate me into ignoring her. :p
 

ShutterMunster

Junior Member
It's awful. Kojima has always been awful in this regard. I haven't played Bayonetta so I cannot comment on that game, but Quiet's design is an abomination.
 

Crossing Eden

Hello, my name is Yves Guillemot, Vivendi S.A.'s Employee of the Month!
I'm just laughing at people getting so offended by it in the first place. It's a video game. Directed by Hideo Kojima. What do you expect? He's well known for his pervy style by now, surely?
None of those are valid excuses.

The only time in those gifs that her breasts are zoomed in on are when her chest his being shocked (which makes sense), during the water torture her breasts are either at the bottom or top of the frame most of the time.
Quiet is absolutely a sexualized character, but I don't think they tried to push any sex appeal during her torture, I think people see that is only a side effect of her outfit.
That's not what happens and you know it.

Full Definition of SEXISM



Is that the case ever here? "We hate her because she is a woman?" Nope they hate her because shes a sniper that killed alot of people. "We hate her because we want to have sex with her?" Once again no, they want to torture her for killing all the men.

Reading too far into things sometimes doesnt help

Edit: it is fair to be offended. I am not knocking you on that. that is your own personal opinion. My issue is you basically trying to make it a fact this is what it really was and no other way to interpret it, while shooting objective facts from the game down.
Framing the camera a specific way because she's a woman is sexism. It's a form of prejudice. Sexism doesn't have to be full blown hate but I think
hope
you already know that.

I eagerly await your bad attempts to spin these and claim i'm reading far too into things.
Sjc6NrE.gif

72h96uP.gif

The trigger for the second gif is staring at her breasts for a certain amount of time, but ofc no no we're just fucking crazy and reading too into it ofc.
speaking of, that's another thing that gets said in these threads.
 
Framing the camera a specific way because she's a woman is sexism. It's a form of prejudice. Sexism doesn't have to be full blown hate but I think
hope
you already know that.
Sjc6NrE.gif


I eagerly await your bad attempts to spin these and claim i'm reading far too into things.
Sjc6NrE.gif

72h96uP.gif


speaking of, that's another thing that gets said in these threads.
My post was solely about the torture scene.
 

MMarston

Was getting caught part of your plan?
I thought the animations were strange at first until I realized she has feelings for Snake, so in a way it makes sense.

They're still hit or miss though. Like there are times where gets up from her chair on the chopper and simply stares affectionately at Snake or a slight nod of approval, which is fine. Adds some nice detail to the character's emotions.


...And then she starts stretching and mooning her butt at me, and turns the moment into being unintentionally hilarious.
 
Full Definition of SEXISM



Is that the case ever here? "We hate her because she is a woman?" Nope they hate her because shes a sniper that killed alot of people. "We hate her because we want to have sex with her?" Once again no, they want to torture her for killing all the men.

Reading too far into things sometimes doesnt help
Doesn't have to be cut and dry hate. Using the camera and poses to constantly remind the player that the woman in a bikini has ass and tits to me is a form of sexism.
 

Sephzilla

Member
Framing the camera a specific way because she's a woman is sexism. It's a form of prejudice. Sexism doesn't have to be full blown hate but I think
hope
you already know that.

I think that's more sexualization than sexism. Framing a camera angle in a way that shows off someone's sexual assets is not inherently a bad thing nor discriminatory. Portraying her as someone who's beneath her male counterparts simply because she is a woman, for example, is sexism.
 

Phocks

Member
They're still hit or miss though. Like there are times where gets up from her chair on the chopper and simply stares affectionately at Snake or a slight nod of approval, which is fine. Adds some nice detail to the character's emotions.


...And then she starts stretching and mooning her butt at me, and turns the moment into being unintentionally hilarious.
Yeah leaving the menu on when I had her as my buddy made me worried people would get the wrong idea when they passed my room...
 
Just because there's a sight gag doesn't meant it isn't sexualized though

Right, but compare it to how female characters are sexualised in the series.

Raiden: "Hey let's make gags around one small section where he's nude!"

All the the woman in the series: "Let's have every camera focus on tits/asses whenever they appear in a cut-scene and come up with reasons for them to show as much skin as possible throughout the game!"

For all of the people claiming "Sexualisation isn't sexism!" I think it's pretty telling that the one clear example of that is male.
 

Crossing Eden

Hello, my name is Yves Guillemot, Vivendi S.A.'s Employee of the Month!
My post was solely about the torture scene.
I'm aware. I'm saying that's not what happens in those scenes, her breasts are almost always visible while she's getting tortured, especially when they pour water on her. It's so exploitive and unnecessary.

I think that's more sexualization than sexism. Framing a camera angle in a way that shows off someone's sexual assets is not inherently a bad thing nor discriminatory. Portraying her as someone who's beneath her male counterparts simply because she is a woman, for example, is sexism.
To me it's sexism because the thought process behind the framing was likely a combination of "this should look sexy" and "do this specifically because she's a woman." When I see the Huey torture scene, I cringe because it actually looks painful, but I have a keen feeling that it's be very framed quite differently if say Strangelove was getting tortured for the same reason.
 

Sephzilla

Member
Right, but compare it to how female characters are sexualised in the series.

Raiden: "Hey let's make gags around one small section where he's nude!"

All the the woman in the series: "Let's have every camera focus on tits/asses whenever they appear in a cut-scene!"

Touche, I'll concede that
 

RM8

Member
I think that's more sexualization than sexism. Framing a camera angle in a way that shows off someone's sexual assets is not inherently a bad thing nor discriminatory.
It's discriminatory if it's mostly done to a certain group of people, isn't it?
 

MMarston

Was getting caught part of your plan?
Isn't always snake, who is looking at her?
We are always looking through his eyes in those clips.

Maybe this was a Wolf of Wall St. situation where we're supposed to be amused by these characters (e.g. Snake) but slowly realize how terrible these people are upon second viewing.

Who knows lol
 
I'm aware. I'm saying that's not what happens in those scenes, her breasts are almost always visible while she's getting tortured, especially when they pour water on her. It's so exploitive and unnecessary.
The only other option is showing only her face or showing only under her breasts. Breasts are kind of in an unavoidable spot for a scene like that. The only time they're zoomed in on is when they are shocking her chest, and that's to show the area being tortured.
 
None of those are valid excuses.


That's not what happens and you know it.


Framing the camera a specific way because she's a woman is sexism. It's a form of prejudice. Sexism doesn't have to be full blown hate but I think
hope
you already know that.

I eagerly await your bad attempts to spin these and claim i'm reading far too into things.
Sjc6NrE.gif

72h96uP.gif

The trigger for the second gif is staring at her breasts for a certain amount of time, but ofc no no we're just fucking crazy and reading too into it ofc.
speaking of, that's another thing that gets said in these threads.

Those gifs make me ill.
 

nOoblet16

Member
Except she's not locked up, she can and does leave the cage whenever she wants, she only plays along because she wants to be a part of what's going on. The only reason she was put in the cage to begin with was her connection to Cypher, it had nothing to do with her being a woman.

Yet she is always in there whenever you arrive, lying there with her bikini top undone.
Even if you had just landed with her in the chopper and run to her cage immediately.

I get what you are trying to say but despite all that fact about her playing along even though she doesn't have to, her character itself is not portrayed as such. The character is portrayed as a submissive character (towards all the main characters in the game) for the most part who (unsurprisingly) falls for the majestic player character, she poses for him (even more suggestively when you stare at her breasts) and dances and showers with him while others watch and pass on comments like "What I wouldn't give.".

She is definitely not a dominant "in control" character like Bayonetta.
 

Phocks

Member
Maybe this was a Wolf of Wall St. situation where we're supposed to be amused by these characters (e.g. Snake) but slowly realize how terrible these people are upon second viewing.

Who knows lol
If it's sexist to look at an attractive female's butt I need to do some self reflection.
 

Auctopus

Member
Not defending the blatant fan-service but that walking away GIF, the player zoomed in. The actual shot isn't directed like that.
 

Sephzilla

Member
It's discriminatory if it's mostly done to a certain group of people, isn't it?

You're right, then it is. Sorry, I was thinking in a broader picture more gender-neutral mindset. In the case of Metal Gear, where they tend to overwhelmingly sexualize females over men, you're right.

I don't generally think sex or sexualization is by default a bad thing. But yes, in this case it is definitely leaning towards being a bad thing since it's definitely not weighed evenly.
 

Roufianos

Member
If I was Kojima I'd feel so awkward around Stefanie.

It would be like a girl at school looking through your notepad and finding loads of erotic sketches of herself.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom