icarus-daedelus said:He IS monotone. He does the same thing in almost every film; he occasionally dials it up (Training Day) or down (Glory) to suit the needs of the role, but by and large it's the same type of performance every time. American Gangster is a perfect example of this.
I liked him in Mighty Quinn, though. It's a guilty pleasure of mine, and one of the few films where I think he actually acted outside of his comfort zone.
He has proven on several occasions that he is not one-dimensional, it's not his fault that hollywood is unwilling to give him a role significantly different from his previous. I wont delve to far into the subject (Seems to be a sensitive subject on GAF), I'll just say he doesn't get nearly as many prime time roles as an actor of his caliber should. You're confusing his ability to act with hollywood's reluctance to give him these roles.