LIGHTNING ROUND!
Pale Flower: Well, this was a pretty fucking great noir from top to bottom. I am now looking for what other Masahiro Shinoda films I should see.
Cruel Gun Story: Decent little riff on The Killing, with good direction and a colorful cast, but you really feel the strain of having to get this past an hour long with all the stuff that feels tacked on when the big climactic shootout turns out to be not so climactic. It seems to go out of its way to make sure that every character gets something to do, even if you're not even sure that they should have been in there in the first place. I'd say two-thirds good, one third fairly bleh.
Killers on Parade: I suspect this is not particularly representative of Shinoda's other films, as it feels like a Seijun Suzuki film without any kind of semblance of structure to it. It's got a lot of neat elements in it with the shifting pool of musical numbers that take on different moods throughout the film, and you can already spot Shinoda's visual eye beginning to find a lot of fascinating architecture in otherwise mundane spots, but it never stops feeling like a patchwork of good ideas needing someone that gives a damn about putting them together in a satisfying way.
Pale Flower: Well, this was a pretty fucking great noir from top to bottom. I am now looking for what other Masahiro Shinoda films I should see.
Cruel Gun Story: Decent little riff on The Killing, with good direction and a colorful cast, but you really feel the strain of having to get this past an hour long with all the stuff that feels tacked on when the big climactic shootout turns out to be not so climactic. It seems to go out of its way to make sure that every character gets something to do, even if you're not even sure that they should have been in there in the first place. I'd say two-thirds good, one third fairly bleh.
Killers on Parade: I suspect this is not particularly representative of Shinoda's other films, as it feels like a Seijun Suzuki film without any kind of semblance of structure to it. It's got a lot of neat elements in it with the shifting pool of musical numbers that take on different moods throughout the film, and you can already spot Shinoda's visual eye beginning to find a lot of fascinating architecture in otherwise mundane spots, but it never stops feeling like a patchwork of good ideas needing someone that gives a damn about putting them together in a satisfying way.