Some of these years are impossible, haha, so I had to go two for those.
1987 - Evil Dead 2 / Full Metal Jacket
1988 - The Naked Gun: Files From The Police Squad!
1989 - Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade / Do The Right Thing
1990 - Goodfellas
1991 - JFK / Barton Fink
1992 - Unforgiven
1993 - Schindler's List
1994 - The Lion King
1995 - Heat
1996 - Fargo
1997 - Boogie Nights
1998 - The Big Lebowski / Happiness / The Thin Red Line (that's an insane year)
1999 - The Matrix
2000 - Gladiator
2001 - The Royal Tenenbaums
2002 - Minority Report
2003 - Oldboy
2004 - Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (it pains me not to say Life Aquatic, but this film means too much to me)
2005 - A History of Violence
2006 - Children of Men
2007 - There Will Be Blood
2008 - Let The Right One In
2009 - (500) Days of Summer
2010 - Scott Pilgrim vs the World
2011 - The Adventures of Tintin
2012 - Frances Ha
2013 - Blue Is The Warmest Color / Blue Ruin
2014 - Nightcrawler (I regret saying Boyhood was my #1 back in the day, Nightcrawler deserves it)
2015 - Carol
2016 - The Edge of Seventeen
2017 - Logan (so far... but we all know The Last Jedi's taking it, like come on)
...my Spielberg bias is showing.
1987 - Evil Dead 2 / Full Metal Jacket
1988 - The Naked Gun: Files From The Police Squad!
1989 - Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade / Do The Right Thing
1990 - Goodfellas
1991 - JFK / Barton Fink
1992 - Unforgiven
1993 - Schindler's List
1994 - The Lion King
1995 - Heat
1996 - Fargo
1997 - Boogie Nights
1998 - The Big Lebowski / Happiness / The Thin Red Line (that's an insane year)
1999 - The Matrix
2000 - Gladiator
2001 - The Royal Tenenbaums
2002 - Minority Report
2003 - Oldboy
2004 - Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (it pains me not to say Life Aquatic, but this film means too much to me)
2005 - A History of Violence
2006 - Children of Men
2007 - There Will Be Blood
2008 - Let The Right One In
2009 - (500) Days of Summer
2010 - Scott Pilgrim vs the World
2011 - The Adventures of Tintin
2012 - Frances Ha
2013 - Blue Is The Warmest Color / Blue Ruin
2014 - Nightcrawler (I regret saying Boyhood was my #1 back in the day, Nightcrawler deserves it)
2015 - Carol
2016 - The Edge of Seventeen
2017 - Logan (so far... but we all know The Last Jedi's taking it, like come on)
...my Spielberg bias is showing.