EAD Tokyo and Retro easily got the most shit for their reveals. Both are two of Nintendo's greatest studios, but 3D World in particular is the one I don't get the backlash on. It's beautiful, it looks fun, and its a legit achievement to make a 2-player 3D platformer... let alone a 4-player one.
It just always screamed "Big time game coming soon!" Tropical Freeze on the other hand is not as pretty as I'd expect a new DKC to be from them, on such powerful hardware. And it wasn't the tone I expected of the title Retro had been working on for three years. I get the TF backlash. But 3D World looks beautiful, fun, and it's from EAD Tokyo.
What's funny is that I suspect the group that didn't want another Galaxy game(can't figure how that series has already run its course) are now saying they wish EAD Tokyo's new game was another Galaxy.
When a developer is THAT good like Retro and especially EAD Tokyo, I roll with whatever they are making next and feel lucky that I'll get to play another title by them.
Disappointment is fine but a lot of it seems disrespectful in tone to some of the best developers on the planet.
I went back and replayed Super Mario 3D Land, a game I really liked but didn't love and the game is once again an impeccably designed game by that group and a better one is not something I could even be disappointed with.
Upon first sight, I have to admit I was surprised that was their game and their only new game but I got over it really fast as it looks top quality.
I'm looking for substance first, flash is a bonus.
New mechanics like the ability to climb(scares me a bit) and the clear tubes makes me really hyped for the game as it looks to me like a better 3D Land.
That might not be good enough for some but it is for me.