Support NeoGAF

[Andodalf]

Mojang has devkits and probaby retail units at this stage.

Yep! Funny to think about that, as well as how Sony San Deigo probably has XSX for next years MLB the Show!

 

[Croatoan]

Certain people in this thread cannot take a joke.

Game Console Warz are serious business folks.

 

[SaucyJack]

I just beat TLOU2 with my Pro fan running so loud i literally couldnt hear the dialogue without turning it all the way up. even if i could hear the dialogue, the noise was basically a third person in the room screaming while im watching these intense scenes unfold.

at this point, its not something i would even joke about lol. its infuriating. sick burn though. of course, sony can reply back with 'what games?' and it would be an even sicker burn but i digress.

I've got a Pro and a normal PS4 and I can only stand to play TLOU2 on the Pro for the same reason, fan on standard PS4 is the loudest of any game I've played. Barely a murmur from it on the Pro though

 

[OmegaSpear]

I have an OG PS4, no sound complaints from me. Must be an issue with some consoles. I however must say that the joke isn't funny.

 

[vaibhavpisal]

He wasn’t running Xbox then.

He was senior level executive back then as well. Was well interviewed if I remember correctly. Just wasn't head of xbox.

 

[Dargor]

So why make a "noisy PS4" joke now? The PS5 is months away from being released.

My guess would be he is trying to hype his product up and get some space under the sun back from sony. The attention is all on playstation since they got a good press reveal of the console and their biggest game released shortly after.

 

[Valentino]

Why does my console never make a noise
Like ever. Does this get exaggerated? If my machine started sounding loud trying to run a game, I’d just allow It. If the game is humungous then it’s something I’d just look past. Most of you got your sticky headphones on anyway

 

[Dibils2k]

he is not wrong, i literally have to turn up my audio way too loud to hear dialogue. one of the reasons i am waiting for PS5 to play TLOU2



this was 2 years ago too, i swear its even worse when it gets to full swing

i refuse to believe there is a quiet PS4 Pro in the world (after atleast 1-2 year use), and if there is plz make a video playing God Of War or Horizon Zero Dawn and prove it, for my sanity

 

[Chumpion]

I guess most gamers don't care about noise that much, or maybe they live in a loud home. Myself, I can't stand it.

I couldn't put a noisebox in my living room. Especially after spending so much time and money optimizing my sound system. So I'm waiting nervously how the cooling situation shakes out.

 

[sircaw]

I do get the joke, its not bad but i feel its targeted at the wrong generation. Last generation would probably of worked better.

If the ps5 turns out to be whisper quite, i suspect that comment might come back in a few memes.

The first one i can think of the top of my head is, Its loud cos its playing a GAME Phil.

 

[OmegaSpear]

he is not wrong, i literally have to turn up my audio way too loud to hear dialogue. one of the reasons i am waiting for PS5 to play TLOU2

Wow, didn't know the PS4 Pro was so loud. It must break immersion.

 

[cormack12]

He must’ve forgotten what his Xbox 360 sounded like, then

Was the 360 loud? I can't really remember, I think the disc drive might have been loud - and the seperate brick had a buzz/hum if you were close.

This is such a weird shot to take at "THIS" point. He should have used this joke when the Xbox One X came out.

TBH it's the perfect time. Sony just dropping two IP's that are likely to sell like hot cakes and you get responses like this:

I just beat TLOU2 with my Pro fan running so loud i literally couldnt hear the dialogue without turning it all the way up. even if i could hear the dialogue, the noise was basically a third person in the room screaming while im watching these intense scenes unfold.

I'm expecting the same in GoT as well to be honest but hoping Sucker Punch have managed some magic. There's going to be a lot of Playstation owners playing these new games and becoming annoyed by it. I'm gonna try GoT on the Pro Slim and see if it makes much of a difference. Not even trying the OG Pro.

 

[SaucyJack]

So much easier to argue against a strawman

 

[sinnergy]

Phil needs to learn xbox will never surpass playstation. He’s becoming more unlikeable.

It’s totally not like the DRM joke from Sony come on let people have some fun.

 

[splattered]

Weird how certain people in this thread seem offended "Not funny!" or "No games!"

Really people? It was a joke...

Either that or it's possible he's already had some hands on with dev/retail kit for PS5 and yeah they're still noisey.

Would noise really be a deal breaker for any of you? You know you're still going to buy it anyway.

 

[LokusAbriss]

He must’ve forgotten what his Xbox 360 sounded like, then

Compared to my fat jet-fan PS3, my Xbox 360 made zero noise, after experiencing the read ring of death.

A noisy console is unacceptable. It was great, when the 360 was finally updated for game installation.

The one x raises the fan sometimes. I had it in Metro Exodus. But that is no comparison to a loud PS3 or PS4.

 

[Flashy Wizard]

Phil and the team must truly have something spectacular lined up for him to release such a sick burn. If there was ever a bear in the games industry that you wouldn’t want to poke with a stick, Sony would definitely be that bear.....unless you have a trick up your sleeve (such as bear spray )

 

[Andodalf]

Phil and the team must truly have something spectacular lined up for him to release such a sick burn. If there was ever a bear in the games industry that you wouldn’t want to poke with a stick, Sony would definitely be that bear.....unless you have a trick up your sleeve (such as bear spray )

They have at least one AAA game for launch that isn’t going to be compared to expansions by company execs

 

[turtlepowa]

Phil and the team must truly have something spectacular lined up for him to release such a sick burn. If there was ever a bear in the games industry that you wouldn’t want to poke with a stick, Sony would definitely be that bear.....unless you have a trick up your sleeve (such as bear spray )

Asian bears are not that big or terrifying

 

[Daring7]

Was the 360 loud?

Can’t speak for everyone, but the two I had were pretty loud, almost jet like during most games and that annoying whine when it was just sitting there.

PS4 is louder for me during the OS in game, and certain beefy games. My One X died, and came back a lot louder after repair. But I use headphones, so the noise never really bothers me.

 

[IntentionalPun]

I just don't care either way about the PR machines behind these companies.

Gimme the products and games.

 

[Mattyp]

Well, PS4's turbine outsold XBOne 3:1 more or less. I guess he wont comment on that.

If they stopped taking off and flying away the numbers might not be as high.

 

[MrS]

People are looking in to this way too much. I don't even think he was slating PS4. What grounds does he really have to slate PS4 when Xbox gaming division has been so bad this gen? I don't think there was any ill intent on Phil's part, and I'm somebody who would be the first to call him a cunt if I thought there was.

 

[Dnice1]

People need to see the entire interview. Phil was asked about the acoustics of the consoles. He didn't just make that comment out thin air.

 

[Great Hair]

It's a dig at the PS4.

A noisy PS4 or a Xbox 360, Xbone (X) that scatches discs or has a 55% failure rate or is equally noisy? Phil must be suffering from amnesia.

 

[mejin]

Shots fired from an angle it won't reach the aim.

 

[Hendrick's]

I don't think this was an intentional joke.

 

[NullZ3r0]

The PS5 design is very loud.

 

[SaucyJack]

People need to see the entire interview. Phil was asked about the acoustics of the consoles. He didn't just make that comment out thin air.

That's useful context. In that case he is absolutely right to say that.

 

[NullZ3r0]

Phil needs to learn xbox will never surpass playstation. He’s becoming more unlikeable.

It almost did even with a clueless idiot like Don Mattrick running the show.

They definitely can beat Sony with a faster console and 15 inhouse studios pumping out AAA hits.

 

[JimboJones]

Can’t speak for everyone, but the two I had were pretty loud, almost jet like during most games and that annoying whine when it was just sitting there.

PS4 is louder for me during the OS in game, and certain beefy games. My One X died, and came back a lot louder after repair. But I use headphones, so the noise never really bothers me.

Yeah two I had and my friends where loud, installation helped a bit but the fans where still pretty bad.
Didn't mind back then but I do notice now, makes you reluctant to use old 360 hardware. Luckily BC exists.

 

[DeepEnigma]

People need to see the entire interview. Phil was asked about the acoustics of the consoles. He didn't just make that comment out thin air.

That makes so much more sense.

 

[REE Machine]

It's a dig at the PS4.

The hottest settling console this gen, uncle phil dont punch up, makes you look dumb.

 

[GymWolf]

Oh shit, phil with dat juvenile zinger to ps4

 

[SlimySnake]

Doesn't matter if the Xbox series x supposedly has games, the Xbox one didn't. Just like how the ps5 is supposedly quiet, and the ps4 wasnt which is what hes taking a dig at.

the xbox one had arguably the most pathetic line up of games of any gen ever. even the original xbox one which was only in the market for 4 years had a better lineup. titanfall and sunset overdrive were the last two truly great games on the platform and they came out 6 years ago.

 

[pr0cs]

Pretty good dig, considering how terrible the fan noise is with the PS4. Hopefully they fixed their shit with the PS5

 

[Deleted member 775630]

Doesn't matter if the Xbox series x supposedly has games, the Xbox one didn't. Just like how the ps5 is supposedly quiet, and the ps4 wasnt which is what hes taking a dig at.

the xbox one had arguably the most pathetic line up of games of any gen ever. even the original xbox one which was only in the market for 4 years had a better lineup. titanfall and sunset overdrive were the last two truly great games on the platform and they came out 6 years ago.

Why do people keep saying this? Compared to Sony? Yeah, PS had the better line up of games. Did Xbox have no games? Don't be silly. Ori, Gears, Forza Horizon.

 

[Fart Knight]

 

[MiguelItUp]

What... now? Going forward?

This was my reaction. I mean, maybe they have a lot of exclusives loaded, I'd certainly hope so. Cause right now all we're seeing is Halo and nothing else. :|

 

[Tulipanzo]

Then why have they showed their console over 7 months before their games...

 

[LostDonkey]

he is not wrong, i literally have to turn up my audio way too loud to hear dialogue. one of the reasons i am waiting for PS5 to play TLOU2



this was 2 years ago too, i swear its even worse when it gets to full swing

i refuse to believe there is a quiet PS4 Pro in the world (after atleast 1-2 year use), and if there is plz make a video playing God Of War or Horizon Zero Dawn and prove it, for my sanity

Mine never sounds that loud. I barely ever hear it. That's insane. I'd say that's faulty.

 

[SlimySnake]

Why do people keep saying this? Compared to Sony? Yeah, PS had the better line up of games. Did Xbox have no games? Don't be silly. Ori, Gears, Forza Horizon.

its referring to the quality of games. its not meant to be taken literally.

xbox does release 2-3 exceedingly mediocre games every year. i dont think thats anything to write home about though.

 

[HeisenbergFX4]

Funny how recently my launch day Scorpio has been getting quite loud under heavy load though nothing like what TLOU2 did to my Pro.

 

[LazyParrot]

That only works if there are games people want to play, Phil. My PS4 might not be the quietest console out there, but at least it has games I actually care about.

 

[SleepDoctor]

Some people really get all upset over an executive taking a dig at its competitor. Shows who really takes this plastic war seriously lol.

This is a good move imo. You have to start some kind of of controversy, it sells. And obviously its what the brand needs. Can't just be all smiles and small talk.

 

[Jesb]

Do people not own surround sound systems of headphones?

 

[NullZ3r0]

Phil was talking aesthetics, not the actual decibel levels of the machine.

 

[Venom Snake]

Yeah, i would like to SEE your games first

 

[SoloKingRobert]

If you get a PS5, you'll probably need to insure your property before turning it on

 

[Ogbert]

All joking aside, my PS4 pro is borderline ridiculous playing TLOU2. I've had to adjust all the audio settings so only the voices can be heard, as I'm having to turn up the volume to drown out the fans.