• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Phil Spencer comments on Silent Hills rumor: 'not true'

He's joking obviously but I think David Jaffe did it with Twisted Metal right? Not familiar with any other instances as blatant as that one.

Did he? I could have sworn the hints on the Twisted Metal Head-On edition for the PS2 gave it away, plus I thought Jaffe confirmed a PS3 Twisted Metal was in the works after the clues were found.
 
The follow up IGN article contains not a single hint of responsibility, let alone apology. In fact it doesn't even reference the previous article except as a link.

http://www.ign.com/articles/2015/05...crosoft-purchase-of-silent-hills-for-xbox-one

Yesterday, an anonymous claimed Microsoft was in talks to purchase the rights to Silent Hills for “billions” of dollars by this year’s E3 and the game was 80% complete, with a release date of March 2016 for Xbox One.

Nice to see IGN reports on "an anonymous" since that is such a reliable source.
 
I really wanted Silent Hills to happen and if someone saved it, I'd be thrilled, wouldn't matter if it was Microsoft or Sony (provided Kojima and Del Toro were still on it) but I knew if was fake and it hurts as a Silent Hill fan to lose hope like that. Such a shame that Konami gets to hold that franchise hostage.
 
Why bother to address such a weak rumor?

Because E3 is coming and people's expectations will only get higher on that possibility. Only to be let down.

And the game won't happen. Even if the IP were let go, there is still the issue of Del Toro, Kojima, and what's his face getting together again.
 
Did he? I could have sworn the hints on the Twisted Metal Head-On edition for the PS2 gave it away, plus I thought Jaffe confirmed a PS3 Twisted Metal was in the works after the clues were found.

Yeah, I believe it was just before E3 that he flat out said they aren't working on Twisted Metal. Sure enough at Sony's conference that year they announced Twisted Metal lol.
 
I got junior'd for posting this news that I assumed had a chance at legitimacy since it was on IGN. I want an apology from them
I think we all deserve one. Lesson learned I suppose, keep your nose clean and maybe you'll get member status again some day.

I've heard of Machinima, but not Red Vs Blue. I have to admit that i dont really follow many gaming channels on Youtube, assuming that they are on Youtube.
It's a comedy series in which red and blue Halo men talk funny and make jokes at one another. Rooster Teeth never should have been referenced by IGN or anyone else as a credible or journalistic entity.
 
The rumor was a ridiculous fanboy's wet dream, and it's even more ridiculous that some sites reported it as real. I'm personally glad there's no chance, that Silent Hills would become ammunition in a console war, as it deserves better. Just like its longtime fans, who actually played PT.
 
I'd take this with a grain of salt but this looks like a leaked confirmation that Microsoft isn't buying Silent Hills.
Looks legit if you ask me. Someone make a thread pls.

R6L8TpF.jpg

Man, the logos on the bottom...

Holy shit, well done.
 
The rumor was a ridiculous fanboy's wet dream, and it's even more ridiculous that some sites reported it as real. I'm personally glad there's no chance, that Silent Hills would become ammunition in a console war, as it deserves better. Just like its longtime fans, who actually played PT.

masterful underhand trolling tbh, 10/10
 
Kudos to Phil for debunking the rumor pretty quickly, although it was obvious it was fake. I don't know why everyone felt the need to comment on such an outlandish rumor and give it 5+ page threads.
 
Damn as much as I wouldn't want SH to be a Xbox One exclusive, its better than not having the game at all. Sucks that its not true tbh.
 
Better as in not released at all ;-)

Well, I don't see how it's better for the PT players who'd have to get another system for it. Kinda like it would have been the same whether REmake was done or not at the time, as it took 13 years for many to get to play the game.
 
lol at them all getting junior slapped

Add me to that list. I saw the title of the video, went "huh, thats interesting". Didn't get to the part where the deal was in the billions before I posted it.

I am a dumbass. I deserved this slap.

I am going to carve "watch the entire video before posting anything" in my skin now
 
Top Bottom